Underdog Pick 'Em Week 5

Dan Hindery's Underdog Pick 'Em Week 5 Dan Hindery Published 10/06/2023

Underdog's Fantasy Pick ‘Em is a fun way to test our powers of prediction against the market. The two keys to success are picking the best players to target and taking advantage of correlations where we can increase our odds. You play Pick ‘Em by simply choosing "Higher" or "Lower" on at least two player props. If you choose successfully, this is the payout structure:

  • Two picks = 3X
  • Three picks = 6X
  • Four picks = 10X
  • Five picks = 20X

In this weekly article, we will list our favorite plays of the week and the reasoning behind them.

Week 3 Review

Overall Picks (5-9 on the week, 26-16 on the season)
Overall Units (-3, -2 on the season)

  • We swung for the fences with a 20-to-1 prop with five running back receiving overs. Miles Sanders (16.5) came up just short with 13 yards. All four of the others went over. Bijan Robinson (25.5) had 32 receiving yards, Jerome Ford (12.5) had 19, Raheem Mostert (14.5) had 36, and James Cook (19.5) had 48.
  • We went 0-for-5, taking higher passing and receiving totals in the Steelers/Texans matchup. The theory of the play was that the five were highly correlated and would hit over 5% of the time (making it a positive expected value at 20-to-1 odds) if the game was a competitive shootout. That game script did not play out, but the correlation held up.
  • We went 1-for-3 on the assortment of unders. Two players we thought might be limited due to nagging injuries exceeded expectations.

Lessons learned: We were four Miles Sanders receiving yards away from a huge week. The process on the Steelers-Texans was solid, we did not get the game script we were hoping for with the Steelers passing game struggling due to in-game injuries and general poor play. If there is a lesson here, maybe it is to stick to three- or four-way entries instead of going for five at a time.

Week 5 Picks

1. Rookie Targets

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a HALL OF FAME subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

Quarterback Rankings and Tiers: One Staffer's Opinion

Dave Kluge

Quarterback rankings provided by Dave Kluge, with explanations on where and why he strays from consensus opinions.

07/15/25 Read More
 
 
 
 
The Myth of Geno Smith
Jason Wood
07/14/25 Read More

More by Dan Hindery

 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: July

Dan Hindery

Quantifying Long-term Player Values

07/03/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: June

Dan Hindery

Long-term player values and dynasty trade targets

06/03/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: May

Dan Hindery

Long-term player values for dynasty leagues

05/02/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: April

Dan Hindery

Long-Term Player Values for Dynasty Leagues

04/04/25 Read More
 

Stock Up, Stock Down: How the NFL Combine Moved Rookie ADP

Dan Hindery

Post-Combine ADP movement in Underdog Best Ball Drafts

03/10/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: March

Dan Hindery

Dynasty trade value can fluctuate; our Dan Hindery has this month's update for your dynasty leagues.

03/05/25 Read More