Underdog Pick 'Em Week 2

Dan Hindery's Underdog Pick 'Em Week 2 Dan Hindery Published 09/15/2023

Underdog's Fantasy Pick ‘Em is a fun way to test our powers of prediction against the market. The two keys to success are picking the best players to target and taking advantage of correlations where we can increase our odds. You play Pick ‘Em by simply choosing "Higher" or "Lower" on at least two player props. If you choose successfully, this is the payout structure:

  • Two picks = 3X
  • Three picks = 6X
  • Four picks = 10X
  • Five picks = 20X

In this weekly article, we will list our favorite plays of the week and the reasoning behind them.

Week 1 Review

Overall (5-5) We hit on just half of our choices overall last week and came up just shy of a big win. The closest we got was nearly hitting a 10X on 49ers-Steelers Higher picks. Brock Purdy, Deebo Samuel, and Brandon Aiyuk each got where we needed (basically by halftime), but George Pickens, on the other side, came up 6.5 yards short of the 42.5 we needed despite catching five of seven targets.

Lessons learned: Do not doubt Anthony Richardson. I put too much stock in the low preseason completion percentage and did not expect Richardson to go out and complete 24 passes in his NFL debut. I am not betting against the talented rookie again anytime soon.

Season Total (-3.0 units)

On to Week 2.

Bengals-Ravens Overs

With three picks, we have a chance to 6X our entry amount. Focusing on one game, we are able to get some positive correlations. The angle here is a belief that the Bengals offense will bounce back after a disastrous Week 1 in Cleveland. It is easier to write off that poor performance given that the Bengals have struggled against the Browns regularly despite having a great offensive season, Joe Burrow being rusty after missing almost all of camp, and the conditions were terrible.

QB Joe Burrow

Higher than 0.5 Total Yards

This one is easy. We want to take advantage of the Underdog promotion to get a free square with Burrow. As long as there is not an Aaron Rodgers situation, this is a lock.

QB Lamar Jackson

Higher than 44.5 Rushing Yards

  • In his last six games against the Bengals, Jackson's median rushing yardage is 76.5. Jackson has rushed for at least 58 yards in all but one game against the Bengals and that was a 2020 blowout in which the Bengals scored just only three points.
  • While the expectation is that Jackson will rush a bit less in the new Todd Monken offense, there are going to be weeks when he will be used more often. In a huge division matchup that should be close the whole way, expect the team to take advantage of Jackson's legs more than they did in the 25-9 Week 1 victory over the Texans.

WR Ja&apos

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a HALL OF FAME subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Dan Hindery

 

NFFC High-Stakes Drafting

Dan Hindery

Everything you need to know to try to win $250,000 in the $350 Online Championship and an introduction to our new NFFC tools

08/03/25 Read More
 

Superflex Draft Strategy, by the Numbers

Dan Hindery

How to Attack 2025 Superflex Drafts to Maximize Value

08/21/25 Read More
 

Optimal First-Round Strategy for NFFC Playoff Contests

Dan Hindery

A simulation-based look at which players matter most under the multiplier format

01/07/26 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: January

Dan Hindery

Quantifying long-term player values for dynasty leagues.

01/06/26 Read More
 

What Worked, What Didn't, and What It Means for 2026

Dan Hindery

Lessons learned from analyzing the drafts of Footballguys Bowl Playoff Teams.

01/05/26 Read More
 

FanDuel GPP Guide: Week 18

Dan Hindery

A position-by-position analysis of the top tournament plays for this week's main slate on FanDuel.

01/03/26 Read More