2025 NFL Draft - Day 2 & 3 Fantasy Winners and Losers
By Sigmund Bloom - Exclusive to Footballguys
The following feature is a free preview of our content. If you like it, click here to sign up for access to our Footballguys Premium Subscriptions, and you'll get all of our content. We're so sure you'll love it that we have an industry-leading 30-day MoneyBack Guarantee, so there's zero risk.
The first round threw us enough twists to keep our brains occupied for weeks, but the developments of the second and third days also end up producing fantasy storylines that will end up mattering in leagues this year. Which picks and players stood out as the biggest potential winners and losers because of picks that happened after the first round?
Fantasy Football Winners
RJ Harvey (RB-DEN) - This running back class didn't really live up to hype when it comes to resculpting the fantasy landscape, but Harvey emerged as the biggest winner from the big third tier that the NFL decided no need to break into until the third day (and for some teams not until late in the third day). Harvey's second-round (pick 60) draft capital bodes well, and he lands on a team with a run-first mentality and a weak enough depth chart that he could lead the backfield in touches in his rookie year. You should feel great if you took him in early best ball drafts.
Bhayshul Tuten (RB-JAX) - Tuten's combination of acceleration, speed, and contact balance didn't crack the second day, but he was one of the earliest third-day picks, and to a team with Liam Coen as the head coach. Coen's Bucs took Bucky Irving in the fourth round last year, and Coen said that he wanted his backs to run the ball like Irving did. We all know what happened in the Bucs' backfield last year and how big of a hit Irving was. Tuten could make this story a rerun.
D'Andre Swift, Roschon Johnson (RB-CHI) - The Bears were interested in Ashton Jeanty, but that might have been more about Jeanty than how they felt about Swift and Johnson. Perhaps new head coach Ben Johnson's feelings about Swift are more positive than their divorce indicated. The Bears didn't take a running back until the seventh round. This was a very deep and diverse class of backs, so if Johnson had a high priority on taking a back to his liking to possibly eventually overtake Swift and Johnson, he passed on many opportunities to do so. If you don't like Swift, invest in Johnson or the seventh-round rookie Kyle Monangai.
Kyle Monangai (RB-CHI), Jaydon Blue, Phil Mafah (RB-DAL), Jacory Croskey-Merritt (RB-WAS) - These third-day picks are worth monitoring because of the potential for them to move quickly up the depth chart. Monangai is a very efficient and hard-nosed back who is also a Matt Waldman favorite. If Ben Johnson doesn't like D'Andre Swift's decision-making as a runner, Monangai is the opposite type of runner. Blue gives the Cowboys' running game speed that Javonte Williams and Miles Sanders lack, and Mafah is a big back who could be a better between-the-tackles option than the veteran duo with some development. Croskey-Merritt is a dynamic mover who was underrated throughout the draft process. Brian Robinson Jr and Austin Ekeler are both free agents next year.
Tyler Shough (QB-NO) - All of the buzz about the NFL liking Shough a lot ended up being true, or at least the Saints liking him a lot. Shough went to New Orleans with the 40th pick and should get a chance to start - maybe even this year, with the Derek Carr situation looking dire. Shough has some dynasty superflex appeal, if only because he'll have a chance to stake his claim as their quarterback of the future. If you don't believe in him because of how many chances he got to fail before succeeding in his seventh year - a chance afforded to few quarterbacks - then be happy that this pick will push him up the dynasty superflex rookie draft board.
Terrance Ferguson (TE-LAR) - Ferguson was taken earlier than expected, and he's kinda sorta the Rams' first-round pick after they traded out of the first and took him with their first pick at #46. Ferguson is more a project than a finished product, but he has above-average athleticism, and obviously, the team sees him as a future starter. The Rams are a good, offensive-minded organization that has maximized production from the talents of mid-round skill position picks.
Isaac TeSlaa (WR-DET) - How badly did the Lions want TeSlaa? They gave up three third-round picks to get him and two sixth-round picks. The team loves his run blocking and his potential as a big downfield target. TeSlaa has the size, speed, and athleticism profile of an alpha outside receiver and was just scratching the surface of his potential at Arkansas after dominating a lower level of competition at Hillsdale. Like the Rams, the Lions have been hitting on skill position picks in the Brad Holmes/Dan Campbell era, so this pick deserves our attention.
Geno Smith (QB-LV) - After the Raiders added Ashton Jeanty with their first round pick, they added a great power slot who also loves to block in second round pick Jack Bech, a high ceiling developmental tackle (Charles Grant) and solid swing tackle candidate (Caleb Rogers) in the third, and a big wideout with field-stretching speed (Dont'e Thornton Jr.) in the fourth. They also did not draft a quarterback until the sixth round. The Raiders spent five of their first six picks on offense, and it appears that they are going to give Smith every opportunity to become the entrenched starter of this retooled unit.
Chase Brown (RB-CIN) - The Bengals had Ohio State teammates Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson in for pre-draft visits, but didn't take a running back until the sixth round. Tajh Brooks is a formidable back and could impress if Brown misses time, but the threat of the Bengals adding a back to create a committee has passed. Their 2023 fifth-round pick, Brown, is set up to remain a feature back and should move up in draft ADP, perhaps even a whole round or more from his pre-draft Underdog ADP of 38.
Woody Marks (RB-HOU) - Marks was a third-day pick, but the Texans took him in the fourth round, and he should have a chance to show them he deserves more work in the future. Dameon Pierce is a free agent in 2026, and Joe Mixon is in the autumn of his career, so this is a good spot for a mid-round running back. Marks has passing-down skills that should allow him to carve out a role as a rookie.
Drake Maye (QB-NE) - After the team added the first offensive lineman drafted with the #4 pick, the Patriots took a speedy running back who is excellent in pass protection (TreVeyon Henderson), a speedy wide receiver (Kyle Williams), and an athletic center (Jared Wilson) on the second day. The directive to build around Maye is clear, which gives him a better chance to succeed.
Will Howard (QB-PIT) - We shouldn't get too excited - Howard did last until the sixth round in the quarterback desperate NFL draft - but with only Mason Rudolph and Skylar Thompson on the roster at his position, he has a chance to start at some point in the next year or two. Howard is big and athletic, and he can execute the play when it works. He's not going to elevate the offense or be a playmaker at quarterback, but in superflex leagues, he could have some value in the future.
Fantasy Football Losers
Shedeur Sanders (QB-CLE) - It's hard to know exactly what happened, but clearly the reports of Sanders turning teams off in interviews were accurate. We just didn't know exactly how accurate until Sanders was still there in the fifth round. He did go to a team with a vacancy at quarterback but wasn't even the first quarterback the Browns selected - that's Oregon's Dillon Gabriel - so Sanders is going to have to show that he has learned from this experience to make the opening day roster. It doesn't seem like other teams would be rushing to sign Sanders to the active roster if he ends up on the practice squad. He's either going to be one of the best values because the NFL unfairly disrespected him, or he'll be a falling knife, a wasted pick for the Browns and anyone who takes in dynasty rookie drafts.
Rhamondre Stevenson, Antonio Gibson (RB-NE) - These backs aren't compelling enough to keep second-round pick TreVeyon Henderson on the sidelines. Stevenson should plummet in best ball drafts, and Gibson might not be draftable. It's too bad for Gibson, who had a chance to take over the backfield if the team didn't add anyone of consequence, although there were reports that the team wanted to add explosiveness in the backfield before the draft.
Quinshon Judkins, Dylan Sampson (RB-CLE) - At the end of the second day, Judkins looked like he could become the new Nick Chubb for the Browns. By the end of the fourth round, his prospects looked more like that of a poor man's David Montgomery. The Browns double-dipped in this running back class, adding the quickness and burst of Sampson to the power and bad intentions that Judkins runs with. It's possible that Judkins could distinguish himself enough that this won't a true committee, but at least for this year Jerome Ford and his passing down abilities are still around. The Browns are also the least exciting offense in the league and may not be moving out of the basement anytime soon.
Tank Dell (WR-HOU) - Dell was already looking like a long shot to play in 2025 after suffering his second catastrophic season-ending leg injury in two years. The Texans took both Iowa State wide receivers (Jayden Higgins in the second and Jaylin Noel in the third) in a development that could be an indication that they aren't counting on anything from Dell in the future.
Blake Corum (RB-LAR) - It seemed like the Rams liked Corum enough to play him more than a mere backup going into the 2024 season. Now it's not clear how the Rams feel about Corum after they gave up a sixth-round pick - which they know how to turn into a contributor - to move up 10 spots in the fourth round to add Jarquez Hunter, a good back between the tackles. We'll be monitoring the competition for playing time between the two in camp this summer.
CONTINUED...