Reading the Defense, Week 8

Tripp Brebner III's Reading the Defense, Week 8 Tripp Brebner III Published 10/28/2022

The Arizona Cardinals made Clemson Tiger star Isaiah Simmons the eighth overall pick of the 2020 NFL Draft. Simmons was described as a “positionless” player in the pre-draft process. Pro Football Focus recorded no majority position in his pre-snap alignments in his final year at Clemson.

The Cardinals planned for Simmons to be a tight-end “eraser.” Defensive coordinator Vance Joseph’s scheme has for years struggled to contain opposing tight ends. Simmons, the team projected, would play on the second level of the defense across from the tight end, his primary coverage assignment.

Unlike most top-ten picks, Simmons struggled to see the field as a rookie. His execution as a linebacker left much to be desired by his coaches.

He overcame this preseason performance to start and play full-time alongside middle linebacker Jordan Hicks throughout 2021, his second pro season. After a decent start to the season, the Cardinals’ defensive performance flagged badly down the stretch. They were easily eliminated by NFC West rival L.A. in the playoffs. Simmons’s pass coverage suffered with that of the team’s, and he generated little pressure in his opportunities as an edge rusher.

This summer, Vance Joseph and the Cardinals redefined Simmons’s position as “starbacker.” The role isn’t radically different in 2022 than in 2021; however, two key differences exist. First, he’s less likely to play on the edge, and second, he’s no longer playing full time. He is frequently the nickel defender in a defensive backfield that stars Budda Baker and Jalen Thompson at safety.

The Cardinals are following the league-wide trend in 2022 by relying more frequently on two high safeties versus last year when they predominantly alternated Baker and Thompson in deep centerfield. With two safeties deep, the defense needs more in run support from the nickel. At 6-foot-4 and 238 pounds with 4.39 speed, Simmons certainly looks the part of a formidable run defender in space.

No Slot Cornerback

Alas, Isaiah Simmons has not thrived in the Starbacker role either. Importantly, the Cardinals are not the only team redefining a role errantly known as “slot cornerback” in many forums.

The Buccaneers have moved star safety Antoine Winfield into the slot. He has already exceeded his career high in tackles for loss with five, matched his career high in sacks (3.0), and is on pace to match his career-high tackles total.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a ELITE subscription.

An ELITE subscription is required to access content for IDP (individual defensive players) leagues. If this league is not a IDP (individual defensive players) league, you can edit your leagues here.

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Tripp Brebner III

 

Reading the New Defense: Jacksonville Jaguars

Tripp Brebner III

Jacksonville has a new defense for 2025. Our Tripp Brebner looks at the new IDP opportunities in Anthony Campanile's scheme.

07/11/25 Read More
 

Reading the New Defense: Dallas Cowboys

Tripp Brebner III

Dallas has a new defense for 2025. Our Tripp Brebner looks at the new IDP opportunities in Matt Eberflus's scheme.

07/03/25 Read More
 

Reading the New Defense: Chicago Bears

Tripp Brebner III

Chicago has a new defense for 2025. Our Tripp Brebner looks at the new IDP opportunities in Dennis Allen's scheme.

06/28/25 Read More
 

Reading the New Defense: New Orleans Saints

Tripp Brebner III

New Orleans has a new defense for 2025. Our Tripp Brebner looks at the new IDP opportunities in Brandon Staley's scheme.

06/19/25 Read More
 

Reading the New Defense: Atlanta Falcons

Tripp Brebner III

Atlanta has a new defense for 2025. Our Tripp Brebner looks at the new IDP opportunities in Jeff Ulbrich's scheme.

06/13/25 Read More
 

Reading the Defense: Week 18

Tripp Brebner III

Tripp Brebner reviews defensive backs' performance to date for lessons learned.

01/04/25 Read More