Reading The Defense Week 3

Life is best lived with a glass-half-full mindset, and that's usually how we approach NFL defenses: with optimism about the schemes that actually work at a high level. We spend plenty of time celebrating the elites. This week is different. We're looking at two units closer to the basement than the attic, defenses that have struggled far more than they've succeeded against opposing offenses.

Houston Can't Defend the Pass

Entering the year, Houston was one of the defenses people feared. DeMeco Ryans had just finished second in total defense and scoring defense, and the roster still had difference-makers at multiple levels. Another year in the same scheme was supposed to tighten the screws. Two games in, that picture has slipped. The Texans are 21st in total defense and 26th against the pass. The run defense is still a real sixth. The pass defense is the problem. Ryans' defense lives in a Wide-9, four-down front that plays nickel as the default. Five defensive backs are on the field about 75 percent of the time. That is a pass-first identity. The first two opponents, Buffalo and Cincinnati, are two of the better passing offenses in the league. Houston allowed 56 points in two losses.

The scheme is built to stop the throw. It has not. A four-down front asks the line to win without extra bodies. Will Anderson can still do that. He has 11 tackles and 1.5 sacks through two weeks after an All-Pro season on the edge. The aging pieces next to him have not kept pace. Danielle Hunter has one tackle and one sack. Sheldon Rankins has six tackles and one sack. If the rush does not arrive with results, the zones behind it have to be airtight. In this league, that is a heavy ask. Derek Stingley Jr. is the name everyone knows. Offensive coordinators already know it too, which is why he rarely sees more than a handful of real chances a game. The load shifts to Kamari Lassiter and Reed Blankenship. Those are the players who have to turn this nickel look into a shutdown defense. They have not. Houston is giving up 338 yards a game, 252.5 of them through the air. In a nickel-heavy scheme, that is closer to the bottom of the league than the middle. The tell is the split. The run tape still looks like Houston. The pass tape does not. Scheme and personnel should match. Right now, the identity is outrunning the results.

Detroit Defense Zoning Out

Nobody walks into a Lions game expecting a defensive nightmare. Detroit still has real pieces at every level. Dan Campbell's message is physicality on both sides of the ball. Through two weeks, the defense has not matched it. The call sheet is old-school. Detroit is in a base 4-3 on about 63 percent of snaps: four down linemen, three linebackers, and no apology for the extra body in the box. Camp talk pointed toward more nickel. The snap counts did not. Behind that front, the coverage is zone on nearly 75 percent of plays. That is a hard break from the Aaron Glenn years, when man coverage was the identity. Last season still had traces of it. This season, almost none.

The personnel explains the shift. Aidan Hutchinson is one of the better young rushers in the league. Offensive lines already plan for him, and he is still showing up in the box score: eight tackles, three sacks, and no rust. Jack Campbell is the other young piece the scheme actually needs. A heavy 4-3 asks linebackers to own the middle of the field in the passing game more often than a nickel defense does. Campbell is that player on paper. The tape is not matching the names. Detroit has allowed 71 points and 457.5 yards a game. Hutchinson can win his rush. Campbell can occupy the middle. That isn't enough if the rest of the unit doesn't run the look. In a base-heavy, zone-heavy scheme, the whole front seven has to buy the assignment. Two stars cannot cover for a defense that is late to the message. The tell is the same one as Houston, just inverted. The Lions have the culture speech and two young difference-makers. They do not have the results. Scheme only works if the roster plays it at the rate the call sheet demands.

Notable Players

T.J. Watt is still T.J. Watt. Age and injury history haven't changed the tape. Four more tackles and another 1.5 sacks in Week 2, on top of a strong start. Pittsburgh changed coaches. Watt did not change jobs. He is still one of the best pass rushers in the league.

Three games in, Evan Williams is climbing the defensive back board the old-fashioned way. Twenty-seven tackles and two passes defended. That is the job: a real tackle floor plus enough disruption to matter. Green Bay's defense needs the help. Fantasy managers will take the production.

Quentin Lake is the early clubhouse leader at safety. Two games, 17 tackles, six passes defended, a forced fumble, and an interception. Same tackle floor as Evan Williams, with extra splash on top. A lot of "new" names are showing up this year. In the secondary, Lake is first in line.

Jihaad Campbell has taken the new role and run with it. At 22, he already has 19 tackles, a sack, and an interception while lining up next to former All-Pro Zack Baun. That is not a complementary stat line. Philadelphia's linebacker pair is feeding IDP rosters more than their share already.

Glass half full or just "the glass has water," the job is the same: put what you are seeing in context before you decide what comes next. Houston and Detroit entered the year with real expectations. Two weeks in, the plan has blown up. Those staffs have to read their own defenses and adjust. You have to do the same with IDP and D/ST. React to the league in front of you, not the one you drafted in August. We get things wrong. That is the job. The prediction matters less than what you do with the new information.

Follow @mattmontyff Follow @Footballguys