Understanding the Value of Building Depth on Your Dynasty Roster

Nick Whalen's Understanding the Value of Building Depth on Your Dynasty Roster Nick Whalen Published 03/19/2023

Quality versus Quantity. One of the biggest debates every year in fantasy football team building. I’ve used both strategies successfully over the last two decades of playing fantasy football. However, knowing when to utilize either strategy is crucial to winning.

Depth Is Important

The past few football seasons have shown the value of depth on your fantasy football team. Good depth helps teams overcome the following potential issues:

  • Suspensions. Unfortunately, players get suspended for substance abuse, violence, performance-enhancing drugs, and trouble with the law.
  • Injuries. The worst part of sports is when players become injured. From season-long to reoccurring to performance-hindering, injuries are an unfortunate result of a violent game. The quarterback or another important offensive teammate could be injured, affecting your player.
  • Poor play. Every year we have players who didn’t live up to the expectations. The prime example of this in 2022 was Allen Robinson.
  • Bye weeks. Players will miss a week.
  • Tough defensive matchup. A very good run defense or Ahmad Gardner shadowing a wide receiver could hinder performance.

Quality is important

Most championship-winning fantasy football teams have at least one top-end player to provide a huge statistical advantage.

  • Travis Kelce, in 2022, averaged almost six more PPG than the TE2.
  • Cooper Kupp, in 2021 averaged 3.6 more PPG than the WR2.

Initially, we need a process in order to evaluate our team. Find the area within your league setting to look at the highest-scoring players by position and then sort this by points per game. Disregard players with a small sample size. Analyze more players than the starting requirement for the league. In the example below, we’ll look at 24 total quarterbacks in a 12-team league that starts one quarterback. These are the results from the 2022 season:

Rank Name PPG Rank Name PPG
1 Patrick Mahomes II 33.13 13 Jared Goff 23.12
2 Josh Allen 32.67 14 Justin Herbert 22.77
3 Jalen Hurts 31.04 15 Daniel Jones 22.28
4 Joe Burrow 29.87 16 Tom Brady 22.24
5 Tua Tagovailoa 24.98 17 Derek Carr 21.12
6 Lamar Jackson 24.97 18 Jimmy Garoppolo 20.49
7 Geno Smith 24.60 19 Russell Wilson 20.22
8 Justin Fields 24.25 20 Carson Wentz 20.21
9 Kirk Cousins 24.10 21 Aaron Rodgers 20.04
10 Dak Prescott 24.03 22 Marcus Mariota 19.86
11 Kyler Murray 23.59 23 Deshaun Watson 19.30
12 Trevor Lawrence 23.25 24 Sam Darnold 19.15

Players highlighted in yellow would qualify as quality starters. Players highlighted in blue represent the quantity or good depth category. Lastly, the green highlighted players and below wouldn’t be viewed as valuable enough for the quantity category.

Averaging the groups of players comes to the following points per game:

  • Yellow players = 31.7
  • Blue players = 22.7
  • Green players = 19.4

Complete this process for running back, wide receiver, tight end, and any other position group to provide a well-rounded view of your team. One of the most difficult parts of evaluating your own team is being objective because people tend to overvalue their own players, which is why I highly recommend using this process.

For the following examples, we’ll reference the graph above and the format of a 12-team league with starting requirements of 1 QB, 2 RBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, and 1 flex.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a ELITE subscription.

An ELITE subscription is required to access content for Dynasty leagues. If this league is not a Dynasty league, you can edit your leagues here.

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Nick Whalen

 

Week 18 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 18 DFS lineups

01/04/25 Read More
 

Week 17 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 17 DFS lineups

12/28/24 Read More
 

Week 16 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 16 DFS lineups

12/21/24 Read More
 

Week 15 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 15 DFS lineups

12/13/24 Read More
 

Week 14 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 14 DFS lineups

12/06/24 Read More
 

Week 13 DFS Contrarian

Nick Whalen

Contrarian plays to consider for your week 13 DFS lineups

11/29/24 Read More