Justin Jefferson: Truly Quarterback Proof

A deeper look at Justin Jefferson's success and why he's still one of the safest bets in fantasy.

Mike Kashuba's Justin Jefferson: Truly Quarterback Proof Mike Kashuba Published 05/21/2025

Death, Taxes, and Justin Jefferson's Fantasy Points

Few things in fantasy football are as dependable as Justin Jefferson's weekly production. Since entering the league, Jefferson has been a cornerstone asset, finishing as a top-five wide receiver on a per-game basis every season except his rookie year in 2020, when he began as a part-time player and erupted after the Minnesota Vikings' bye week.

In 2023, Jefferson had every reason to regress. Kirk Cousins suffered a season-ending injury, and Jefferson caught passes from a revolving door of backups: Joshua Dobbs, Jaren Hall, and Nick Mullens. Despite those challenges—and his own time missed due to injury—Jefferson still averaged over 100 receiving yards per game without Cousins under center.

RELATED: See all of our 2025 Player Spotlights here.

2024 rolls around, and there's hope on the horizon. The team takes J.J. McCarthy in the top ten, and signs Sam Darnold as a fixer-upper backup option. McCarthy ends up having to take a redshirt for his rookie season, and the fantasy community is posed with the impossible question - is Justin Jefferson good enough to produce with Darnold as his primary quarterback? That question pushed his average draft position (ADP) to WR5—ironically, the lowest mark of his career and his historical floor. He reminded the doubters that he doesn't need a fancy quarterback, just a functional arm to get him the ball. He finished as the No. 3 fantasy receiver on the season and No. 5 in points per game. 

Justin Jefferson's pitch to be a top receiver in 2025 is easy:

  1. He has a proven track record of elite production across all four of his NFL seasons.
  2. He has shown resilience in the face of poor quarterback play.
  3. With J.J. McCarthy likely taking over and Kevin O'Connell still orchestrating the offense, Jefferson's ceiling could be even higher.

© Joseph Rondone/The Republic / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images Justin Jefferson

Justin Jefferson's Opportunity Cost Versus Expectations

It's no secret that if fantasy managers want Jefferson on their rosters in 2025, they will have to pay up. He's a top-three pick in current average draft position (ADP) and the second receiver off the board. Footballguys' projections reflect that value. In our consensus outlook, Jefferson ranks as the No. 2 wide receiver.

Jefferson has hovered just under a 30% target share over his career, and the sheer volume of targets he commands keeps his floor relatively safe. He's in line for more of the same in 2025, even as T.J. Hockenson returns from injury and Jordan Addison gets his share. He's being drafted exactly where he's expected to finish, at the top.

Keeping Up a Historic Rate

Justin Jefferson isn't just one of the best options in fantasy football; he's chasing some of the NFL's all-time greats. Through five seasons, his production places him in elite company:

Player NameReceiving YardsReceiving TDsReceptionsGames
Justin Jefferson74324049577
Tory Holt67843542380
Randy Moss67436041480
Jerry Rice63646634676
CeeDee Lamb63393849681
Julio Jones62013441465
A.J. Green61714541576
Mike Evans61034039577
Larry Fitzgerald59754642676
Michael Thomas59503251070

Jefferson leads all players in receiving yards through five seasons. He ranks third in receptions and second all-time in receiving yards per game, trailing only Hall of Famer Lance Alworth. The only slight blemish is in touchdowns, but year-to-year scoring variance makes that the least stable wide receiver metric.

With his 2025 projections added to the tally, Jefferson is set to crack the top 100 in career receiving yards and will continue to climb leaderboards at a historic pace.

He's not just a top-tier fantasy asset in 2025; he's authoring a Hall of Fame career in real time.

PlayerPosAgeGamesCarries1DTDYDS1DRECTDSYDSFPs/GFPs
Justin Jefferson MINWR2516.01.50.30.0868.0102.59.0143318.87301.85
Malik Nabers NYGWR2116.05.51.30.03365.4103.510.0131518.62297.95
CeeDee Lamb DALWR2616.011.03.00.36963.0100.09.5126918.24291.8
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETWR2516.03.00.60.01562.8105.510.5119318.05288.8
Puka Nacua LARWR2315.512.02.70.36065.1102.56.8134818.41285.3
Brian Thomas Jr. JAXWR2216.06.51.50.03761.292.09.5128117.53280.45
Nico Collins HOUWR2615.50.50.10.0360.389.58.0128717.17266.15
Drake London ATLWR2316.00.50.10.0357.993.08.8115816.33261.35
Ladd McConkey LACWR2316.00.00.00.0058.592.57.5119616.07257.05

There's not much more of a case to be made; Justin Jefferson is a safe bet at his ADP outside of injury. But what he does to his quarterback and the rest of the offense is where things get interesting.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Footballguys.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Mike Kashuba

 

AMA Recap: Breece Hall, Tyreek Hill, and Competitive Dynasty Rosters

Mike Kashuba

This week, Footballguys Analyst Mike Kashuba goes into a puzzling choice between two former first-rounders, Quinshon Judkins current value, and developing a competitive dynasty roster.

08/14/25 Read More
 

Kaleb Johnson Fantasy Outlook: Instant Reaction

Mike Kashuba

Kaleb Johnson was drafted by the Pittsburgh Steelers. What does it mean for his 2025 fantasy football outlook? Find out in this instant reaction article!

04/26/25 Read More
 

NFL Combine Quarterback Reactions: Risers and Fallers

Mike Kashuba

NFL Combine quarterback workouts are in the books, and Mike Kashuba provides updates and reactions from the quarterback workouts.

03/03/25 Read More
 

NFL Combine Wide Receiver Reactions: Risers and Fallers

Mike Kashuba

NFL Combine wide receiver workouts have come in a flash, Mike Kashuba gives updates and reactions following their testing and fieldwork.

03/03/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Quarterbacks and Risk Tolerance

Mike Kashuba

Dynasty quarterbacks are often viewed through two lenses: their real-life job security and their fantasy football upside. How do we balance risk to find the right quarterback to roster?

01/16/25 Read More
 

Start or Sit? Week 18: Deebo Samuel, Jameson Williams, Michael Pittman Jr.

Mike Kashuba

Deebo Samuel, Jameson Williams and Michael Pittman Jr. are some wide receivers you might consider starting in Week 18. Should you?

01/01/25 Read More