|
The Perfect Draft - 12 Teams
|
|
Posted 8/12 by David Dodds, Exclusive to Footballguys.com
|
Note: This is the first of a 5 part series. This article covers a 12 team draft. The other articles will cover 10 teams, 14 teams, WCOFF scoring and how to apply this to an auction draft. I expect to have all of these versions done before Monday, August 15th.
Aaaah....The Perfect Draft. We have all dreamt of having it. Some of us have experienced it. And for those that have....we want it again and again. And why not? You surely did not subscribe to this website to be average. You want to dominate. You want to have such a good roster that others salivate over who you have. You want them all to come to you when discussing trades. And in this article I am going to break down how to have that perfect draft.
Let's start with the two basic principles of Value Based Drafting (VBD). I will expound on them as we go through this.
ALL PLAYERS HAVE VALUE
Don't love anyone. Don't hate anyone. Get players that will significantly outperform their value and you will build a winning team.
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE AVERAGE GUY THINKS
It is this opinion that allows one to maximize draft value round after round. You may believe someone will be the 4th best WR, but if everybody else does not then you need to wait and maximize value.
If you don't follow these principles, you will not have a perfect draft. If you...believe rookie WRs are always bad...that you should always avoid players after ACL injuries...that drafting anyone over 30 is a sure sign he will get injured, etc then you will not have the perfect draft. Throw away the biases. Let value guide your team. Let others succumb to prejudices and generalities. You are here to win your league. And you do that by getting value every single round.
So what is value then? Value Based Drafting (VBD) has shown us that we can compare unlike positions for comparative value. Let this be our guide. The cornerstone of VBD starts with solid projections. And these projections can be manipulated to form Top 200+ lists. I have provided my own Top 200+ list here (based on my projections) that has been sorted by position. I have highlighted favorable differences in green to indicate players that may be bargains on draft day.
| Rank |
ADP |
Diff |
Pos |
# |
Player |
Team/Bye |
| 6 |
4 |
-2 |
QB |
1 |
Peyton Manning |
Ind/8 |
| 17 |
17 |
0 |
QB |
2 |
Daunte Culpepper |
Min/5 |
| 30 |
27 |
-3 |
QB |
3 |
Donovan McNabb |
Phi/6 |
| 41 |
42 |
1 |
QB |
4 |
Marc Bulger |
StL/9 |
| 48 |
56 |
8 |
QB |
5 |
Kerry Collins |
Oak/5 |
| 52 |
59 |
7 |
QB |
6 |
Michael Vick |
Atl/8 |
| 59 |
81 |
22 |
QB |
7 |
Jake Plummer |
Den/9 |
| 65 |
51 |
-14 |
QB |
8 |
Trent Green |
KC/5 |
| 68 |
84 |
16 |
QB |
9 |
Aaron Brooks |
NO/10 |
| 75 |
66 |
-9 |
QB |
10 |
Brett Favre |
GB/6 |
| 81 |
77 |
-4 |
QB |
11 |
Tom Brady |
NE/7 |
| 86 |
75 |
-11 |
QB |
12 |
Matt Hasselbeck |
Sea/8 |
| 89 |
78 |
-11 |
QB |
13 |
Carson Palmer |
Cin/10 |
| 92 |
89 |
-3 |
QB |
14 |
Drew Brees |
SD/10 |
| 95 |
120 |
25 |
QB |
15 |
Steve McNair |
Ten/10 |
| 97 |
97 |
0 |
QB |
16 |
Jake Delhomme |
Car/7 |
| 104 |
108 |
4 |
QB |
17 |
David Carr |
Hou/3 |
| 108 |
103 |
-5 |
QB |
18 |
Byron Leftwich |
Jac/7 |
| 113 |
104 |
-9 |
QB |
19 |
Chad Pennington |
NYJ/8 |
| 119 |
123 |
4 |
QB |
20 |
Ben Roethlisberger |
Pit/4 |
| 123 |
119 |
-4 |
QB |
21 |
Brian Griese |
TB/7 |
| 129 |
132 |
3 |
QB |
22 |
Joey Harrington |
Det/3 |
| 134 |
149 |
15 |
QB |
23 |
Kyle Boller |
Bal/3 |
| 140 |
138 |
-2 |
QB |
24 |
Eli Manning |
NYG/5 |
| 148 |
208 |
60 |
QB |
25 |
Patrick Ramsey |
Was/3 |
| 153 |
180 |
27 |
QB |
26 |
Alex Smith |
SF/6 |
| 160 |
206 |
46 |
QB |
27 |
Rex Grossman |
Chi/4 |
| 169 |
135 |
-34 |
QB |
28 |
Kurt Warner |
Ari/6 |
| 181 |
166 |
-15 |
QB |
29 |
J.P. Losman |
Buf/9 |
| 190 |
160 |
-30 |
QB |
30 |
Drew Bledsoe |
Dal/9 |
| 199 |
229 |
30 |
QB |
31 |
Trent Dilfer |
Cle/4 |
| 206 |
250 |
44 |
QB |
32 |
Gus Frerotte |
Mia/4 |
| 214 |
195 |
-19 |
QB |
33 |
Jeff Garcia |
Det/3 |
| 219 |
250 |
31 |
QB |
34 |
Josh McCown |
Ari/6 |
| 226 |
250 |
24 |
QB |
35 |
A.J. Feeley |
Mia/4 |
| 232 |
201 |
-31 |
QB |
36 |
Billy Volek |
Ten/10 |
| 238 |
250 |
12 |
QB |
37 |
Matt Schaub |
Atl/8 |
| 240 |
250 |
10 |
QB |
38 |
Brad Johnson |
Min/5 |
| 247 |
250 |
3 |
QB |
39 |
Kelly Holcomb |
Buf/9 |
| 253 |
220 |
-33 |
QB |
40 |
Philip Rivers |
SD/10 |
| 258 |
250 |
-8 |
QB |
41 |
Jamie Martin |
StL/9 |
| 264 |
250 |
-14 |
QB |
42 |
Jon Kitna |
Cin/10 |
| 275 |
250 |
-25 |
QB |
43 |
Tim Rattay |
SF/6 |
| 285 |
250 |
-35 |
QB |
44 |
Tommy Maddox |
Pit/4 |
| 297 |
250 |
-47 |
QB |
45 |
Marques Tuiasosopo |
Oak/5 |
| 307 |
250 |
-57 |
QB |
46 |
Doug Johnson |
Cle/4 |
| 1 |
1 |
0 |
RB |
1 |
LaDainian Tomlinson |
SD/10 |
| 2 |
3 |
1 |
RB |
2 |
Priest Holmes |
KC/5 |
| 3 |
2 |
-1 |
RB |
3 |
Shaun Alexander |
Sea/8 |
| 4 |
7 |
3 |
RB |
4 |
Deuce McAllister |
NO/10 |
| 5 |
5 |
0 |
RB |
5 |
Edgerrin James |
Ind/8 |
| 7 |
11 |
4 |
RB |
6 |
Domanick Davis |
Hou/3 |
| 8 |
8 |
0 |
RB |
7 |
Clinton Portis |
Was/3 |
| 9 |
15 |
6 |
RB |
8 |
Tiki Barber |
NYG/5 |
| 10 |
6 |
-4 |
RB |
9 |
Willis McGahee |
Buf/9 |
| 11 |
12 |
1 |
RB |
10 |
Corey Dillon |
NE/7 |
| 13 |
25 |
12 |
RB |
11 |
Brian Westbrook |
Phi/6 |
| 14 |
14 |
0 |
RB |
12 |
Kevin Jones |
Det/3 |
| 15 |
13 |
-2 |
RB |
13 |
Julius Jones |
Dal/9 |
| 16 |
24 |
8 |
RB |
14 |
Curtis Martin |
NYJ/8 |
| 18 |
19 |
1 |
RB |
15 |
Rudi Johnson |
Cin/10 |
| 21 |
9 |
-12 |
RB |
16 |
Jamal Lewis |
Bal/3 |
| 24 |
22 |
-2 |
RB |
17 |
Steven Jackson |
StL/9 |
| 25 |
16 |
-9 |
RB |
18 |
Ahman Green |
GB/6 |
| 29 |
44 |
15 |
RB |
19 |
J.J. Arrington |
Ari/6 |
| 33 |
26 |
-7 |
RB |
20 |
Lamont Jordan |
Oak/5 |
| 36 |
29 |
-7 |
RB |
21 |
Tatum Bell |
Den/9 |
| 38 |
45 |
7 |
RB |
22 |
Michael Bennett |
Min/5 |
| 42 |
46 |
4 |
RB |
23 |
Warrick Dunn |
Atl/8 |
| 43 |
39 |
-4 |
RB |
24 |
Carnell Williams |
TB/7 |
| 51 |
95 |
44 |
RB |
25 |
Thomas Jones |
Chi/4 |
| 54 |
34 |
-20 |
RB |
26 |
Chris Brown |
Ten/10 |
| 55 |
60 |
5 |
RB |
27 |
Kevan Barlow |
SF/6 |
| 57 |
53 |
-4 |
RB |
28 |
DeShaun Foster |
Car/7 |
| 58 |
58 |
0 |
RB |
29 |
Fred Taylor |
Jac/7 |
| 63 |
61 |
-2 |
RB |
30 |
Larry Johnson |
KC/5 |
| 70 |
102 |
32 |
RB |
31 |
Jerome Bettis |
Pit/4 |
| 74 |
67 |
-7 |
RB |
32 |
Lee Suggs |
Cle/4 |
| 77 |
38 |
-39 |
RB |
33 |
Ronnie Brown |
Mia/4 |
| 82 |
91 |
9 |
RB |
34 |
T.J. Duckett |
Atl/8 |
| 85 |
48 |
-37 |
RB |
35 |
Cedric Benson |
Chi/4 |
| 91 |
94 |
3 |
RB |
36 |
Reuben Droughns |
Cle/4 |
| 99 |
55 |
-44 |
RB |
37 |
Duce Staley |
Pit/4 |
| 105 |
174 |
69 |
RB |
38 |
Mike Anderson |
Den/9 |
| 107 |
140 |
33 |
RB |
39 |
LaBrandon Toefield |
Jac/7 |
| 112 |
112 |
0 |
RB |
40 |
Michael Pittman |
TB/7 |
| 117 |
96 |
-21 |
RB |
41 |
Marshall Faulk |
StL/9 |
| 124 |
128 |
4 |
RB |
42 |
Eric Shelton |
Car/7 |
| 131 |
202 |
71 |
RB |
43 |
Kevin Faulk |
NE/7 |
| 136 |
110 |
-26 |
RB |
44 |
Ricky Williams |
Mia/4 |
| 142 |
136 |
-6 |
RB |
45 |
Derrick Blaylock |
NYJ/8 |
| 149 |
82 |
-67 |
RB |
46 |
Travis Henry |
Ten/10 |
| 158 |
175 |
17 |
RB |
47 |
Chester Taylor |
Bal/3 |
| 165 |
161 |
-4 |
RB |
48 |
Najeh Davenport |
GB/6 |
| 170 |
130 |
-40 |
RB |
49 |
Correll Buckhalter |
Phi/6 |
| 184 |
212 |
28 |
RB |
50 |
Moe Williams |
Min/5 |
| 189 |
250 |
61 |
RB |
51 |
Tony Fisher |
GB/6 |
| 194 |
250 |
56 |
RB |
52 |
Zack Crockett |
Oak/5 |
| 200 |
250 |
50 |
RB |
53 |
Shawn Bryson |
Det/3 |
| 203 |
250 |
47 |
RB |
54 |
Verron Haynes |
Pit/4 |
| 208 |
250 |
42 |
RB |
55 |
Ladell Betts |
Was/3 |
| 215 |
185 |
-30 |
RB |
56 |
Anthony Thomas |
Dal/9 |
| 220 |
224 |
4 |
RB |
57 |
Mike Alstott |
TB/7 |
| 227 |
173 |
-54 |
RB |
58 |
Dominic Rhodes |
Ind/8 |
| 233 |
191 |
-42 |
RB |
59 |
Brandon Jacobs |
NYG/5 |
| 241 |
137 |
-104 |
RB |
60 |
Frank Gore |
SF/6 |
| 244 |
250 |
6 |
RB |
61 |
Alvin Pearman |
Jac/7 |
| 249 |
215 |
-34 |
RB |
62 |
Chris Perry |
Cin/10 |
| 251 |
118 |
-133 |
RB |
63 |
Stephen Davis |
Car/7 |
| 255 |
250 |
-5 |
RB |
64 |
Shaud Williams |
Buf/9 |
| 259 |
250 |
-9 |
RB |
65 |
Lamar Gordon |
Mia/4 |
| 262 |
106 |
-156 |
RB |
66 |
Mewelde Moore |
Min/5 |
| 267 |
250 |
-17 |
RB |
67 |
Jonathan Wells |
Hou/3 |
| 270 |
199 |
-71 |
RB |
68 |
Ryan Moats |
Phi/6 |
| 276 |
222 |
-54 |
RB |
69 |
Antowain Smith |
NO/10 |
| 280 |
172 |
-108 |
RB |
70 |
Maurice Morris |
Sea/8 |
| 286 |
250 |
-36 |
RB |
71 |
Greg Jones |
Jac/7 |
| 292 |
250 |
-42 |
RB |
72 |
Justin Fargas |
Oak/5 |
| 298 |
204 |
-94 |
RB |
73 |
Vernand Morency |
Hou/3 |
| 303 |
167 |
-136 |
RB |
74 |
Ciatrick Fason |
Min/5 |
| 308 |
139 |
-169 |
RB |
75 |
Marcel Shipp |
Ari/6 |
| 115 |
131 |
16 |
PK |
1 |
Mike Vanderjagt |
Ind/8 |
| 122 |
117 |
-5 |
PK |
2 |
Adam Vinatieri |
NE/7 |
| 130 |
141 |
11 |
PK |
3 |
Jason Elam |
Den/9 |
| 138 |
126 |
-12 |
PK |
4 |
David Akers |
Phi/6 |
| 147 |
165 |
18 |
PK |
5 |
Matt Stover |
Bal/3 |
| 156 |
152 |
-4 |
PK |
6 |
Sebastian Janikowski |
Oak/5 |
| 162 |
179 |
17 |
PK |
7 |
Ryan Longwell |
GB/6 |
| 166 |
163 |
-3 |
PK |
8 |
Jeff Wilkins |
StL/9 |
| 168 |
198 |
30 |
PK |
9 |
Josh Brown |
Sea/8 |
| 173 |
194 |
21 |
PK |
10 |
Jeff Reed |
Pit/4 |
| 176 |
183 |
7 |
PK |
11 |
Mike Nugent |
NYJ/8 |
| 178 |
184 |
6 |
PK |
12 |
Shayne Graham |
Cin/10 |
| 185 |
213 |
28 |
PK |
13 |
John Kasay |
Car/7 |
| 193 |
219 |
26 |
PK |
14 |
Jason Hanson |
Det/3 |
| 198 |
193 |
-5 |
PK |
15 |
Nate Kaeding |
SD/10 |
| 202 |
205 |
3 |
PK |
16 |
Lawrence Tynes |
KC/5 |
| 207 |
250 |
43 |
PK |
17 |
Josh Scobee |
Jac/7 |
| 213 |
216 |
3 |
PK |
18 |
John Carney |
NO/10 |
| 218 |
250 |
32 |
PK |
19 |
Ryan Lindell |
Buf/9 |
| 225 |
250 |
25 |
PK |
20 |
Billy Cundiff |
Dal/9 |
| 231 |
250 |
19 |
PK |
21 |
Rob Bironas |
Ten/10 |
| 237 |
221 |
-16 |
PK |
22 |
Phil Dawson |
Cle/4 |
| 246 |
230 |
-16 |
PK |
23 |
Neil Rackers |
Ari/6 |
| 257 |
227 |
-30 |
PK |
24 |
Jay Feely |
NYG/5 |
| 269 |
250 |
-19 |
PK |
25 |
Matt Bryant |
TB/7 |
| 274 |
250 |
-24 |
PK |
26 |
Aaron Elling |
Min/5 |
| 279 |
250 |
-29 |
PK |
27 |
John Hall |
Was/3 |
| 284 |
250 |
-34 |
PK |
28 |
Doug Brien |
Chi/4 |
| 291 |
250 |
-41 |
PK |
29 |
Joe Nedney |
SF/6 |
| 296 |
250 |
-46 |
PK |
30 |
Olindo Mare |
Mia/4 |
| 302 |
250 |
-52 |
PK |
31 |
Todd Peterson |
Atl/8 |
| 306 |
250 |
-56 |
PK |
32 |
Kris Brown |
Hou/3 |
| |
| Rank |
ADP |
Diff |
Pos |
# |
Player |
Team/Bye |
| 27 |
30 |
3 |
TE |
1 |
Tony Gonzalez |
KC/5 |
| 34 |
32 |
-2 |
TE |
2 |
Antonio Gates |
SD/10 |
| 49 |
52 |
3 |
TE |
3 |
Jason Witten |
Dal/9 |
| 64 |
69 |
5 |
TE |
4 |
Jeremy Shockey |
NYG/5 |
| 78 |
68 |
-10 |
TE |
5 |
Alge Crumpler |
Atl/8 |
| 83 |
83 |
0 |
TE |
6 |
Dallas Clark |
Ind/8 |
| 98 |
64 |
-34 |
TE |
7 |
Todd Heap |
Bal/3 |
| 100 |
105 |
5 |
TE |
8 |
Eric Johnson |
SF/6 |
| 110 |
113 |
3 |
TE |
9 |
L.J. Smith |
Phi/6 |
| 118 |
142 |
24 |
TE |
10 |
Jeb Putzier |
Den/9 |
| 126 |
85 |
-41 |
TE |
11 |
Randy McMichael |
Mia/4 |
| 132 |
156 |
24 |
TE |
12 |
Chris Cooley |
Was/3 |
| 139 |
209 |
70 |
TE |
13 |
Jerramy Stevens |
Sea/8 |
| 144 |
159 |
15 |
TE |
14 |
Marcus Pollard |
Det/3 |
| 150 |
177 |
27 |
TE |
15 |
Ben Troupe |
Ten/10 |
| 154 |
250 |
96 |
TE |
16 |
Erron Kinney |
Ten/10 |
| 159 |
158 |
-1 |
TE |
17 |
Bubba Franks |
GB/6 |
| 163 |
153 |
-10 |
TE |
18 |
Daniel Graham |
NE/7 |
| 172 |
111 |
-61 |
TE |
19 |
Jermaine Wiggins |
Min/5 |
| 180 |
250 |
70 |
TE |
20 |
Steve Heiden |
Cle/4 |
| 186 |
250 |
64 |
TE |
21 |
Mike Seidman |
Car/7 |
| 188 |
168 |
-20 |
TE |
22 |
Doug Jolley |
NYJ/8 |
| 195 |
150 |
-45 |
TE |
23 |
Heath Miller |
Pit/4 |
| 201 |
250 |
49 |
TE |
24 |
Courtney Anderson |
Oak/5 |
| 211 |
250 |
39 |
TE |
25 |
Mark Campbell |
Buf/9 |
| 221 |
189 |
-32 |
TE |
26 |
Ben Watson |
NE/7 |
| 228 |
250 |
22 |
TE |
27 |
Alex Smith |
TB/7 |
| 234 |
250 |
16 |
TE |
28 |
Jim Kleinsasser |
Min/5 |
| 243 |
250 |
7 |
TE |
29 |
Kris Wilson |
KC/5 |
| 248 |
250 |
2 |
TE |
30 |
Aaron Shea |
Cle/4 |
| 254 |
250 |
-4 |
TE |
31 |
George Wrighster |
Jac/7 |
| 260 |
250 |
-10 |
TE |
32 |
Matt Schobel |
Cin/10 |
| 265 |
250 |
-15 |
TE |
33 |
Kyle Brady |
Jac/7 |
| 271 |
250 |
-21 |
TE |
34 |
Billy Miller |
Hou/3 |
| 277 |
250 |
-27 |
TE |
35 |
Roland Williams |
StL/9 |
| 281 |
250 |
-31 |
TE |
36 |
Itula Mili |
Sea/8 |
| 287 |
250 |
-37 |
TE |
37 |
Anthony Becht |
TB/7 |
| 293 |
211 |
-82 |
TE |
38 |
Boo Williams |
NO/10 |
| 299 |
250 |
-49 |
TE |
39 |
Dustin Lyman |
Chi/4 |
| 309 |
250 |
-59 |
TE |
40 |
Ben Hartsock |
Ind/8 |
| 12 |
10 |
-2 |
WR |
1 |
Randy Moss |
Oak/5 |
| 19 |
18 |
-1 |
WR |
2 |
Terrell Owens |
Phi/6 |
| 20 |
21 |
1 |
WR |
3 |
Torry Holt |
StL/9 |
| 22 |
23 |
1 |
WR |
4 |
Chad Johnson |
Cin/10 |
| 23 |
20 |
-3 |
WR |
5 |
Marvin Harrison |
Ind/8 |
| 26 |
35 |
9 |
WR |
6 |
Reggie Wayne |
Ind/8 |
| 28 |
31 |
3 |
WR |
7 |
Joe Horn |
NO/10 |
| 31 |
28 |
-3 |
WR |
8 |
Javon Walker |
GB/6 |
| 32 |
37 |
5 |
WR |
9 |
Darrell Jackson |
Sea/8 |
| 35 |
33 |
-2 |
WR |
10 |
Andre Johnson |
Hou/3 |
| 37 |
50 |
13 |
WR |
11 |
Drew Bennett |
Ten/10 |
| 39 |
43 |
4 |
WR |
12 |
Roy Williams |
Det/3 |
| 40 |
36 |
-4 |
WR |
13 |
Hines Ward |
Pit/4 |
| 44 |
41 |
-3 |
WR |
14 |
Michael Clayton |
TB/7 |
| 45 |
40 |
-5 |
WR |
15 |
Nate Burleson |
Min/5 |
| 46 |
63 |
17 |
WR |
16 |
Isaac Bruce |
StL/9 |
| 47 |
47 |
0 |
WR |
17 |
Steve Smith |
Car/7 |
| 50 |
87 |
37 |
WR |
18 |
Lee Evans |
Buf/9 |
| 53 |
74 |
21 |
WR |
19 |
Jimmy Smith |
Jac/7 |
| 56 |
73 |
17 |
WR |
20 |
Ashley Lelie |
Den/9 |
| 60 |
70 |
10 |
WR |
21 |
Chris Chambers |
Mia/4 |
| 61 |
62 |
1 |
WR |
22 |
Donald Driver |
GB/6 |
| 62 |
49 |
-13 |
WR |
23 |
Anquan Boldin |
Ari/6 |
| 66 |
65 |
-1 |
WR |
24 |
Larry Fitzgerald |
Ari/6 |
| 67 |
54 |
-13 |
WR |
25 |
Laveranues Coles |
NYJ/8 |
| 69 |
93 |
24 |
WR |
26 |
Rod Smith |
Den/9 |
| 71 |
57 |
-14 |
WR |
27 |
Jerry Porter |
Oak/5 |
| 72 |
79 |
7 |
WR |
28 |
Deion Branch |
NE/7 |
| 73 |
80 |
7 |
WR |
29 |
Eric Moulds |
Buf/9 |
| 76 |
115 |
39 |
WR |
30 |
Donte Stallworth |
NO/10 |
| 79 |
76 |
-3 |
WR |
31 |
Muhsin Muhammad |
Chi/4 |
| 80 |
98 |
18 |
WR |
32 |
Eddie Kennison |
KC/5 |
| 84 |
101 |
17 |
WR |
33 |
T.J. Houshmandzadeh |
Cin/10 |
| 87 |
71 |
-16 |
WR |
34 |
Derrick Mason |
Bal/3 |
| 88 |
86 |
-2 |
WR |
35 |
Plaxico Burress |
NYG/5 |
| 90 |
92 |
2 |
WR |
36 |
Santana Moss |
Was/3 |
| 93 |
143 |
50 |
WR |
37 |
David Givens |
NE/7 |
| 96 |
109 |
13 |
WR |
38 |
Keary Colbert |
Car/7 |
| 101 |
124 |
23 |
WR |
39 |
Keyshawn Johnson |
Dal/9 |
| 102 |
154 |
52 |
WR |
40 |
Amani Toomer |
NYG/5 |
| 106 |
146 |
40 |
WR |
41 |
Justin McCareins |
NYJ/8 |
| 109 |
134 |
25 |
WR |
42 |
Brandon Lloyd |
SF/6 |
| 111 |
90 |
-21 |
WR |
43 |
Brandon Stokley |
Ind/8 |
| 116 |
144 |
28 |
WR |
44 |
Antwaan Randle El |
Pit/4 |
| 120 |
125 |
5 |
WR |
45 |
Mike Williams |
Det/3 |
| 121 |
129 |
8 |
WR |
46 |
Keenan McCardell |
SD/10 |
| 127 |
176 |
49 |
WR |
47 |
Antonio Bryant |
Cle/4 |
| 128 |
250 |
122 |
WR |
48 |
Bernard Berrian |
Chi/4 |
| 135 |
197 |
62 |
WR |
49 |
Ronald Curry |
Oak/5 |
| 137 |
148 |
11 |
WR |
50 |
Reche Caldwell |
SD/10 |
| 141 |
196 |
55 |
WR |
51 |
Joey Galloway |
TB/7 |
| 146 |
250 |
104 |
WR |
52 |
Jabar Gaffney |
Hou/3 |
| 151 |
107 |
-44 |
WR |
53 |
Charles Rogers |
Det/3 |
| 155 |
122 |
-33 |
WR |
54 |
Troy Williamson |
Min/5 |
| 157 |
250 |
93 |
WR |
55 |
Andre Davis |
Cle/4 |
| 164 |
250 |
86 |
WR |
56 |
Quincy Morgan |
Dal/9 |
| 171 |
181 |
10 |
WR |
57 |
Michael Jenkins |
Atl/8 |
| 175 |
186 |
11 |
WR |
58 |
Kevin Curtis |
StL/9 |
| 179 |
190 |
11 |
WR |
59 |
Terry Glenn |
Dal/9 |
| 182 |
250 |
68 |
WR |
60 |
Brandon Jones |
Ten/10 |
| 187 |
207 |
20 |
WR |
61 |
Samie Parker |
KC/5 |
| 191 |
217 |
26 |
WR |
62 |
Darius Watts |
Den/9 |
| 196 |
114 |
-82 |
WR |
63 |
Braylon Edwards |
Cle/4 |
| 204 |
164 |
-40 |
WR |
64 |
Marcus Robinson |
Min/5 |
| 209 |
250 |
41 |
WR |
65 |
Ike Hilliard |
TB/7 |
| 216 |
188 |
-28 |
WR |
66 |
Reggie Williams |
Jac/7 |
| 222 |
250 |
28 |
WR |
67 |
Marty Booker |
Mia/4 |
| 229 |
250 |
21 |
WR |
68 |
Justin Gage |
Chi/4 |
| 235 |
250 |
15 |
WR |
69 |
David Patten |
Was/3 |
| 242 |
250 |
8 |
WR |
70 |
Eric Parker |
SD/10 |
| 245 |
228 |
-17 |
WR |
71 |
Robert Ferguson |
GB/6 |
| 250 |
250 |
0 |
WR |
72 |
Peter Warrick |
Cin/10 |
| 256 |
151 |
-105 |
WR |
73 |
Mark Clayton |
Bal/3 |
| 261 |
250 |
-11 |
WR |
74 |
Shaun McDonald |
StL/9 |
| 266 |
250 |
-16 |
WR |
75 |
Greg Lewis |
Phi/6 |
| 268 |
225 |
-43 |
WR |
76 |
Bobby Engram |
Sea/8 |
| 272 |
250 |
-22 |
WR |
77 |
Clarence Moore |
Bal/3 |
| 278 |
250 |
-28 |
WR |
78 |
Arnaz Battle |
SF/6 |
| 282 |
223 |
-59 |
WR |
79 |
Joe Jurevicius |
Sea/8 |
| 288 |
250 |
-38 |
WR |
80 |
Rod Gardner |
Car/7 |
| 289 |
250 |
-39 |
WR |
81 |
Bryant Johnson |
Ari/6 |
| 294 |
187 |
-107 |
WR |
82 |
Peerless Price |
Atl/8 |
| 300 |
192 |
-108 |
WR |
83 |
David Boston |
Mia/4 |
| 304 |
250 |
-54 |
WR |
84 |
Cedrick Wilson |
Pit/4 |
| 310 |
145 |
-165 |
WR |
85 |
Tyrone Calico |
Ten/10 |
| 94 |
72 |
-22 |
Def |
1 |
Baltimore |
Bal/3 |
| 103 |
99 |
-4 |
Def |
2 |
Buffalo |
Buf/9 |
| 114 |
88 |
-26 |
Def |
3 |
New England |
NE/7 |
| 125 |
100 |
-25 |
Def |
4 |
Pittsburgh |
Pit/4 |
| 133 |
133 |
0 |
Def |
5 |
Tampa Bay |
TB/7 |
| 143 |
121 |
-22 |
Def |
6 |
Carolina |
Car/7 |
| 145 |
171 |
26 |
Def |
7 |
NY Jets |
NYJ/8 |
| 152 |
182 |
30 |
Def |
8 |
Cincinnati |
Cin/10 |
| 161 |
116 |
-45 |
Def |
9 |
Philadelphia |
Phi/6 |
| 167 |
127 |
-40 |
Def |
10 |
Atlanta |
Atl/8 |
| 174 |
147 |
-27 |
Def |
11 |
Minnesota |
Min/5 |
| 177 |
170 |
-7 |
Def |
12 |
Indianapolis |
Ind/8 |
| 183 |
155 |
-28 |
Def |
13 |
Washington |
Was/3 |
| 192 |
250 |
58 |
Def |
14 |
New Orleans |
NO/10 |
| 197 |
162 |
-35 |
Def |
15 |
Jacksonville |
Jac/7 |
| 205 |
169 |
-36 |
Def |
16 |
Chicago |
Chi/4 |
| 210 |
210 |
0 |
Def |
17 |
Arizona |
Ari/6 |
| 212 |
218 |
6 |
Def |
18 |
Detroit |
Det/3 |
| 217 |
226 |
9 |
Def |
19 |
Seattle |
Sea/8 |
| 223 |
157 |
-66 |
Def |
20 |
Dallas |
Dal/9 |
| 224 |
178 |
-46 |
Def |
21 |
Miami |
Mia/4 |
| 230 |
214 |
-16 |
Def |
22 |
Kansas City |
KC/5 |
| 236 |
250 |
14 |
Def |
23 |
Ny Giants |
NYG/5 |
| 239 |
200 |
-39 |
Def |
24 |
San Diego |
SD/10 |
| 252 |
203 |
-49 |
Def |
25 |
Denver |
Den/9 |
| 263 |
250 |
-13 |
Def |
26 |
San Francisco |
SF/6 |
| 273 |
250 |
-23 |
Def |
27 |
Cleveland |
Cle/4 |
| 283 |
250 |
-33 |
Def |
28 |
Houston |
Hou/3 |
| 290 |
250 |
-40 |
Def |
29 |
Green Bay |
GB/6 |
| 295 |
250 |
-45 |
Def |
30 |
Tennessee |
Ten/10 |
| 301 |
250 |
-51 |
Def |
31 |
Oakland |
Oak/5 |
| 305 |
250 |
-55 |
Def |
32 |
St. Louis |
StL/9 |
|
Let's have the perfect draft.
The goal is to get you the best possible team and to make sure you don't overpay for players that can still be had a few rounds later. What I look for are players that I project significantly better than where they are being drafted. The positional analysis tracks to my projections.
This article assumes a 12 team league using scoring that starts 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 Def and 1 PK.
Quarterbacks
Simply put, this is one of the deepest fields of quarterbacks I have ever seen. Eleven quarterbacks are "expected" to be drafted in the first 80 picks. Fifteen are "expected" to be drafted by the first 100 picks. And a whopping 20 will be picked by pick 120 on average.
Let me repeat that so it sinks in. Nearly one third of the teams will take their SECOND quarterback by the end of the 8th round.
Simply put, let me say this the easiest way I can - don't be one of those teams. The fantasy points differential between QB5 and QB15 is not enough (in most leagues) to justify spending two picks in the first eight rounds on quarterbacks.
So how many QBs do you need in a perfect 12-team draft?
I think you need two that are not in jeopardy of losing their jobs (unless they get injured).
With history as our guide, the top QBs are almost always drafted too early. And this makes sense. The QB position generally scores the most points so fantasy players want a good one. But since most leagues only require one starting QB there is little pressure on the remaining QBs after the first three or four are gone. Just scratch off Peyton Manning, Daunte Culpepper, and Donovan McNabb from your cheatsheets. Every one of these players will be drafted too soon because one owner in every league will drink the grape Kool-Aid that is called Stud Quarterbacks.
Don't be that owner. If you do, you will not have the perfect draft.
In fact, I think this is key #1 to winning your league this year. Resist the temptation and let others grab these stars. How can I say that with such conviction? Because draft after draft, I have seen the same thing happen. People overpay for the top stars, and then a lull takes place before a mad rush ensues (starting at the end of round six) for the quality quarterbacks left. This run continues through round nine until about 16 QBs have been taken.
There are two sweet spots to target for QBs this year. The first appears early in the sixth round. Kerry Collins and Michael Vick are the two players to target here.
Kerry Collins, Oak (Value = 48, ADP = 56)
Michael Vick, Atl (Value = 52, ADP = 59)
We expect big things from both of these players this year. Collins because of the addition of Randy Moss and Lamont Jordan and Vick because this is his second year in this offense. Both of these players could easily be gone by round 6. And if that happens, do not panic...just move to plan B.
Plan B at QB: As you enter the seventh round, take one of these excellent QBs:
Jake Plummer, Den (Value = 59, ADP = 81) - Almost always available
Aaron Brooks, NO (Value = 68, ADP = 84) - Almost always available
Brett Favre, GB (Value = 75, ADP = 66 ) - Usually drafted already
Tom Brady, NE (Value = 81, ADP = 77) - Usually available
Grab the best one you can. I expect them all to have great years.
Now sit back and enjoy the panic from the other owners as the quarterbacks keep flying off the board. Later in the draft, set your sites on getting one of these quality backups:
Steve McNair, Ten (Value = 95, ADP =120) in the 10th round or later.
Jake Delhomme, Car (Value = 97, ADP = 97) in the 10th round or later.
Again, the general strategy is to wait at QB unless exceptional value presents itself early.
No need to panic at this position. Just let the draft come to you. There is great value to be gained by waiting. Typically after those first 16 QBs are drafted (usually by the middle of round nine), QBs will come off the board at about two per round until all of the starters are taken.
Additionally the following QBs are rarely drafted but could be homeruns if their starting QB went down to injury:
Jon Kitna, Cin
Brad Johnson, Min
Todd Collins, KC
In leagues with deep drafts, taking a flier on one of these with your last pick in the draft could yield outstanding results. Less than half of the QBs in the league play all 16 games each year. The other owners will call you lucky if you hit on one of these players, but the engraving on the trophy still looks the same.
One last QB strategy you have to have in your arsenal this year is the handcuff play with the Detroit quarterbacks. There is no questioning the talent this team has at running back (Kevin Jones) and wide receiver (Roy Williams, Charles Rogers, Kevin Johnson, and Mike Williams). They also have a solid TE in Marcus Pollard. Their defense is below average. They play Chicago, Minnesota and Green Bay twice and are likely to be involved in some shootouts (because those teams have below-average defenses too).
All said, the Detroit passing game will likely put up great numbers this season. The problem is who is the starter? A case could be made for Harrington or Garcia. I think it's likely both will be the starter at some point this season. So do the right thing and get them both. Their ADPs right now are hovering around the 24th and 32nd quarterbacks. Combined, they have a great chance to be top ten in passing. One will likely emerge, and even if the controversy lasts all season you will know who to play each week. It will be the player practicing with the first team.
Running Backs
In most leagues, running backs are golden. Yes they can run and catch, but the real reason they are golden is there simply are not enough of them to go around. Every owner wants three or four quality backs. In 12-team leagues this creates huge demand with limited supply.
My strategy for the perfect 12-team draft is to try and secure three of the top 20 elite backs this season.
Here they are according to my rank (feel free to move them around to your liking):
- LaDainian Tomlinson, SD
- Priest Holmes, KC
- Shaun Alexander, Sea
- Deuce McAllister, NO
- Edgerrin James, Ind
- Domanick Davis, Hou
- Clinton Portis, Was
- Tiki Barber, NYG
- Willis McGahee, Buf
- Corey Dillon, NE
- Brian Westbrook, Phi
- Kevin Jones, Det
- Julius Jones, Dal
- Curtis Martin, NYJ
- Rudi Johnson, Cin
- Jamal Lewis, Bal
- Steven Jackson, StL
- Ahman Green, GB
- Lamont Jordan, Oak
- Tatum Bell, Den
Your ideal goal is to get three of these players and let the other owners fight over the table scraps that are left. And to get three of them, owners will need to pick RB, RB and RB in three successive picks.
Here are the only non-RB players that I would take before these elite 22 backs:
Peyton Manning at pick 14 or later.
Randy Moss at pick 19 or later.
Daunte Culpepper at pick 23 or later.
There is a good chance that none of these players will be available at these spots. That is OK. Continue to stockpile the elite RBs and position yourself for a strong draft the rest of the way. The reason you need to get exceptional value if you don't take running backs with your first two or three picks is because you will likely overpay for mediocre RBs every round after round two.
So getting Randy Moss at fair value (pick 12) actually represents negative value to your squad because you will be scrambling to make the RB position work later in the draft.
Average Draft Position shows that these 20 elite backs are usually gone by the 29th pick. So teams drafting late in the first round may not even have the possibility to execute this strategy.
Once the 20 elite RBs are off the board, you have to shift gears and take the best available player. Continuing to pursue lesser RB talent is likely a recipe for disaster and should only be done if it coincides with the Top 200 valuations.
Besides taking quality RBs early, I also like these backs in the following rounds:
JJ Arrington, Ari (Value = 29, ADP = 44) in the 4th round or later.
Warrick Dunn, Atl (Value = 42, ADP = 46) in the 4th round or later.
Kevan Barlow, SF (Value = 55, ADP = 60) in the late 5th round or later.
Thomas Jones (Value = 51, ADP = 95) in the 7th round or later.
Jerome Bettis, Pit (Value = 70, ADP = 102) in the 8th round or later.
Mike Anderson, Den (Value = 105, ADP = 174) in the 13th round or later.
Kevin Faulk, NE (Value = 131, ADP = 202) in the 15th round or later.
Additionally, you can generate value by taking these handcuffs:
Deshaun Foster (ADP = 53) in the 5th and Eric Shelton (ADP = 128) in the 11th.
Fred Taylor (ADP = 58) in the 5th and LaBrandon Toefield (ADP = 140) in the 12th.
Wide Receivers
The biggest key to having a great wide receiver corps is implementing the QB and RB strategies from steps one and two above. By waiting at QB until round six or seven and grabbing two or three RBs early, you have the fourth, fifth and sixth or seventh rounds (and possibly the third round) to grab quality WRs. And this is exactly what you should do.
By the end of round four, you should have at least two quality RBs and one or two quality wide receivers.
Although a team constructed like this won't have a horse like Randy Moss, it should end up with a great team full of players in very secure situations. These players are also great for trading after the draft.
There is almost always great value late in a draft at wide receiver too, and this year is no exception. But you will want the core talent to build around (especially in start 3 WRs leagues - which this article is based on).
Here are the WRs I believe will have exceptional value in the draft:
Reggie Wayne, Ind (Value = 26, ADP = 35) in the 4th or later.
Drew Bennett, Ten (Value = 37, ADP = 50) in the late 4th or later.
Isaac Bruce, StL (Value = 46, ADP = 63) in the 5th round or later.
Lee Evans, Buf (Value = 50, ADP = 87) in the 6th round or later.
Jimmy Smith, Jac (Value = 53, ADP = 74) in the 6th round or later.
Rod Smith, Den (Value = 69, ADP = 93) in the 7th round or later.
Donte Stallworth, NO (Value = 76, ADP = 115) in the 9th round or later.
Eddie Kennison, KC (Value = 80, ADP = 98) in the 9th round or later.
TJ Houshmandzadeh, Cin (Value = 84, ADP = 101) in the 9th round or later.
David Givens, NE (Value = 93, ADP = 143) in the 11th round or later.
Amani Toomer, NYG (Value = 102, ADP = 154) in the 12th round or later.
Justin McCareins, NYJ (Value = 106, ADP = 146) in the 12th round or later.
Some other WRs will undoubtedly slip in your drafts besides the above targeted bargain list. In recap, grab one or two solid receivers in your first four rounds and add at least one more in rounds five and six. Then wait for exceptional value to emerge at WR because it always does.
Tight Ends
Tony Gonzalez and Antonio Gates are in a class by themselves. If you can get either of these in the fourth round, leap and don't think twice. If you are lucky enough to land one of these players, simply look to add an additional value WR later. Most of us won't be this lucky however.
But fear not. There are always bargains at the tight end position.
It's no surprise that since TEs catch a relatively small amount of passes primarily on short and intermediate routes (again, excluding the top tier guys), there isn't a great deal of variance usually between the 4th best TE and the 12th best, witness:
2004 - 4th (113 points), 12th (69 points) = 44 points difference (2.75 per game)
2003 -- 4th (74 points), 12th (65 points) = 9 points difference (0.56 per game)
2002 -- 4th (91 points), 12th (63 points) = 28 points difference (1.75 per game)
2001 -- 4th (93 points), 12th (75 points) = 18 points difference (1.13 per game)
2000 -- 4th (96 points), 12th (61 points) = 34 points difference (2.13 per game)
5 YR AVG -- 4th (93 points), 12th (67 points) = 26 points difference (1.63 per game)
So ultimately, once you get past the big TEs, you're really debating over a point or two per week (which is why it is wise to just wait until the later rounds to select a TE).
In 2002, I told you to wait and get Todd Heap (great). In 2003, I targeted Stephen Alexander (bust) and Freddie Jones (solid). In 2004, I nailed Daniel Graham (great early and then faded).
The TE I love this season is Ben Troupe. But there is a problem. Ben Troupe may start the year injured. But lucky for you, Erron Kinney (the other TE from Tennessee) will be asked to pick up the slack. The ADPs of these two TEs are as follows:
Ben Troupe (ADP = 177) - Can usually be drafted in the 14th round
Erron Kinney (ADP = 250) - Usually is not drafted
I fully expect the combination of these two players to yield results on par with a Top 5 TE.
Why do I love the Tennessee Tight Ends?
First, the team has but one viable receiver in Drew Bennett. Derrick Mason is gone and the WR2 spot will be filled with either a rookie or someone with extremely limited experience. The team would like Tyrone Calico to win this role, but it remains to be seen if he can get healthy enough to be a contributor. Additionally, the Titans are expected to have a below-average defense meaning they may be forced to throw a lot this season. Offensive Coordinator Norm Chow has already stated that they will lean on their TEs this year. And lastly, Troupe was an animal down the stretch last year. So if you can afford the roster spots, I advocate locking up both Kinney and Troupe.
Another tight end that I believe is under-valued is Jeb Putzier. Early reports from Denver show Stephen Alexander running with the first team, but that is likely due to Putzier not 100% healthy right now. I fully expect Jeb to win the job by the start of the season. He can likely be picked in the 11th round or later.
Because quality TEs can usually be had on the waiver wire, once you have one TE (or the Tennessee handcuff above), you should generally just wait until the last few rounds of your draft to add a backup.
Place Kickers
Who cares right? Well...kind of right. Definitely nothing you should even look at until round 12. But all drafts are different. In leagues that go after kickers early, just wait. You can get an adequate PK three rounds after every other owner has their first. In leagues that sluff this position until real late, look towards the top of the kicker list in round 12. If your top kicker is available then draft him. Suffice it to say that in a lot of leagues now, people wait too long to take their kickers. As a rule of thumb, you can generally maximize kicker value by taking the fifth or sixth kicker off the board. In waiver wire friendly leagues (most), don't be afraid to just draft one kicker and add others as necessary to cover the bye weeks and/or exploit matchups.
Defenses
The top defenses (Baltimore, Buffalo, New England, and Pittsburgh) will not represent value in most leagues this year. Just like kickers, your league may draft defenses early or very late.
Scoring systems generally come into play and define when defenses are taken.
I suggest you wait until round 12 to assess what to do next. If Baltimore or Buffalo are on the board grab them, and be done with this position. If those two teams are gone, I would wait until six to eight defenses have been drafted and then see where the value is.
Because owners rank defenses so differently, you can generally get good value just by waiting for the value to emerge.
A winning strategy to deploy after the draft for defenses is simply to look two games ahead in the waiver process. Most teams will have one or two defenses meaning that half of the defenses are available as free agent pick ups each week. By looking two to three weeks ahead at who will be playing San Francisco, Cleveland or the New York Giants, you likely can find a cheap defense that should perform well against sub-par competition. Drop this defense after their "quality game" so that you can continue to pick up other defenses that will have good weeks. Because of this strategy, we advise you to draft but one quality defense and look to play matchups the rest of the way. Every year two or three defenses are predicted to be terrible but end up playing great.
Putting It All Together
Look to draft two or three of the elite 20 RBs unless significant value exists elsewhere. Make these backs the centerpiece of your team.
QB value is available throughout the draft so just wait until it emerges. Grab one QB in the sixth or seventh round and then add a "value QB" in rounds 10-12. Consider taking a flier with your last pick on a QB that could be a goldmine with a key injury. If you draft on the turn (first or 12th) look to get both Detroit QBs with back-to-back picks.
Grab at least one quality WR (in rounds two through four), stockpile two more solid contributors in rounds five and six and then wait for value to emerge. It always does. Stockpile value wide receivers. Some will bust, but others will help you win your league. Guys like Michael Clayton emerge from deep in the draft every single year.
Sluff TE unless Gonzalez or Gates slides to the fourth round. If you don't get one of the Big Two TEs wait until after round ten to draft your first tight end. Target both Tennessee Tight Ends very late in the draft for exceptional value.
Sluff defense, but don't be afraid to grab the first or second one in round 12. If defenses go earlier than normal, wait for 6-8 defenses to be picked before you take your first. Do not add a second defense (or if you do, add it very late). Work the waiver wire weeks ahead of great matchups for value.
Sluff kicker, but don't be afraid to grab the first or second in round 12. If kickers go early, take the firth or sixth kicker off the board. Wait until the last rounds to add a second kicker.
Well that is it folks. Hope you all do well in your coming drafts. Remember, the key is not to just follow the Top 200 list but to see where it differs substantially from average drafts. This is how you get value. And value is how you build winning fantasy teams.
Note: I know there is more than one way to have a great draft. I have seen teams take players like Manning and Moss with their first two picks and run away with titles by picking undervalued players the rest of the way. I am not going to state that this article is the ONLY way to be successful in your twelve team draft. It's simply one way to end up with a very competitive team.
|