Dynasty quarterback rankings are unlike any other position. Production matters, of course, but age, draft capital, job security, rushing upside, coaching stability, injury history, and long-term insulation all dramatically shape player value. That's why I don't publish my flat dynasty rankings like this. Instead, these quarterbacks are grouped into tiers based on similar profiles, trajectories, and risk levels. This is the final part of a series I do every offseason, and you can find running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends linked right here.
Some quarterbacks are elite producers entering their 30s. Some are young stars already posting QB1 seasons. Others are talented reclamation projects, aging veterans, or rookies who may not see the field for years. The goal of these dynasty QB tiers is to better reflect how dynasty managers actually build and value rosters.
DON'T MISS OUT: Sign up for our free, daily newsletter here.
These dynasty quarterback rankings are built with both short-term production and long-term value in mind. Contending teams should value stability and weekly ceiling. Rebuilding rosters should prioritize insulation, age, and future appreciation. Context matters, and tiers help illustrate that better than flat rankings ever could.
Whether you're searching for dynasty quarterback rankings, superflex quarterback rankings, dynasty quarterback trade values, or long-term fantasy football quarterback projections, this tiered approach is designed to help dynasty managers understand not just where players rank, but why they belong there.
Jeff Bell and I discussed these tiers in a recent episode. Check out the full episode for even more nuance on a deeply-layered position.
Dynasty Quarterback Rankings and Tiers
The QB1... For Now.
Allen's run atop the quarterback rankings has been unbelievable. He's been the top-scoring quarterback in all but one of the last six seasons, and he was the QB2 in the one year he came up short. While there's no reason to panic, it's impossible to ignore his age. Allen recently turned 30, and it's hard to believe that he can maintain his elite fantasy production as he enters his third decade. Much of Allen's production comes via his legs. After setting a career-best 47.6 yards per game in 2022, he's come up short of 35 rushing yards per game in each of the three seasons since. That's gone mostly unnoticed, as he's scored twelve or more touchdowns in each of the last three seasons. Allen is a physical specimen and one of the best modern quarterbacks. He's the most valuable player in dynasty, but it's not crazy to think that managers without loaded rosters might want to tier down and get a bit younger.
Year 3 Breakouts?
The 2024 NFL Draft class was touted as a good one, and it quickly lived up to the hype. Williams, Daniels, and Maye went first, second, and third overall, and all have proven capable of elite fantasy production. Williams has some obvious red flags. He likes to play off script, and his big-game hunting can lead to the occasional poor decision. Still, he logged an impressive QB6 finish in Year 2 and should only improve in his second season with Ben Johnson. Maye was second behind only Josh Allen in scoring last year, and has the added benefit of being the youngest of the trio. He's probably the safest of the bunch, and adding pass-catchers this offseason could raise his ceiling. Daniels is the oldest of the group, but he'll still be just 26 this year. Despite coming off an injury-plagued ceiling, his rushing prowess gives him the highest ceiling of the bunch. All of these quarterbacks are young, have elite draft capital, and at least one QB1 season under their belt. They are insulated in value and make for high-end targets for rebuilers and contenders alike.
In Their Prime QB1s
All of these quarterbacks are aged 28 through 31, right at the top of the age curve. They have all proven capable of elite fantasy production. While you can imagine all of these guys still starting five-plus years from now, we've got to wonder what the upside will look like as their athleticism wanes. Jackson has taken huge strides as a passer, but that efficiency could take a hit as his legs age. Burrow isn't a pure rusher, but his athleticism allows him to scramble and extend plays regularly. He'll have to change his game as he gets older. Justin Herbert will be 28 this year, younger than the rest of the group. He is also coming off a career-best 31.1 rushing yards per game, giving him a newfound floor and ceiling. Year 2 with Jim Harbaugh and the return of his bookend tackles could quickly push him up the rankings. And finally, Mahomes. His value took a bump this year. Despite a good year from a fantasy perspective, his season ended with a torn ACL. He's now entering his age-31 season, coming off the biggest injury of his career. Mahomes is known for making plays happen with his legs, and he could struggle there early in the year. The talent in this tier is obvious, but their ages make it difficult to recommend any non-contending rosters target them in trades.
Younger Than You Might Realize
Continue reading this content with a ELITE subscription.
An ELITE subscription is required to access content for Dynasty leagues. If this league is not a Dynasty league, you can edit your leagues here.