Busts on the Indianapolis Colts

Busts can ruin your fantasy team's drive to a championship. Our staff searches for them on the Colts.

Footballguys Staff's Busts on the Indianapolis Colts Footballguys Staff Published 07/09/2024

As we race toward August, Footballguys.com will look at one team per weekday with our quick-hitting Team Busts feature, where we check out the players we think will disappoint this year. 

Go Deeper: See in-depth projections for every Lions player here >>>

This is a weekday series that will stretch through July 30. If you like this and want another, come back the next workday. Another will be here.

Busts We Are Avoiding on the Colts

We asked the Footballguys staff to identify a player they're uncomfortable drafting at their current price.

Reasons Anthony Richardson Could Be a Bust

  • Jason Wood: He's only slightly overvalued if he can stay healthy but QB is such a deep position this year that you're better off waiting a few more rounds and grabbing a skill position player where others are targeting Richardson. 
  • Jeff Haseley: I'm not convinced that Richardson will be a bust, but his acquisition cost already accounts for high expectations. While he can deliver impressive rushing numbers as a quarterback, we can't be certain whether he'll be an effective and productive passer.
  • Phil Alexander: Richardson can easily make me eat this fade, but part of his appeal last season was a QB16 ADP. Now that he goes in Round 5, I'd rather wait 50 picks and scoop Jayden Daniels, who should approximate Richardson's passing and rushing stats.
  • Andy Hicks: Richardson can exceed his ADP, but his downside is much worse. Finishing games will be a good start. Until he respects his body and the opposing defenses, other options are more attractive. 
  • Nick Whalen: Richardson has started only 17 games in the last four seasons, but he's priced near his ceiling which is risky for a small sample size.
Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Footballguys Staff

 

Drake Maye: Why the Industry is Catching Up to Our Optimism

Jason Wood

Jason Wood spotlights Drake Maye and why we've projected him as a Top-3 fantasy quarterback since February.

06/03/26 Read More
 

4 Second-Year Players Poised to Surge in 2026

David Zacharias

A deep dive into a quartet of second-year players shows why they are set to break out this season.

06/02/26 Read More
 

2026 Tight End Preview: The Catch-A-Rising-Star Tier

Bob Harris

Sorting out the chaos with a big-picture look at fantasy-specific news, notes, and analysis from around the NFL.

06/02/26 Read More
 

5 Undervalued Running Backs You Should Target

The Footballguys staff finds value at the running back position.

06/02/26 Read More
 

3 Running Backs Who Are Overvalued

Footballguys staff members discuss overvalued running backs.

06/02/26 Read More
 

DeVonta Smith: The NFL's Best Wingman Is Ready to Fly Solo

Jason Wood

Jason Wood spotlights DeVonta Smith and his readiness to jump into the top-12 conversation in 2026.

06/02/26 Read More