2025 NFL Rookie Rankings: Top 12 Safeties

An early look at our staff's top safeties in the 2025 rookie class.

Footballguys Staff's 2025 NFL Rookie Rankings: Top 12 Safeties Footballguys Staff Published 01/29/2025

© Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

RELATED: See our staff's top players at the IDP positions.
Defensive Lineman | Edge Rusher | Linebacker | Cornerback | Safety

Recently, we asked the Footballguys staff for their top rookies at each position. Over the next several weeks, we'll get deeper into the 2025 draft class and release our massive 2025 Footballguys Rookie Guide (for offense) after the Super Bowl. For now, here's a quick look at how our staff sees the safety position.

Remember that it is early in the process. Showcase events like the Senior Bowl and Shrine Bowl will allow us to better compare these players, and the NFL Combine will add even more clarity.

Key

  • Rank: the player's rank at the position.
  • Pts: the number of points the player gained in the voting; the max changes based on how many staff members participated and how deep the voting was, but bigger numbers are always better.
  • Firsts: the number of first-place votes the player received from a staff member.
RankSafetySchoolPtsFirsts
1tNick EmmanworiSouth Carolina191
1tMalaki StarksGeorgia191
3Andrew MukubaTexas140
4Xavier WattsNotre Dame130
5tKamari RamseyUSC80
5tMalachi MooreAlabama80
5tLathan RansomOhio State80
8tSebastian CastroMissouri60
8tKevin Winston Jr.Penn State60
10Billy Bowman Jr.Oklahoma40
11Michael TaaffeTexas30
12Jaylen ReedPenn State20

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Footballguys Staff

 

Is Trevor Lawrence Finally Elite?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether Trevor Lawrence's growth under Liam Coen is set to continue.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Should You Draft Bhayshul Tuten or Chris Rodriguez?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether they prefer incumbent Bhayshul Tuten or newcomer Chris Rodriguez Jr.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Brenton Strange: Is He a Tight End to Target?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses Brenton Strange and whether his late-season surge in 2025 is predictive of his value this year.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Will Brian Thomas Jr. Return to Relevance?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses how to rank the veteran receiver trio of Thomas, Meyers, and Washington this season.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Will Travis Hunter Focus on Cornerback?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether Travis Hunter will focus primarily on defense in 2026.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Daniel Jones: Was Last Season a Fluke?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses where to tier Daniel Jones and whether 2025's performance was an anomaly.

04/20/26 Read More