Roundtable: Dump, Bench, and Start

The Footballguys roundtable panel assesses the future of three underperforming fantasy starters since October.

Matt Waldman's Roundtable: Dump, Bench, and Start Matt Waldman Published 11/07/2024

© Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images roundtable

Jayden Reed, Marvin Harrison Jr., and C.J. Stroud have been dramatically worse in October than their overall fantasy rankings this year. What does the Footballguys staff think about their fantasy value for the rest of the year? 

Welcome to Week 10 of the 2024 Footballguys Roundtable. Our intrepid panel of fantasy pundits discusses and debates four topics every week. We split the conversation into separate features.

This week's roundtable features these four topics:

Let's roll. 

Dump, Bench, Start

Matt Waldman: Since Week 6, these players have drastically underperformed relative to their overall fantasy ranking.  

Pick one to Dump, one to Bench, and one to Start. Our readers know that you aren't likely to dump any of them in a real league. 

Gary Davenport: My “Start” here would be Harrison. Yes, his numbers haven’t been great. But the talent is undeniable, and he’s always just one long pass away from a big stat line.  

The “Bench” is Stroud. Injuries have had as much to do with Stroud’s drop-off in production as the quarterback himself, and the return of Nico Collins (possibly as soon as this week) should give Stroud a boost.

That leaves Reed as the “Dump.” The Green Bay Packers are loaded with young talent at wide receiver, and while it’s a good problem for the team to have from an NFL perspective, the havoc it wreaks on target share isn’t going away anytime soon.

Justin Howe: Harrison, who’s very, very good at football, is my start. We saw two weeks ago that, when a Cardinals game is competitive, they’ll be looking to involve Harrison early and often.

His raw numbers haven’t impressed, but the 22% target share has been solid, especially since he’s being used primarily down the field.

Harrison’s sky-high 14.6 aDOT and basement-low 51% catch rate look like early outliers. Before long, I expect he’ll be drawing consistent 8-12 targets a game – and winning downfield more often than not. 

Waldman: His catch rate isn't an outlier based on his film. I pointed out this week that most of the football media has glossed over his real issues as a pass catcher. While I agree he is talented and likely remains a viable fantasy option, I would not anoint him an immediate top-15 fantasy WR with the problems he has winning against man coverage. I am also concerned he returns to startable fantasy value in two-WR sets this year. 

Howe: I like Jordan Love and his weapons, but this is (a) a crowded group that doesn’t offer predictable volume and (b) a touchdown-dependent group that needs the red zone to produce. Since the start of last season, only the Cowboys have thrown more near the goal line than these Packers. All those touchdowns have obscured the fact that no Packer has claimed more than 17% of team targets. That makes all of them – including Reed, who’s only topped 8 targets once in 25 NFL games – tough to project week-to-week. Chasing touchdowns is tricky; I prefer to chase catches and yards, which lead to touchdowns. I'm benching Reed. 

Dump Stroud, as I’m doing this week in my highest-leverage league (in a deal for Brock Purdy). Stroud still very much looks the part of an NFL cornerstone, but the numbers simply aren’t there right now. And if you have a Purdy or a Baker Mayfield in reserve, there’s no reason to chase them. At the moment, Stroud looks hampered by a shaky front line that’s forcing him to move early and often. He’s capable, but that’s not his game. He doesn’t need to be prioritized right now; there are 12-15 other guys with similar floors and ceilings.

Sam Wagman: Dump: Marvin Harrison Jr. He has had a rough time being consistent in the Cardinals' offense. This is understandable, given there is no real second weapon to draw attention away from him and the Cardinals have been a run-heavy attack to start. This does not seem to be ending, despite defensive struggles. 

Waldman: Sam, Tre McBride is TE4 in PPR formats this year and in a combined WR/TE ranking, McBride sits 22nd among fantasy point-getters at these two positions. He's a low-end WR2. I'd argue that's a real second weapon. 

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Matt Waldman

 

August Risers and Fallers: The Gut Check No. 654

Matt Waldman

August has given fantasy football GMs a lot to consider. Matt Waldman shares his rankings revisions based on what he's seen.

08/21/25 Read More
 

Gut Checks: 2025 Pre-Draft Brain Dump

Matt Waldman

Gut Checks. Matt Waldman shares several of his for the 2025 fantasy season.

08/14/25 Read More
 

Draft Plan: The 2025 Fantasy Football Lists of Lists 1.0

Matt Waldman

Matt Waldman unveils the first iteration of his 2025 fantasy football draft plan.

08/07/25 Read More
 

ADP-Less Talents, Ultra-Deep Sleepers: The Gut Check No. 651

Matt Waldman

ADP-less talents today often become free agent darlings tomorrow. Matt Waldman profiles 22 ADP-less talents who are worth adding to your early-season waiver-wire lists.

07/31/25 Read More
 

AMA Recap: Tahj Brooks, Anthony Richardson and the RSP

Matt Waldman

This week, Footballguys Analyst Matt Waldman takes a look at everything from player outlooks to the long marathon of tape-based player evaluation.

07/31/25 Read More
 

WR Idiocracy, 8 Incorrect ADPs: The Gut Check No. 650

Matt Waldman

WR Idiocracy has taken storm with 2025 redraft values. Matt Waldman examines eight receiver values that stupefy him.

07/24/25 Read More