Welcome to the latest edition of AMA Recap! We'll be summarizing our bi-weekly Discord AMAs as we lead up to the 2025 NFL season. This week, Footballguys Analyst Mike Kashuba shares his thoughts on Quinshon Judkins, building a competitive dynasty roster, deep-roster tight end options, and a puzzling "this or that" scenario involving two former first-rounders.
Hall or Hill?
Hurl Bruce: I need a one-year keeper in a PPR league. Should I keep Breece Hall or Tyreek Hill? I already have Patrick Mahomes II, Brock Bowers, and CeeDee Lamb. We start two wide receivers, two running backs, and two flex spots that can be wide receivers, running backs, or tight ends.
Mike Kashuba: Hall is the riskier option for this year, but there's optimism for next season if he lands on a new team or earns a bigger role than expected. Hill has a solid path for 2025, but the coach-speak out of camp is odd. I'd go with Hill and then hammer running back and quarterback in the draft.
Quinshon Queries?
Mr. Landry: Quinshon Judkins has been dropping like a lead balloon in most rookie drafts I've seen. Are you still in on him, or has he lost his shine?
Mike Kashuba: I love the talent, but I'm not a lawyer and won't pretend to know what's going to happen there. I've moved him way down due to the uncertainty, but in rookie drafts, it's rare to find his level of talent in the early third or late second rounds. I'm still taking shots at the discount, but I wouldn't spend a first or early second with the current uncertainty.