Roundtable: Fantasy vs. Reality II

The Footballguys roundtable picks between sets of two players they'd prefer in fantasy football and building an NFL team.

Matt Waldman's Roundtable: Fantasy vs. Reality II Matt Waldman Published 12/19/2024

© Denny Simmons / The Tennessean / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images roundtable

Some players have better fantasy value than real-life value. For others, the opposite is true. 

Welcome to Week 16 of the 2024 Footballguys Roundtable. Our intrepid panel of fantasy pundits discusses and debates four topics every week. We split the conversation into separate features.

This week's roundtable features these four topics:

Let's roll. 

Fantasy vs. Reality

Matt Waldman: Consider these four pairs of established talents at the main fantasy positions. 

Pick two pairs from the list and tell me which ones from each pair you prefer for fantasy over the next two seasons and which you'd prefer if you ran a real team. 

Justin Jefferson vs. Ja'Marr Chase

Joseph Haggan: I'm taking Chase for my fantasy and NFL teams. Jefferson wins with elite route running and magical sticky hands. Chase is another excellent route runner, but he also has tremendous speed and dominates physically. 

As good as Jefferson is, he is not as powerful as Chase, who is also tied to Joe Burrow, one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. Jefferson is stuck with Sam Darnold, who has exceeded expectations, or J.J. McCarthy, who has not even taken an NFL snap.

Chase's physical dominance and big-play ability give him the edge over Jefferson.  

Ryan Weisse: I'll take Chase on my fantasy team and Jefferson on my real team. We probably don't need to make much of a case for Chase in fantasy. He is the best receiver in 2024 and can seemingly score on any play. With over 1400 yards, 15 touchdowns, and three games left to play, his stat line speaks for itself.

However, Jefferson still feels like a better receiver to me. Chase's stats are carried by a defense that can't stop anyone, and the Bengals played every game in a shoot-out. Jefferson is putting up great numbers on a contending team. Plus, Jefferson performed far better with bad quarterback play than Chase when he was without Joe Burrow in his career. 

Waldman: I love both players. I'll take Chase in both. He's more athletic and versatile, and Jefferson's equal as a route runner. The scheme is more important than the quality of the quarterback. It's a difficult choice, but Chase has the highest ceiling in any given year. 

T.J. Hockenson vs. Sam LaPorta

Corey Spala: I would prefer Sam LaPorta for fantasy and if I ran my own NFL team. LaPorta notably had a disappointing season relative to his draft capital. Offensive coordinator Ben Johnson has utilized multiple weapons and has generated success for Detroit, notably the ascension of Jameson Williams.

Despite the change in utilization, LaPorta (9.9) averages more fantasy points per game than T.J. Hockenson (9.6). Johnson has been a top candidate for a head coaching position, and it is unknown if he will depart following the 2024 season.

Regardless of the outcome, LaPorta should continue to have fantasy success over Hockenson. Both tight ends can improve their blocking, but LaPorta is a superior athlete who can create after the catch.  

Sean Settle: T.J. Hockenson is the player I would prefer to have in a real-life situation. He is a better blocker, does not require specialized packages in an offense to get targets, and has been more consistent over his career.

From a fantasy standpoint, LaPorta has the higher upside. He plays for a team that can score 40 on any defense and likes to get creative in the red zone. LaPorta is having a down season compared to his rookie year but has the higher ceiling of the two tight ends. 

Waldman: This year, I have taken LaPorta in both fantasy and real life. Now? I'll take Hockenson in both. Hockenson is one of the few all-around tight ends in the league capable of performing at a high level in every facet of the game. LaPorta offers a higher ceiling, but the impending change with coordinators gives Hockenson the slightest edge due to the continuity of the offensive scheme. 

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Tennessee.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

Muddy Backfields: Sorting the Kansas City Chiefs RBs

Phil Alexander

A look at Kansas City's murky backfield, how much it matters, and which players to target or fade before training camp brings clarity and the market adjusts.

07/17/25 Read More
 
 
 
 

More by Matt Waldman

 

Chubb and Hopkins, the Expendables: The Gut Check No. 647

Matt Waldman

Fantasy football has written off Nick Chubb and DeAndre Hopkins. Matt Waldman sees potential draft-day steals.

07/03/25 Read More
 

Jalen Milroe Was the Right Pick: The Gut Check No. 646

Matt Waldman

Jalen Milroe going to Seattle in the third round may prove to be the best investment in a rookie QB in the NFL and dynasty football in 2025.

06/26/25 Read More
 

Luther Burden III: All-In? The Gut Check No. 645

Matt Waldman

Luther Burden III is a compelling candidate to become the most productive rookie fantasy receiver in 2025. Matt Waldman explains why.

06/19/25 Read More
 

Replacements: Week 18

Matt Waldman

The weekly list of preemptive additions before their fantasy emergence and candidates who could contribute due to unexpected late-week events.

01/03/25 Read More
 

Replacements: Week 17

Matt Waldman

The weekly list of preemptive additions before their fantasy emergence and candidates who could contribute due to unexpected late-week events.

12/27/24 Read More
 

The Gut Check No.644: What We Got from Michael Penix Jr.

Matt Waldman

Matt Waldman breaks down what fantasy GMs got from quarterback Michael Penix Jr.'s first start and what to expect moving forward.

12/24/24 Read More