What to Do If Your Fantasy Team Just Lost Joe Burrow

Moves to make this week if your fantasy team lost Joe Burrow to injury.

Sigmund Bloom's What to Do If Your Fantasy Team Just Lost Joe Burrow Sigmund Bloom Published 09/15/2025

© Cara Owsley/ The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images joe burrow

For the third time, we've watched Joe Burrow go down with a season-ending injury. A ripple in the force that disrupted an otherwise scintillating Football Sunday. All of us are poorer as football fans. Burrow was one of the main characters in the Great American Novel that is every NFL season, and the unfolding epic story won't be as good without him. If you drafted Joe Burrow this year, you got a dud against the Browns, and another week-killing number when Burrow left the game vs. the Jaguars early with a toe injury that will probably end his season. While there's no solace for Bengals fans, who lost another prime year of their franchise quarterback's career, fantasy teams can actually recover from this somewhat well without using that many resources. Here's a plan to be the balm for your wound if you were depending on him.

Plan A: Spend big on the waiver wire for or trade for Daniel Jones.

In public and casual leagues, Jones might not have even been added after his huge Week 1 performance because of his reputation for disappointment and his Week 2 matchup against the Broncos. He aced that test and faces an easier schedule of Tennessee, the Rams, Las Vegas, Arizona, the Chargers, Tennessee again, and Pittsburgh through Week 9. He has been an elite QB1, and there's no reason to think that he won't at least be a viable fantasy start as long as he's healthy. Jones' past will make him cheaper than his fantasy numbers to date would dictate.  

Plan B: Add Jake Browning from the waiver wire for a reasonable price.

Browning is available in every league, and Burrow teams shouldn't have much competition, as most teams are satisfied with their quarterback production to date. Browning was a top 10 fantasy quarterback when he replaced Burrow for the last third of 2023. He's an aggressive, even reckless passer, and he'll courageously pull the ball down and run even though he's not a supreme athlete, especially when the goal line is in sight. The defensive woes will force Browning to play the way he did against the Jaguars to keep the Bengals in games. Think of him as a discount Baker Mayfield. If you do add Browning to take Burrow's place, maybe add a second quarterback this week with a better matchup than the Vikings, which Cincinnati faces on the road.

Plan C: Trade for Jordan Love or Wait for Geno Smith to be Dropped**UPDATED**

It's likely neither of these guys was drafted to be their fantasy team's starter. One could be available via trade and another could be on the waiver wire after a Monday night stinker. Smith has been given the green light to be an aggressive passer, and he has an array of weapons that could put him back on the fringe of the top 10 fantasy quarterbacks, where he has been before. While that green light led to three interceptions in a poor showing by Smith, he should bounce back against Washington in Wee, and will continue to be the main engine of the offense with the run blocking stuck in neutral. If Smith is dropped, he can start for you for the next two weeks. Love is playing as well as he did in the second half of 2023, when he was a top 10 fantasy quarterback, but the Packers' defense is so good that he isn't getting a chance to get much passing volume in the second half of games to push him even higher in the weekly ranks.

Plan D: Cobble together a bargain-basement QBBC from the waiver wire.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Footballguys.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Sigmund Bloom

 

Sabotage Drop of the Week: Week 9

Sigmund Bloom

Who should you drop so they'll bring down someone else's team instead of yours?

11/03/26 Read More
 

Rent-A-Defense: Week 9

Sigmund Bloom

Sigmund Bloom runs down defenses with good matchups in Week 9 that could be on your waiver wire.

11/03/26 Read More
 

What You Need to Know From Week 8

Sigmund Bloom

A game-by-game summary of the crucial fantasy takeaways from last week's NFL action.

11/03/26 Read More
 

The Top Waiver Wire Pickups of Week 9

Sigmund Bloom

The most valuable Week 9 waiver additions.

11/02/26 Read More
 

Cutdown Day News You Need to Know

Sigmund Bloom

Sigmund Bloom tells you all of the important news from the chaos of roster cutdown day and why it matters for fantasy football

08/27/25 Read More
 

Buy Low, Sell High: Week 8

Sigmund Bloom

Chaos is a ladder. Here's a look at who to move toward and away from as we approach the midpoint of the 2026 season.

10/29/26 Read More