Dynasty, in Theory: One Trade from Four Angles

There are many ways to look at any given move.

Adam Harstad's Dynasty, in Theory: One Trade from Four Angles Adam Harstad Published 11/21/2026

After last week's column on the (potential lack of) value of denying players to your leaguemates, a reader reached out with a dilemma he was facing in his league. His team was in 2nd place, but a series of win-now trades had left it aging and potentially in decline after 2026. The manager of the first-place team approached him with a strong offer to acquire Trey McBride.

The reader had a strong backup in Isaiah Likely, but the trade saw little immediate help coming back his way—most of the value was in the form of picks that were several years away from maturity. Overall, his team got worse in the short run, while his top rival's got better. Surely in this case there would be some additional value to declining the trade and keeping McBride away from his top competitor?

In theory, yes, keeping points away from the best team is more valuable than keeping points away from the worst team. But think about everything that would have to happen for this trade to "matter".

  1. Both the reader and his rival need to meet in the playoffs.
  2. The rival needs to win.
  3. The margin of victory needs to be less than the delta produced by the McBride trade.

I love this question because, in my opinion, there are no fewer than four different angles to consider.

Angle #1: Is Denying Points to the Top Team More Valuable?

There's a good chance the two teams never even meet in the playoffs—and that chance is increased because the two teams in question are currently the Top 2 seeds. If the rival holds on to the #1 seed, the reader would need to fall to the #4 or #5 seed to wind up on the same side of the playoff bracket; with a #2, #3, or #6 seed, he's guaranteed to avoid the rival until the championship game at the earliest. And it's unlikely that they'd both make it that far. 

Historically, higher-seeded teams win a little bit under 58% of their matchups in the playoffs, so even if these two teams secure the top two seeds, there's only a 1-in-3 chance of them meeting in the championship. If the reader falls to the #3 seed, the chances of meeting fall below 20%.

That puts the value of denying points higher than the default 1 in 11, but still significantly lower than the direct value of adding or subtracting points from your own lineup.

Angle #2: How Likely Are the Points to Matter?

But let's say they do meet. If the higher seed wins 58% of the time, there's a 42% chance the reader wins outright and renders this entire discussion academic; he gets the benefit of all that long-term value without any short-term cost.

And even in the 58% of situations where the rival wins, it doesn't matter unless the delta from the McBride trade is greater than the final margin of victory. Which is a fairly big ask, because the median margin of victory in fantasy football is massive.

In 2021, I compared the most closely matched teams in several of my leagues in terms of average points per game. In one, I compared a team that averaged 114.4 points to a team that averaged 113.8 points. The median weekly difference in their scores was 34.2 points. Even closely matched teams are rarely scoring close to each other in any given week.

What are the odds that the delta from the McBride trade in a given week is greater than 30 points? Fairly low, I'd wager.

This is why I say managers should be more willing to take on short-term pain for long-term gain. When you trade immediate production for future value and win anyway, or when you lose but would have lost even without the trade, you're essentially getting that future value for free. You sacrificed nothing for it.

Angle #3: Those Future Picks Will Likely Be Earlier Than You'd Think.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a ELITE subscription.

An ELITE subscription is required to access content for Dynasty leagues. If this league is not a Dynasty league, you can edit your leagues here.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Adam Harstad

 

Regression Alert: Week 11

Adam Harstad

Just because players regress doesn't mean they're "due".

11/19/26 Read More
 

Odds and Ends: Week 11

Adam Harstad

How to adjust your strategy in pick pools as the season goes on.

11/19/26 Read More
 

Rent-a-Kicker: Week 11

Adam Harstad

Finding startable kicker production on your fantasy waiver wire.

11/17/26 Read More
 

Dynasty, in Theory: Deny Points and You Deny Yourself

Adam Harstad

Is it worth burning a roster spot to play keep-away from your leaguemates?

11/14/26 Read More
 

Regression Alert: Week 10

Adam Harstad

Is Vegas suddenly bad at making money? (I wouldn't bet on it.)

11/13/26 Read More
 

Odds and Ends: Week 10

Adam Harstad

The quickest way to grow your bankroll (if you actually had an edge).

11/12/26 Read More