Industry Experts Poll: All-Overrated 1st and 2nd Teams

Using the Industry Experts Poll results to build the 2026 All-Overrated Team.

Clayton Gray's Industry Experts Poll: All-Overrated 1st and 2nd Teams Clayton Gray Published 09/07/2026

Joe Camporeale-Imagn Images overrated

Sigmund Bloom polled 45 Fantasy Football experts on a variety of topics. If you haven't checked out the results, all of the links are here.

Yesterday, we had fun and created an All-Underrated Team based on the poll results. Today, let's get a little worried and find the All-Overrated Team.

ADP and positional rank are taken from the new FBG LABS average draft position page.

All-Overrated 1st Team

QB Joe Burrow, Cincinnati (ADP: 62 | QB3)
RB De'Von Achane, Miami (ADP: 14 | RB8)
RB Omarion Hampton, LA Chargers (ADP: 15 | RB9)
WR Rashee Rice, Kansas City (ADP: 27 | WR13)
WR Ladd McConkey, LA Chargers (ADP: 35 | WR16)
WR Courtland Sutton, Denver (ADP: 80 | WR36)
TE Kyle Pitts Sr., Atlanta (ADP: 79 | TE7)

Note: Josh Jacobs would be on this list, but the voting took place before he was placed on the Commissioner's Exempt List.

All-Overrated 2nd Team

QB Caleb Williams, Chicago (ADP: 81 | QB7)
RB Quinshon Judkins, Cleveland (ADP: 52 | RB22)
RB Cam Skattebo, NY Giants (ADP: 45 | RB18)
WR Justin Jefferson, Minnesota (ADP: 10 | WR5)
WR Drake London, Atlanta (ADP: 21 | WR8)
WR A.J. Brown, New England (ADP: 18 | WR7)
TE Trey McBride, Arizona (ADP: 25 | TE2)

Note: Lots of receivers tied with two votes. The ones with the highest ADP were chosen for the All-Overrated 2nd Team.

How disappointing could these teams be this season? It's almost time to start finding out.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Clayton Gray

 

Game Predictor: Week 7

Clayton Gray

Blending our expert projections with Vegas lines to create game-by-game predictions for this week's NFL games.

10/21/26 Read More
 

Late-Game Pivot Players: Week 6

Clayton Gray

A simple list of players who play late in the week to help you avoid zeroes in your lineup.

10/16/26 Read More
 

Game Predictor: Week 6

Clayton Gray

Blending our expert projections with Vegas lines to create game-by-game predictions for this week's NFL games.

10/14/26 Read More
 

Game Predictor: Week 5

Clayton Gray

Blending our expert projections with Vegas lines to create game-by-game predictions for this week's NFL games.

10/07/26 Read More
 

Late-Game Pivot Players - Week 5

Clayton Gray

A simple list of players who play late in the week to help you avoid zeroes in your lineup.

10/06/26 Read More
 

Game Predictor: Week 4

Clayton Gray

Blending our expert projections with Vegas lines to create game-by-game predictions for this week's NFL games.

09/30/26 Read More