MISSION
The mission of this column—and a lot of my work—is to bridge the gap between the fantasy and reality of football analysis.
The goal of this feature is to provide you with actionable recommendations that will help you get results. The fundamental mission is to get the process right.
While it's a rush to see the box score or highlights and claim you made the right calls, doing so without a sustainable process makes success ephemeral.
The Top 10 will cover topics that attempt to get the process right (reality) while understanding that fantasy owners may not have time to wait for the necessary data to determine the best course of action (fantasy).
My specialty is film analysis. I've been scouting the techniques, concepts, and physical skills of offensive skill talent as my business for over 20 years.
The Top 10 will give you fantasy-oriented insights rooted in football analysis that have made the Rookie Scouting Portfolio one of the two most purchased independent draft guides among NFL scouts. This is what University of Kentucky Assistant GM Alex Brown has told me over the past 8-10 years.
Sigmund Bloom's Waiver Wire piece, available every Monday night during the season, is a viable source of information to kick-start your week as a fantasy GM.
STRAIGHT, NO CHASER: WEEK 8'S CLIFF'S NOTES
The article below will provide expanded thoughts and supporting visuals for the bullet points in this section.
The Top 10: The Cliff's Notes
- Emmett Johnson has been showing all year why he was Matt Waldman's pre-draft RB2 in the RSP.
- Justin Jefferson no longer has to be Kyler Murray's snack lackey with Kirk Cousins back in town.
- Jordyn Tyson is a volatile fantasy prospect, but if Kellen Moore continues using him like Jarvis Landry, Tyson's fantasy GMs will be happy for the rest of the year.
- Parker Washington will remain a long-term fantasy starter because he wins the ball as well as Ja'Marr Chase.
- Xavier Hutchinson earned some love from C.J. Stroud during the week and against Cleveland, but can his JuJu Smith-Schuster impersonation yield him weekly starter value?
- Seth McGowan has performed well enough for a change-of-pace role. Is it McGowan or the defenses he faced? It's a little of both, but take him and let future opponents prove otherwise
- Chuba Hubbard is the rare case of a player who has incrementally improved his game and hasn't been labeled a reserve while doing so.
- Cade Klubnik's extended NFL debut was what you'd expect from a rookie. He's not ready to be a weekly starter, but there are promising moments.
- J.J. McCarthy's performance against the Commanders was what you'd expect from a developmental starter with only 17 starts in two different offenses, one of them he was asked to learn midseason.
- Cam Skattebo has top-three fantasy value based solely on his skills, but can he last long enough for the Giants to build a team around him where he can dominate before he falls apart?
1. Emmett Johnson RSP Pre-Draft Scouting Report
I'm not a fan of the NFL Combine. It has its place. It can provide a helpful layer of intel for prospects, but it also creates a ton of red herrings for analysts, scouts, and teams.
NFL Combine and Pro Day measurements are so flawed that we're still in the wild-west era of metric evaluation for athletic performance in the NFL.
Last year, I shared with Rookie Scouting Portfolio subscribers that Harold Fannin Jr. was most likely to become an NFL Combine red herring -- a player with strong draft capital heading into the Combine but then falls off the map after the workouts. Here's where you can read Fannin's Pre-Draft Scouting Report from the Rookie Scouting Portfolio.
Emmett Johnson was my prediction to become 2026's NFL Combine Red Herring. You can read the full scouting report at my site. Here are parts of the elevator pitch:
RB Emmett Johnson’s RSP Scouting Profile
RSP Ranking: RB2
Jersey No. 21
Height/Weight: 5’10” / 202 School: Nebraska
Comparison Spectrum: Dalvin Cook – X/Devonta Freeman – Duke Johnson – Jordan James
Depth of Talent Score: 84.6 = Rotational Starter: Executes at a starter level in a role that plays to their strengths. Johnson is on the cusp of the Starter Tier: Starting immediately with a large role and learning on the go.
Games Tracked (Opponent/Date/Link):
- Cincinnati ’25
- Michigan ‘25
- UCLA ‘25
- Penn State ‘25
- Iowa ‘25
The Elevator Pitch: Emmett Johnson’s pre-draft trajectory reminds me of Harold Fannin Jr.’s. They gained acclaim during the season based on their on-field performances.
There was legitimate excitement to see them perform at the NFL Combine. When they didn’t perform to expectations of the public, the excitement plummeted to the point that you could hear an echo out in the world if you broached their names.
Last year, I detailed how Fannin’s “bad NFL Combine” was an overstated and overrated analysis point. Fannin had a strong rookie year and could be taking over a lead role in the Browns’ passing game.
The gist of the analysis was about interpreting the tests, knowing how much weight to give them compared to other sources of information, and who else compared stylistically to Fannin in the NFL with similar production.
This year’s candidate for “The NFL Combine Threw a Red Herring into the Collective’s Draft Analysis” is Johnson.
Let’s begin with the 4.56-second, 40-Yard Dash. It’s the same time as Aaron Jones Sr., and they had similar dimensions at that point in their careers. The number is fast enough.
So is the 4.29-second, 20-yard shuttle. A 4.30-second mark is the RSP’s minimum standard guideline for the Starter Tier. Both marks are in the Starter Tier, for whatever that’s worth when considering that the timing technology is either second- or third-tier technology with a high variation that makes it much less reliable than they want you to believe.
These were underwhelming marks for Johnson because the media and draft culture have been brainwashed to overvalue Relative Athletic Score percentiles. RAS is an entertaining and informative resource.
There’s value to knowing the percentile that an NFL Combine participant’s performance is relative to his peers. It unintentionally creates noise for the signal.
That signal is knowing what the minimum expected times should be for each position based on physical dimensions, style of movement, and expected role (elite starter, starter, rotational contributor, situational contributor, reserve, and free agent.
These factors provide valuable context well beyond RAS percentiles. When Johnson ran a 7.32-second, Three Cone Drill, the RAS Percentile Apostles of the Pseudo-Science Church of Oblong Money Ball that Bounces Too Funny for Predictability in Everything Baseball Does immediately cited the 32nd percentile like they were saying, “A-men,” from the pews of Lucas Oil Stadium.
Let’s dig deeper than the good book, shall we?
A Three-Cone Drill time commensurate with a starting RB in the RSP is seven seconds-flat or less. Here are backs who contributed at a high level with no better than Reserve Tier Three-Cone marks of 7.20 seconds.
- Kenny Gainwell – 7.26 seconds
- Dalvin Cook – 7.27 seconds
- Samaje Perine – 7.25 seconds
- Jamaal Williams – 7.25 seconds
- Chris Carson – 7.53 seconds
- Devin Singletary – 7.32 seconds
These backs came in all shapes and sizes...The player on this list that stands alone and was arguably the best of the group was Dalvin Cook. I was there when the SPARQ Denomination of the Percentile Apostles of the Pseudo-Science Church of Oblong Money Ball that Bounces Too Funny for Predictability in Everything Baseball Does were ready to doom Cook to football hell because of his Three Cone Drill and Vertical.
It wasn’t pretty. Here’s what I shared about Cook that they didn’t consider – if they did, they couldn’t do anything about it because of the limits of the data collection method of the drills.
The three-cone drill approximates changes of direction we see from players performing lateral cuts. The correct assumption is that most running backs make lateral cuts when they change direction.
Dalvin Cook was an exception. Much of his change of direction was rooted in curvilinear movement – bending around an obstacle. The best at this skill can bend tight enough at a high rate of speed that it can be as effective as making cuts.
Cook didn’t even use lateral cuts as a runner. In some cases, his feet moved in place like little pistons before he rotated in the direction he wanted to go. Watch for yourself on YouTube, and you’ll see it...Because the general public and the Apostles of the Oblong Money Ball (I ain’t writing that mouthful again…) didn’t consider that their methodology for measuring performance can’t be one-size-fits-all, Cook’s stock fell in the public eye. The Vikings knew enough to take Cook in the second round...
...In addition to everything else mentioned, the Three Cone Drill is not an everyday football drill. It’s one of the more difficult drills to perform with the technique to maximize the result, and only 13 percent of the Combine participants did it.
Johnson was the only RB to do it this year. The Three Cone Drill has the lowest participation rate for a while now, and it’s because it’s a skill unto itself rather than an exercise to mimic the true skill.
If a player does well, and it matches what I see on the field, I’ll cite it for two reasons:
- If they had to train for it, they went above and beyond to get the technique down.
- If they didn’t train for it and ran well, they are even quicker on the field than what the drill indicates.
If a player doesn’t do well, but it doesn’t match what he does on the field, I throw it out. If too much is made about this drill. I get to tell you why it’s a bullshit drill.
Unlike Cook, Emmett Johnson executes cuts with his game. Like Cook, he leans hard on curvilinear movement. Johnson also flips his hips efficiently to make 90-degree turns without the need of cutting. Like Devin Singletary, he processes information fast and can be a step ahead.
Repeatedly, Johnson identifies pre-snap tells from defenders and leverages it for quick cutbacks or bounces to open space. Post-snap, Johnson has precise feet to press deep enough into the line to work past a defensive push or penetration, buying time to assess and manipulate.
Johnson also runs a lot of gap plays. There’s not a lot of need for cutbacks, bounces, or reversals of field in this scheme. The back plays with pace and stride length if needed but otherwise hits the crease hard and without hesitation.
Johnson isn’t just a gap runner. He’s experienced and skilled with Duo and varieties of Zone.
Johnson has precise footwork. His jump cuts may not be as electric as the altar boys confirmed by the Apostles of the Money Ball, but he gets his feet over contact and alters stride and pacing with his steps with precision....Johnson is a good finisher who drags and pushes box defenders and wins collisions with linebackers and safeties in the open field.
His third-down game is NFL-ready as a pass-catcher on check downs and leak routes. He has shown potential to develop an expanded route tree...
...Johnson may never become a top-tier starter, but at the very least, I believe he’s a high-end contributor who can become a good RB2 in a committee or a top-tier reserve who delivers high-end starter production when the franchise runner gets hurt early in the season.
That’s the worst case I can see for Johnson if he’s a healthy, well-behaved football player during his NFL career. The best case is that Johnson has a run as a lead back or starter that lasts 3-5 years.
2. Making Up for Lost Time: Justin Jefferson
We all know the Vikings organization went on tilt when they let Sam Darnold walk, and then watched him become a vital cog for a Super Bowl winning team in their conference. They got impatient with J.J. McCarthy and then made a desperation move to Kyler Murray.
The argument has been that Kevin O'Connell is a QB whisperer. He may be, but as a head coach, he doesn't have the time to do it. Even most NFL QB coaches on teams don't have time to do it.
Many lack the wherewithal. Coaching players on skills beyond the game plan is left in the hands of the players and their private coaches.
There's talk in recent years of teams thinking about hiring these types of coaches for their quarterbacks. I'm not holding my breath, but I'll give them a callback number so I don't have to wait in queue while the play muzak.
Just as we all knew the Vikings tilted when Darnold won the Super Bowl, we all knew the return of Kirk Cousins to Minnesota made the most sense. Minnesota has an excellent defense, a ground game with more potential than the stats indicate, and a quartet of pass-catchers who should be earning yardage on par with the Cowboys' passing attack, if not the Bengals.
Cousins played in the offense and worked with every starting pass-catcher other than Jauan Jennings, and he's back to playing good football after a couple of years working through his Achilles tear. Cousins wasn't going to walk into the Packers game and light up the Green Bay defense after two and a half years playing in different schemes and different teams.
Still, Cousins can manage the game, distribute the ball, find options while still in the pocket, and not physically, mentally, and emotionally wear out teammates with a self-centered style of quarterbacking that only works in some conferences of college football. He also knows something everyone else knew: The fastest way to lose your job in Minnesota -- hamstring excuse or not -- make Justin Jefferson's stats look ordinary.
Jefferson didn't match Ja'Marr Chase's 231 receiving yards this weekend, but 74 receiving yards was his best total in a month and his third-best this year.
Most notable was the intent to get him the ball in every way possible.
Kirk Cousins and the Vikings getting Justin Jefferson involved in every way possible that no longer included JJettas being Kyler Murray's hotdog vendor and snack lackey... https://t.co/ea4xiuK0NO
— Matt Waldman (@MattWaldman) November 17, 2026
You can start Jefferson safely in most leagues again. In case you were having a case of the Kyler's didn't understand the assignment.