Welcome to the weekly Fantasy Notebook, the must-stop spot for keeping your finger on the pulse of Fantasy Nation. NFL news and developments drive fantasy values. The Notebook is here to keep you in the loop on all of it throughout the season -- and into the offseason.
Trust Isn't Easy to Come By
In this year's Footballguys Draft Guide, I wrote the cover story. The theme was "Who Can You Trust?"
The premise was simple. "The same things that make the NFL so fantastic for us as fans -- close, unpredictable outcomes driven by factors beyond anyone's control -- make achieving our fantasy objectives difficult.
"Leaning into players with traits we trust is important. And understanding who we can trust means understanding what we can trust."
What are we looking for?
We kept it simple and focused on four things:
The Observables: Talent, Role, Scheme
It's not hard to see who plays at a higher level than those around them. We also understand math. Numbers matter. Especially opportunities. There is no scoring without them.
Talented players with high-volume roles are trustworthy. Playing in a successful offensive ecosystem adds another layer. We're not just drafting a running back or a wide receiver; we're buying a majority stake in offenses with proven track records.
The Intangibles: Red Flags
As in all things, tempering our enthusiasm -- in this case, our trust -- is wise. Even if they're subjective, acknowledging potential weaknesses is part of the process.
The Next Step
In the original article, we took the top five players in the Footballguys 2026 Projections. We left out quarterbacks (who touch the ball every snap) and sorted through the observables and intangibles for this group to understand why we should trust them with our fantasy fortunes.
Now that we're past the halfway point of the season, let's revisit these players, our assessments, and most importantly, determine whether our trust was well placed.
Jahmyr Gibbs, RB, Detroit Lions
Here's what we thought in July:
Footballguys Preseason Projection: 353.91 points
Heading into his fourth NFL season, expectations for Gibbs were already sky-high. Head coach Dan Campbell added to them in early June when he told us what to expect: "[Gibbs is] going to be our bell cow now."
Talent: Gibbs is an elite, dual-threat running back, recognized for his explosive home-run speed, high-level receiving skills, and elite open-field agility.
Role: Last year, Gibbs set a career-high with 320 touches (243 rushes, 77 catches) and played the most snaps of his three-year career (737). This year, the arrival of new offensive coordinator Drew Petzing and the departure of running mate David Montgomery put Gibbs in position to get even more.
Scheme: The Lions have been a top-five unit in terms of points per game in four consecutive seasons, and they should be in that range again in 2026.
Red Flags: None. Gibbs is one of the league's most dangerous playmakers in one of its most prolific offenses. He's a strong option with the first pick of fantasy drafts.
Here's What We Know Now
Gibbs is currently the RB1 overall. He's scored 257.4 points through nine games. Based on his 28.6 points-per-game average, he's on pace for 486.2 points -- well ahead of our projected total.
As NFL.com's Kevin Patra noted, Gibbs is the engine of Detroit's offense, generating 37.7 percent of the Lions' scrimmage yards through nine games. He leads the NFL with 1,000 rushing yards, 11 rushing touchdowns, 64 rushing first downs, and 111.1 yards per game.
His 1,384 scrimmage yards and 13 scrimmage TDs are both tops, as well.
Gibbs has already accumulated 211 touches, leading the NFL in total touches and regularly seeing 20 to 29 touches per game. His 73 missed tackles forced are 13 more than any other running back, per Next Gen Stats, and his 395 yards after those forced missed tackles are 69 more than any other running back.
Most recently, the Offensive Player of the Year candidate finished Sunday's win over New England in Munich with 252 total yards (171 in the first half alone) and two scores on 29 touches, becoming just the second player with four games of at least 200 scrimmage yards and two TDs before age 25 (Hall of Famer LaDainian Tomlinson, five).
Where This Is Going
Gibbs' 153.77 scrimmage yards per game puts him on pace for 2,614, which would break Chris Johnson's 2,509 record set in 2009.
Fantasy-wise, Gibbs has exceeded 40 fantasy points in three of his past 16 regular-season games and 35-plus in seven of his past 20. According to ESPN.com's Tristan Cockcroft, Gibbs' 257.4 points are the eighth-most ever by a running back through his team's first nine games.
Level of Trust: Couldn't be higher.
Bijan Robinson, RB, Atlanta Falcons
Here's what we thought in July:
Footballguys Preseason Projection: 353.22 points
Robinson broke the Falcons' single-season record for yards from scrimmage last year with 2,298. That total led the NFL and ranks 12th all-time. He also became just the second player in league history with 800 receiving yards and 1,400 rushing yards in a single season. Atlanta's offseason moves made his path to a potential RB1 finish even clearer.
Talent: A "generational" talent with exceptional vision and elite contact balance, Robinson excels as a three-down back with soft hands and explosive playmaking ability.
Role: Robinson averaged 21.5 touches per game last year, second-most in the league, and his 103 targets ranked second among running backs. In games with at least five receptions, he averaged 30.5 fantasy points.
Scheme: New coach Kevin Stefanski, who helped Nick Chubb to three straight 1,000-yard seasons in Cleveland, will almost certainly build the offense around Robinson's agility, size, and breakaway speed.
Red Flags: Slight, related to the new staff and scheme. Still, the 24-year-old is in his prime, poised for a huge workload, and worth consideration as the first pick overall.
Here's What We Know Now
Robinson is RB3 overall. He's scored 197.7 points through 10 games. His 19.8 points per game put him on pace for 336.6 points, not far off our projection.
The Falcons star running back now has 951 rushing yards as his team heads into its bye week.
But he's losing momentum.
Robinson has dropped from first place down to third among the NFL's rushing leaders following his 71-yard outing against the Chiefs in Week 10. The Falcons went three-and-out on their first possession without Robinson touching the ball.
He has not had 20 or more carries since the team's Week 7 win over the 49ers.
The Falcons have lost five of their past six games, and Robinson did not hit the 20-carry mark in any of those losses.
Adding to the concerns, Atlanta's offense has struggled over the last few weeks. The team is averaging just 10 points per game over its last three contests.
Where This Is Going
Robinson is still great. He leads the NFL in yards after contact. But SI.com's Scott Kennedy believes the more telling metric is yards before contact. Robinson is 12th in the NFL at 2.7 yards per rush, according to Pro Football Reference.
Kennedy went on to point out the Falcons have fallen to 27th in the NFL in third-down conversions at 32.4 percent.
It's hard to establish a running game when you can't extend drives and you're behind in games.
Nonetheless, Robinson's touches per game still rank fourth in the NFL at 22.0, trailing only James Cook III of the Bills, Ken Walker III of the Chiefs, and Gibbs.
But until the Falcons figure out how to back defenders off the line of scrimmage, Robinson is going to continue to be limited in his effectiveness.
Level of Trust: Wavering, but only slightly.
Ja'Marr Chase, WR, Cincinnati Bengals
Here's what we thought in July:
Footballguys Preseason Projection: 351.95 points
The Bengals' top receiving weapon is coming off another elite fantasy campaign. It's become the norm. He's finished four of his five NFL seasons no lower than fifth in fantasy points per game.
Talent: Chase is a premier wide receiver with an elite combination of speed, power, and contested-catch ability -- a dominant playmaker with exceptional YAC skills and consistent home-run upside.
Role: Chase led the league in pass routes and targets for the second straight year in 2025. His 185 targets translated to a 30.2 percent target share, second-best among players with at least 10 games, after 175 targets the year before. With 127 catches in 2024 and 125 last season, he's only the third receiver in NFL history with multiple 125-catch campaigns.
Scheme: Joe Burrow has legitimate QB1 overall upside, and the Bengals are one of the few teams with two wide receivers and a quarterback all drafted within the top 55 picks.
Red Flags: Minimal. Chase is the best bet to finish as the overall WR1, and Joe Flacco eases concerns about Burrow's injury history.
Here's What We Know Now
Chase is currently WR3 overall with 193.8 fantasy points, behind Jaxon Smith-Njigba and CeeDee Lamb. At his current pace, Chase's 21.5 points per game would give him 365.5 points over 17 games, slightly ahead of his projection.
But he could finish higher than that. After a slow start, Chase has 527 receiving yards in his last three games. He's the WR1 overall over that span, averaging 32.2 points per game.
Against the Steelers in Week 10, Chase gobbled up seven receptions for 146 yards in the first half on his way to an outstanding 11 catches for 231 yards.
That was the highest yardage total for any receiver this season, and it was Chase's fourth regular-season game with at least 200 receiving yards.
After similarly punishing the Falcons a week prior, Chase became the first player since at least 2000 to record 140-plus receiving yards in the first half in back-to-back games, per NFL Research.
Where This Is Going
After dominating the Steelers on Sunday Night Football, Chase said the Bengals offense is currently at its peak. He praised the offensive line and Burrow for their performance.
"I think right now, we're at our peak with momentum," Chase said. "The O-line's been playing incredible right now and giving Joe enough time to get the ball out of his hands, and Joe is just trusting his playmakers to win in space."
As SB Nation's Dadio Makdook suggested, the combination of Burrow having time, the offense finding its identity, and Tee Higgins emerging as one of the most physically dominant receivers in the league has led to Chase being able to break out his entire bag on a regular basis.
According to Makdook, Chase may have been the best receiver in the league for a couple of seasons, but he's somehow reached another level.
Burrow is part of this conversation. He's the first player since 2013 with at least 20 passing touchdowns in a five-game span. Chase has been -- and will continue to be -- an integral part of that success.
Level of Trust: Increasing with each passing week.
Christian McCaffrey, RB, San Francisco 49ers
Here's what we thought in July:
Footballguys Preseason Projection: 344.66 points
Last year's RB1 overall delivered 24.5 points per game -- 2.5 more per week than Robinson managed in his RB2 finish. McCaffrey topped 25 PPR points eight times and 30 points five times. Even heading into his age-30 season, he remains an elite option as long as he's on the field.
Talent: One of the most versatile backs in NFL history, McCaffrey pairs elite route-running and receiving skills with exceptional agility, vision, and football IQ.
Role: The 2025 Comeback Player of the Year appeared in every game and accounted for 2,126 yards -- 35.6 percent of San Francisco's offensive output. Only Robinson's 40.6 percent share was higher.
Scheme: Kyle Shanahan's run-first system leans on wide-zone rushing, heavy play-action, and pre-snap motion. Maximizing personnel and creative play sequencing are also factors in Shanahan's success.
Red Flags: McCaffrey turns 30 this season, and his 2025 workload was historically heavy. His 413 opportunities led the league by a wide margin, and since 2010, backs with 400-plus touches have averaged just 12.7 games the following year.
Here's What We Know Now
McCaffrey is currently the RB2 overall, with 213 points. At his current 23.7-point-per-game pace, CMC would finish with 402.9 fantasy points.
So yes, pair him with Gibbs at the top of the heap.
We expected elite production; the extraordinary receiving efficiency supplied the ceiling. But generally speaking, McCaffrey has proven to be as dangerous as ever.
Through nine games, he has 115 carries for 519 yards and 10 touchdowns while averaging 4.5 yards per carry. On the receiving end, he has 431 yards and three touchdowns.
In Week 10, McCaffrey had a career-high 161 receiving yards on four catches, two of them touchdowns, and ran for 62 yards and a touchdown on 13 carries. He is the first player in the Super Bowl era with at least 150 receiving yards, two receiving touchdowns, 50-plus rushing yards, and at least one rushing touchdown.
The result was a single-game high score for the season, as McCaffrey scored 44.3 fantasy points in the 46-40 win over the Cowboys.
He was dynamic in both phases, but his receiving prowess in this game was extraordinary, as he had a career-high 32.1 points on catches, remarkable considering he has 121 career games played and 12 games with 10-plus catches.
By comparison, he had only four receptions in this game.
Where This Is Going
As Cockcroft pointed out, the 49ers are doing a fine job keeping McCaffrey's 30-year-old legs fresh, though he does have two of his toughest matchups all year in the next two weeks (against Minnesota in Mexico City on Sunday night this week and against the Seahawks in Week 12).
He might struggle to hit his ceiling in those games, but expecting him to finish the year outperforming our preseason projections is still plenty reasonable.
Level of Trust: Rising as concerns about age and workload diminish.
Puka Nacua, WR, Los Angeles Rams
Here's what we thought in July:
Footballguys Preseason Projection: 353.91 points
Nacua, a 2023 fifth-round pick, has developed into one of the league's most productive receivers. He's finished sixth or better in fantasy points per game in all three seasons with the Rams, and last year's WR1 finish in both total points (377) and points per game (23.6) showed how high the ceiling is.
Talent: Nacua is one of the league's most versatile receivers, with an exceptional ability to win contested catches, high-level route running, and physical play after the catch.
Role: Like Chase, Nacua is a volume machine. Matthew Stafford's top target led the league with 129 receptions, added 1,715 yards (second-most), and finished no lower than third among receivers in targets, yardage, and touchdowns. When Nacua ran a route, Stafford looked his way at a historic pace -- a target rate just over 36 percent. He even chipped in 105 rushing yards and a score on 10 carries.
Scheme: The Rams' offense is built on Sean McVay's ability to funnel massive production into a few specific roles. Nobody in Los Angeles benefits more than Nacua.
Red Flags: The Rams' weakest fantasy position may be quarterback -- and no, not 38-year-old reigning MVP Matthew Stafford. With Jimmy Garoppolo unsigned, Stetson Bennett IV and rookie Ty Simpson are the next men up. That's why Nacua isn't being drafted ahead of Chase.
Here's What We Know Now
In seven games this season, Nacua was WR2 on a points-per-game basis, with 25.1 points per game. At that pace, Nacua would have hit 426.7 total points over a full 17-game season.
He'll not get the opportunity, however.
Nacua was placed on injured reserve after Week 9 with an MCL and PCL sprain in his right leg, as well as turf toe.
He was hurt on the Rams' final offensive snap of Sunday's victory over the Washington Commanders. The injuries happened on third down with the Rams attempting to end the game with a conversion. Nacua rushed for 5 yards but took a hard hit on the play and briefly stayed on the ground before walking off the field.
McVay said Monday he's "kicking himself" in retrospect about exposing Nacua to a big hit with a run play late with a 20-13 lead. Fantasy managers invested in Nacua would probably like to join McVay in that.
Nacua had 14 catches for 150 yards and a touchdown in that Week 9 win. He was targeted 19 times.
Nacua now has nine career games with 150-plus receiving yards, two more than any other player since he entered the NFL in 2023. He broke a tie with Hall of Famer Elroy Hirsch for the third-most such games in Rams history and now trails only Hall of Famer Isaac Bruce (13) and Torry Holt (12).
His 25 receptions over the two games leading up to his injury are the second most by a Rams player in the Super Bowl era.
Where This Is Going
Nowhere fast.
The earliest Nacua might come back is a Week 15 home game against the Cowboys. With the missed time, he's not going to return full-season value this year.
But the bigger question is whether fantasy managers can expect him to quickly get up to speed upon return and deliver solid totals over his final outings this season.
At the very least, holding Nacua to find out is well worth the roster spot.
Level of Trust: Stuck in neutral. Nacua is great, but not when he's sidelined.
On the whole, the players we trusted this summer are giving up ample reasons to keep trusting them.