Welcome to Week 11 of the 2026 Footballguys Roundtable. Our intrepid panel of fantasy pundits discusses and debates four topics every week. We split the conversation into separate features.
This week's roundtable features these four topics:
Let's roll...
Matt Waldman: Which NFC QB do you prefer for the rest of the year and why?
- Jordan Love 19.4 Fpts/gm
- Jared Goff 18.9 Fpts/gm
- Kirk Cousins 18.6 Fpts/gm
- Caleb Williams 18.4 Fpts/gm
Choose.
Maurile Tremblay: I'd take Caleb Williams.
He had a rough Week 2 loss to Minnesota, a 9-3 game he left in the fourth quarter with the hamstring tear. Since coming back, he has played the best football of his career. In the five games he has started and finished, Chicago has averaged 36.2 points. He's also the best runner of the four and opened the season with two rushing touchdowns.
The risk is pressure. Defenses that blitz heavily gave him his two worst games: the Minnesota loss and the four-interception game against Tampa Bay. He still has a trip to Minnesota left on the schedule. Chicago also runs the ball more than any other team, which limits his passing volume.
Jordan Love is the close second, but he's taken a beating all season and has a tough remaining schedule filled with cold-weather games.
Corey Spala: Jared Goff has a favorable schedule for the rest of the season. Unfortunately, he has a tough Week 15 fantasy playoff matchup against Minnesota and Brian Flores' defense, and it is a critical week to need your starters to score points.
Detroit's defense has suffered two critical season-ending injuries, which may result in their offense needing to stay in the game and pass more. Maurile makes a great point that Jordan Love will be playing outdoor games in the cold weather, and Meng noted the volatility in Caleb Williams.
The process of elimination has me wanting Kirk Cousins. In addition, he has a favorable rest-of-the-season schedule. Cousins is familiar and capable of running the Minnesota system. Cousins offers a safe floor with the upside needed for the rest of the season.
Jason Wood: All four are top-12 points-per-game quarterbacks this season, which is a remarkable feat—even if Kirk Cousins built most of his year-to-date value playing for the Raiders before being traded back to Minnesota. Of the four, Cousins actually has the easiest remaining schedule, drawing Detroit (easiest) and Washington (second easiest) in Weeks 15 and 16 before a relatively unchallenging fantasy championship matchup against the Jets in Week 17.
Still, am I really putting my fantasy title in the hands of Kirk Cousins over those other three signal-callers? If I must pick one, it's Jared Goff. The Lions' defense is terrible, the offense is fantastic, and he and his teammates are seasoned veterans ready for a deep playoff push. My mind says Cousins, my heart says Goff.