A good sports betting column should be backed by a profitable gambler with a proven track record. It should offer picks generated by a sophisticated and conceptually sound model. Most importantly, it should treat the subject with the seriousness it warrants.
This is not that column.
Instead, this will be an offbeat look at the sports betting industry—why Vegas keeps winning, why gambling advice is almost certainly not worth the money, and the structural reasons why even if a bettor were profitable, anything they wrote would be unlikely to make their readers net profitable, too.
While we're at it, we'll discuss ways to minimize Vegas' edge and make recreational betting more fun, explain how to gain an advantage in your office pick pools, preview games through an offbeat lens (with picks guaranteed to be no worse than chance), and touch on various other Odds and Ends along the way.
Now, About Those Office Pools
Back in Week 2, I went over the basics of how to put yourself in the best position to win your office pick pool. The three basic principles were:
- Make sure you got all your picks in (ideally, just submit random picks early in the week and go back to change them later in the week)
- Take advantage of line movement for guaranteed Closing Line Value (if the lines in your pick pool lock early, then any time the line moves in the direction of a team over the course of the week, always pick that team in your pool)
- Make as many office-contrarian picks as you can (because it's easier to differentiate yourself from the pack if you... differentiate yourself from the pack).
We haven't discussed pick pools since then because there's not really anything else to say early in the season. All those principles are great! If you're already doing those things, keep doing those things.
But as more data comes in, we have an opportunity to improve our chances through the power of Math. Since we're past the halfway mark, now is a good time to take stock of where things stand and start deciding if you need to adjust your approach to be more or less risk-averse.
Barring any surprise cancellations, 272 games will be played this season (assuming your office runs a separate pool for the playoffs). 150 are gone, leaving 122 to go—meaning the season is about 55% over. Because there are fewer games ahead than behind, if someone leads you by 2% right now, you'll need to outperform them by more than 2% on the remaining picks to secure a victory. (You'll need to beat them by 2.5% to tie and by 3.3% to win outright.) Likewise, if you have a 2% edge, your competitors will need to beat you by 3.3% down the stretch to catch you.
Take this time to identify your primary competitors. If possible, find out if anyone else in your pool is also relatively sharp. The easiest way to do this is to watch the teams you bet solely because of line movement and see whether anyone else in your pool is picking the same teams every week. If so, it's probably not a coincidence; they probably know what they're doing.
Beating other sharp managers can be tricky when they have a head start. To make up ground, you either need to outperform them by a bigger margin on the picks where neither of you is getting closing line value, or else you need to start intentionally sacrificing your closing line value picks to try to make up ground. Betting against the line movement is a worse bet in expectation, but if your opponent is religiously chasing line movement, this is an easy way to differentiate.
If the teams ahead of you aren't sharp, things are easier. You can keep making fundamentally sound picks with respect to line movement (which are likely to help make up any deficit in the long run), and focus on differentiating yourself in the games where the line movement doesn't provide any guidance.
The more you're down, the more you need to focus on contrarianism to make up ground. (On the other hand, if you're ahead, you should try to pick with the consensus instead of against it; your opponents can't make up ground if you're picking the same teams as they are.)
Also, at this point, make sure you're tailoring your idea of "contrarian" and "chalk" to your actual competitors. If someone is 20 games back, it doesn't matter what they pick because they're probably not catching up. Only concern yourself with those who have a realistic chance of winning it all.
Sometimes, two of your "rules of thumb" will be in conflict. Most often, this will be because there's line movement in the direction of the "popular team" in the office. If the standings are relatively close, it's best to pick conservatively still at this point and let your "follow line movement" rule trump the "pick against the home team" rule. With good line management, anticipate being able to pick 52-54% of games correctly instead of 50%. If that kind of edge is going to be enough to have you among the leaders seven weeks from now, stick with it. If you're so far down that even a 5% edge won't be enough, start taking bigger risks.
Remember, once you're out of the money, it doesn't matter where you finish. If payouts go three deep, 4th place is no better than 40th. When high-variance strategies fail, they fail badly. But it's better to try and fail than to just coast along and delay the inevitable, so once you fall far enough behind that embracing variance becomes your only hope of catching up, make the switch.