What's the backup plan for Jonathan Taylor?

The Footballguys staff discusses what the Colts need to do to bolster a depleted running back room.

Jason Wood's What's the backup plan for Jonathan Taylor? Jason Wood Published 04/20/2026

© Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts

We are proud to be among the first, if not the first, to publish full projections for the upcoming season, going live just days after the Super Bowl. Publishing detailed projections in early February comes with trade-offs, not the least of which is a near-total lack of clarity on how free agency, cap transactions, and the NFL draft will reshape rosters.

We've been updating our projections in near real time, including during the recent onslaught of free-agent transactions. This version will remain largely stable until we can layer in the April NFL draft, but stable projections don't mean settled debates.

We have a staff of sharp analysts with sharp takes of their own, so I thought it would be worthwhile to solicit their views on the key coin-toss situations that will shape each team's outlook in the coming months. These are important questions where reasonable, informed people can credibly land in very different places. I asked my colleagues to weigh in with one assumption: they were answering strictly through the lens of a standard 0.5-PPR redraft league.

Indianapolis Colts Coin-Toss Questions


Jonathan Taylor is one of the NFL's few true workhorses, but the running back depth chart leaves much to be desired. Do you expect the Colts to add a veteran No. 2, a rookie No. 2, or stick with DJ Giddens and Ulysses Bentley IV as the backups?

Jeff Haseley: I expect the Colts to add a veteran No. 2 running back. Relying on DJ Giddens and Ulysses Bentley IV as the only insurance for Jonathan Taylor feels like playing with fire.

Maurile Tremblay: I'd lean veteran No. 2. Jonathan Taylor is a true workhorse and should maintain his usual workload, but the Colts don't have much of a backup plan. In the broader team context, this looks like a roster trying to win now with Daniel Jones — not a team that should feel great about lacking an insurance policy behind Taylor. A rookie is possible, but standing pat with Giddens and Bentley would be malpractice.

Andy Hicks: The Colts need to add at least one more option to this backfield. There are still viable choices in free agency if they don't secure a suitable addition in the draft. Giddens, a fifth-round pick last year, did little to justify a larger role based on his rookie season. Durability is also a concern — last season marked just the second time in his six-year career that Taylor played a full slate of games. In the three prior years, he missed a combined 16 games, with at least three absences in each season. Veteran options such as Najee Harris and Joe Mixon remain available. Until the Colts address the position, most likely during the draft, it's reasonable to expect an upgrade behind Taylor.

Jason Wood's Verdict

I expect both rookie and veteran free-agent additions.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Footballguys.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Jason Wood

 

Is Trevor Lawrence Finally Elite?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether Trevor Lawrence's growth under Liam Coen is set to continue.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Should You Draft Bhayshul Tuten or Chris Rodriguez?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether they prefer incumbent Bhayshul Tuten or newcomer Chris Rodriguez Jr.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Brenton Strange: Is He a Tight End to Target?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses Brenton Strange and whether his late-season surge in 2025 is predictive of his value this year.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Will Brian Thomas Jr. Return to Relevance?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses how to rank the veteran receiver trio of Thomas, Meyers, and Washington this season.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Will Travis Hunter Focus on Cornerback?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses whether Travis Hunter will focus primarily on defense in 2026.

04/20/26 Read More
 

Daniel Jones: Was Last Season a Fluke?

Jason Wood

The Footballguys staff discusses where to tier Daniel Jones and whether 2025's performance was an anomaly.

04/20/26 Read More