Dynasty Rookie Draft Strategy: 6 Elite Athletes You Need to Pick

Dynasty Rookie Draft Strategy: Alfredo Brown and Dave Kluge take a look at six NFL draft prospects and their relative athletic scores.

Alfredo Brown's Dynasty Rookie Draft Strategy: 6 Elite Athletes You Need to Pick Alfredo Brown Published 04/03/2025

Dave Kluge and I were joined by Kent Lee Platte of RAS.Football to take a look at some of the best athletes in the 2025 NFL Draft and discuss why having a top-tier athletic profile is so important for fantasy success. After the interview, Dave and I listed six of our favorite dynasty rookie draft prospects who have proven to have excellent athletic profiles. Here's a summary of our conversation:

dynasty rookie draft

1. Quinshon Judkins, RB – Ohio State (Watch at 24:19 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: 9.90 (Best among all RBs in the class).
  • Pre-draft Knock: Questioned athleticism due to limited long-speed shown at Ohio State and getting chased down in the national title game.
  • Post-Combine Evaluation: Blew up those concerns; now clearly above players like Kaleb Johnson.
  • Traits on Film: Shows strong acceleration and burst through the line, though not often seen hitting top-end speed.
  • NFL Projection: Can be a three-down back with explosive play potential, especially if paired with the right blocking scheme.

2. Emeka Egbuka, WR – Ohio State (Watch at 27:24 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: Estimated 9.27 (Unofficial due to incomplete drills).
  • Strengths: Excellent route running, spatial awareness, blocks in the run game, inside/outside versatility.
  • Athletic Testing Highlights: 4.49 40-yard dash, 4.15 shuttle, 38" vertical — showing great agility and explosion.
  • Comp: Compared to Amon-Ra St. Brown — productive, tough, and versatile.
  • NFL Projection: Strong candidate for a top-20 pick, fits well with teams like Baltimore or Houston, likely high rookie fantasy relevance.

3. Jaylin Noel, WR – Iowa State (Watch at 31:03 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: 9.75
  • Size Knock: Shorter (5-10) and stockier (194 lbs), but not frail.
  • Combine Strengths: Elite speed and explosion with great agility — big plays after the catch.
  • Film Takeaway: Explosive, fast, and tough — looks like the video is playing at 1.25x speed.
  • NFL Projection: Early-round 2 potential. Slot role early on but could develop into more. Think "explosive Christian Kirk."

4. Mason Taylor, TE – LSU (Watch at 33:24 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: Impressive despite initial athletic concerns — ran a 4.68 at 251 lbs.
  • Profile: NFL-ready, consistent contributor with smooth route running, blocking ability, and pro bloodlines (son of Jason Taylor II).
  • Production: Modest stats due to crowded LSU offense but steady role.
  • Age Factor: Only 20 years old — room to grow physically and as an athlete.
  • NFL Projection: Late Round 1 to early Round 2. Ideal for teams like the 49ers or Chiefs to groom behind veteran stars.

5. Terrance Ferguson, TE – Oregon (Watch at 37:42 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: 9.32 — best of any TE in the class.
  • Combine Results: Elite speed and explosion, though slightly light at 247 lbs.
  • On-Field Production: Huge after-the-catch threat (9 yards after contact per attempt).
  • Style: Compared to Mike Gesicki — could serve as a "big slot" TE.
  • NFL Projection: Potential to sneak into late Round 1, but more likely early Day 2. Strong TE2 or TE3 in rankings, depending on landing spot.

6. RJ Harvey, RB – UCF (Watch at 40:05 on YouTube)

  • RAS Score: Elite explosion and speed grades. Ran a 4.40 at 5-8 and 205 lbs.
  • Production: Over 1,400 yards in back-to-back years, 38 rushing TDs in two seasons.
  • Film Takeaway: Fast, compact, and explosive — "Sonic the Hedgehog" vibes.
  • Size Debate: Same size as top RB prospect Ashton Jeanty, yet often dismissed due to frame.
  • Efficiency Metrics: Top 5 in multiple advanced categories (YPC, explosive runs, missed tackles, etc.).
  • NFL Projection: Day 3 most likely due to size stigma, but Day 2 wouldn't be a shock. Excellent sleeper candidate.

Subscribe to the Show

YouTube
Apple Podcasts
Spotify

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

Quarterback Rankings and Tiers: One Staffer's Opinion

Dave Kluge

Quarterback rankings provided by Dave Kluge, with explanations on where and why he strays from consensus opinions.

07/15/25 Read More
 
 
 
 
The Myth of Geno Smith
Jason Wood
07/14/25 Read More

More by Alfredo Brown

 

AMA Recap: Rome Odunze, QB for WR Trades, and Mr. Fantastic

Alfredo Brown

Footballguys All-Star Analyst Alfredo Brown answered questions about 2025 sleepers, Trevor Lawerence's 2025 outlook, and how to execute a quarterback for wide receiver trades.

06/26/25 Read More
 

8 Breakout Players to Draft in Fantasy Football (2025)

Alfredo Brown

Alfredo Brown reveals 8 Breakout Players to Draft in Fantasy Football

06/18/25 Read More
 

Dynasty QB Trade Value Tiers (2025 Rankings)

Alfredo Brown

Alfredo Brown and Dave Kluge ranked their top 34 Dynasty QBs in tiers and discussed who to trade for.

06/04/25 Read More
 

Dynasty TE Trade Targets by Tier (2025 Rankings)

Alfredo Brown

Alfredo Brown and Dave Kluge ranked their top Dynasty TEs in tiers and discussed who to trade for.

05/28/25 Read More
 

Dynasty WR Trade Targets by Tier (2025 Rankings)

Alfredo Brown

Alfredo Brown and Dave Kluge ranked their top 31 Dynasty WRs in tiers and discussed who to trade for.

05/22/25 Read More
 

All 32 NFL Schedule Release Videos Ranked (from worst to best)

Alfredo Brown

Alfredo Brown ranked all 32 of the 2025 NFL Schedule Release videos from worst to best

05/16/25 Read More