Staff Confidence Pool (No Spread) Week 5

Will Grant's Staff Confidence Pool (No Spread) Week 5 Will Grant Published 10/03/2019

Looking to dominate your office pool this season? Eighteen Footballguys.com staff members are here to help you out. Each week they will pick the winners of every NFL game, and rank their selections based on how confident they are that the team will win. The most-confident pick gets 16 points, and the least-confident gets just 1. We'll even total up everyone's picks so you can get an overall consensus on who our staff think will be the most likely winners. Each week we'll announce the weekly winners, and track the overall record for the entire season. A couple of things to note before we get to the picks:

  • Picks for this pool are straight up (no point spread considered).
  • Picks are due on Wednesday nights, and will not reflect any late-breaking news. If your league allows for last-minute changes, please make adjustments to your office pool accordingly.
  • Our staffers also play in weekly picks Against The Spread, and Survivor Style 'Pick one Winner each week' formats as well. Check out the other weekly articles for more help with those types of games.

RESULTS FROM LAST WEEK

This week was rough - between the lower amount of games and a couple of big upsets, most of the staff finished with less than 50% of the total possible confidence points. But Andy Hicks made the most of it, finishing with the highest score of the week - 72 confidence points. Interestingly though, he did it with managing risk. Hicks had only 7 correct picks this week, but he beat out overall leader Dave Larkin who had 8 and Sean Settle who had 9. It was Hicks's big 14 point win on Monday Night that gave him the overall win.

Away Team
PHI
WAS
CLE
NE
OAK
CAR
TEN
KC
LAC
TB
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
CIN
Home Team
GB
NYG
BAL
BUF
IND
HOU
ATL
DET
MIA
LAR
ARI
CHI
DEN
NO
PIT
Staffer
The Picks
LW
Hicks
GB
WAS
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
JAC
DAL
PIT
72
3
4
2
7
5
6
8
10
15
11
12
1
13
9
14
Larkin
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
NO
PIT
68
9
10
6
8
12
4
5
11
14
13
15
3
2
1
7
Settle
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
NO
PIT
65
7
10
11
15
9
6
8
13
14
12
5
2
4
1
3
Knotts
GB
NYG
CLE
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
PIT
65
11
8
5
12
9
10
7
14
15
13
6
1
2
4
3
Brimacombe
PHI
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
ARI
CHI
JAC
NO
PIT
65
1
6
7
10
12
11
9
13
15
14
2
5
8
3
4
Roberts
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
CAR
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
JAC
DAL
PIT
63
10
5
8
9
12
1
11
13
15
14
7
4
3
2
6
Pasquino
PHI
WAS
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
DEN
DAL
PIT
62
2
4
11
12
10
9
5
14
13
15
8
6
1
3
7
Wood
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
DEN
DAL
CIN
61
8
11
10
12
7
6
4
15
14
13
9
3
2
5
1
Garda
GB
WAS
BAL
NE
IND
CAR
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
PIT
59
10
4
9
11
13
3
7
14
15
12
8
1
2
5
6
Buzzard
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
DEN
NO
PIT
59
7
2
11
13
12
5
8
10
15
14
9
3
4
1
6
Haseley
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
DEN
DAL
CIN
57
8
7
14
12
10
6
5
11
15
13
9
3
1
4
2
Davenport
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
PIT
56
9
4
12
10
6
8
7
14
13
15
11
2
1
5
3
Miglio
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
ARI
CHI
DEN
NO
PIT
54
12
7
11
13
8
10
6
9
14
15
1
4
3
2
5
Tuccitto
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
NO
PIT
53
11
10
13
4
6
12
2
5
14
15
1
8
7
9
3
Bitonti
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
DEN
DAL
PIT
53
13
6
12
11
10
5
7
9
14
15
8
2
1
4
3
Gray
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
CHI
JAC
DAL
PIT
51
9
8
12
10
15
14
5
6
11
13
7
3
2
1
4
Grant
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
DEN
DAL
PIT
50
11
6
13
12
7
9
8
14
3
15
10
4
1
2
5
Wimer
GB
NYG
BAL
NE
IND
HOU
ATL
KC
LAC
LAR
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
PIT
42
11
8
14
7
13
6
10
5
15
12
4
3
2
9
1
Away
PHI
WAS
CLE
NE
OAK
CAR
TEN
KC
LAC
TB
SEA
MIN
JAC
DAL
CIN
Total Pts
3
12
5
188
0
4
0
200
244
0
129
27
46
53
3
Home
GB
NYG
BAL
BUF
IND
HOU
ATL
DET
MIA
LAR
ARI
CHI
DEN
NO
PIT
Total Pts
149
108
176
0
176
127
122
0
0
244
3
31
13
17
80
Tot Conf Pts
152
120
181
188
176
131
122
200
244
244
132
58
59
70
83

The big losses started early last week and kept going throughout the weekend. Philadelphia's loss to Green Bay on Thursday took down all but 2 of the staff, and losses by Baltimore, Los Angeles, Atlanta, and Houston were all big hits to a majority of the staff. Over 800 confidence points were lost on those games last week, contributing to the low scoring week.

OVERALL RANKINGS

Dave Larkin extended his lead to five points with his second-place finish this week. Brimacombe is just behind him and both are more than 14 points ahead of the rest of the field.

Staff Member
Wk01
Wk02
Wk03
Wk04
Wk05
Wk06
Wk07
Wk08
Wk09
Wk10
Wk11
Wk12
Wk13
Wk14
Wk15
Wk16
Wk17
Total
Larkin
111
93
112
68
384
Brimacombe
109
95
110
65
379
Garda
115
94
97
59
365
Knotts
113
93
94
65
365
Miglio
115
97
97
54
363
Buzzard
105
98
99
59
361
Roberts
113
90
95
63
361
Pasquino
113
92
93
62
360
Davenport
108
101
94
56
359
Settle
112
92
89
65
358
Haseley
104
94
98
57
353
Grant
103
100
98
50
351
Gray
100
97
101
51
349
Wood
103
82
100
61
346
Tuccitto
105
87
92
53
337
Wimer
91
95
106
42
334
Hicks
81
78
102
72
333
Bitonti
101
87
87
53
328

THIS WEEK'S PICKS

Here are the picks for this week.

Away Team
LAR
NE
TB
MIN
CHI
NYJ
JAC
ARI
BUF
ATL
BAL
DEN
GB
IND
CLE
Home Team
SEA
WAS
NO
NYG
OAK
PHI
CAR
CIN
TEN
HOU
PIT
LAC
DAL
KC
SF
Staffer
The Picks
MNF
Miglio
SEA
NE
NO
MIN
CHI
PHI
CAR
CIN
TEN
HOU
BAL
LAC
DAL
KC
SF
52
7
15
11
9
12
13
5
1
10
8
6
4
3
14
2
Davenport
SEA
NE
TB
MIN
CHI
PHI
CAR
CIN
TEN
HOU
BAL
LAC
GB
KC
SF
49
2
15
7
4
10
13
3
1
5
11
9
12
8
14
6
Garda
SEA
NE
NO
MIN
CHI
PHI
JAC
CIN
TEN
HOU
BAL
LAC
DAL
KC
CLE
45
3
14
9
10
11
12
6
4
8
13
5
7
2
15
1
Hicks
LAR
NE
NO
MIN
CHI
PHI
JAC
CIN
TEN
HOU
BAL
LAC
DAL
KC
CLE
45
1
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

Quarterback Rankings and Tiers: One Staffer's Opinion

Dave Kluge

Quarterback rankings provided by Dave Kluge, with explanations on where and why he strays from consensus opinions.

07/15/25 Read More
 
 
 
 
The Myth of Geno Smith
Jason Wood
07/14/25 Read More