Quarterback By Committee (QBBC)

Clayton Gray's Quarterback By Committee (QBBC) Clayton Gray Published 08/24/2021

There are a couple of ways to approach the quarterback position in your draft. You can go after an elite option, or you can wait and use a committee approach.

If you want an elite option, you're in the wrong place. But there is something for you. Click here to find the best backup to your star quarterback.

If you choose the committee approach, you have to know which quarterbacks to target to make the best possible committee. Let's get to it.

Ranking the Defenses

You have to know which defenses are optimal opponents before you can find the right quarterbacks to go after. Below, you'll see all 32 teams ranked from toughest (New England) to easiest (Detroit) against opposing quarterbacks.

Rank
Defense
Rank
Defense
Rank
Defense
1 New England 12 Denver 23 LA Chargers
2 LA Rams 13 Indianapolis 24 Cleveland
3 Pittsburgh 14 Miami 25 Philadelphia
4 San Francisco 15 Tampa Bay 26 NY Jets
5 Minnesota 16 Cincinnati 27 Houston
6 Washington 17 Baltimore 28 Seattle
7 Green Bay 18 Kansas City 29 Atlanta
8 NY Giants 19 Buffalo 30 Jacksonville
9 Chicago 20 Las Vegas 31 Tennessee
10 New Orleans 21 Arizona 32 Detroit
11 Carolina 22 Dallas

This means we would like our quarterbacks to face Detroit, Tennessee, Jacksonville, Atlanta, etc., and avoid teams like Patriots, Rams, Steelers, and 49ers.

Starting-Level Quarterbacks

If we are going to have a QBBC, that means we are not drafting a starting-level quarterback. The players below are listed with their projected fantasy points scored per game.

While there are always exceptions, those quarterbacks are generally considered the Top 10 at the position. They are in almost everyone's Top 12 and have very few (if any) question marks surrounding them. If you get one of those guys, you start him. Pretty simple process.

Beat Ryan Tannehill

The goal of a QBBC is to compete against quarterbacks in the Top 10. That means our goal is to find duos who will score more than 23.16 fantasy points per game.

High-Level Committee

This doesn't happen every season, but this year, there is a trio of quarterbacks just below the Top 10.

These three players can creep into some top-10s, and they are in almost every Top 15 list you'll see.

So, while it would be expensive, let's see how good a committee you can get with two of these quarterbacks.

Quarterback 1
Quarterback 2
Fantasy PPG
Jalen Hurts - Phi Matthew Stafford - LAR 24.46
Matthew Stafford - LAR Joe Burrow - Cin 24.00
Jalen Hurts - Phi Joe Burrow - Cin 23.70

The good news is all three of those combos beat Ryan Tannehill's 23.16 PPG. The Hurts/Stafford committee even passes Herbert and Rodgers and gives us the equivalent of having the No. 8 quarterback. Not bad. Remember, though, the draft capital needed to acquire two of these quarterbacks is high. It would be more efficient to go ahead and take Herbert or Rodgers.

Value QBBC

Instead, we'll ignore Hurts, Stafford, and Burrow and find a QBBC based on value. And isn't that why everyone is here?

Looking through the 154 possibilities (if you want to see all 154 combos, they are at the bottom of this article), 14 QBBCs will beat Ryan Tannehill.

Rank
Quarterback 1
Quarterback 2
Fantasy PPG
1 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Lance/Garoppolo - SF 24.12
2 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 24.08
3 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.80
4 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Carson Wentz - Ind 23.74
5 Kirk Cousins - Min Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.64
6 Fields/Dalton - Chi Trevor Lawrence - Jac 23.62
7 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Newton/Jones - NE 23.56
8 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 23.42
9 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Newton/Jones - NE 23.37
10 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Bridgewater/Lock - Den 23.34
11 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Carson Wentz - Ind 23.30
12 Kirk Cousins - Min Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 23.33
13 Fields/Dalton - Chi Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 23.33
14 Fields/Dalton - Chi Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.18

Of course, it's immediately apparent that there are two kinds of teams making up these committees:

  • Teams where we know exactly who is starting at quarterback.
  • Teams where we don't know the Week 1 starter.

So we have multiple QBBC options for this season.

The 3-Player QBBC: Trevor Lawrence and Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo

If you have no issues rostering three quarterbacks or want to bank on Lance getting the Week 1 nod in San Francisco, this trio (or duo if you want to exclude Garoppolo) is your QBBC.

Week
Starting Quarterback
Opponent
1 Lance/Garoppolo - SF at Detroit
2 Lance/Garoppolo - SF at Philadelphia
3 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Arizona
4 Lance/Garoppolo - SF vs. Seattle
5 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Tennessee
6 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Miami
7 Lance/Garoppolo - SF vs. Indianapolis
8 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Seattle
9 Lance/Garoppolo - SF vs. Arizona
10 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Indianapolis
11 Lance/Garoppolo - SF at Jacksonville
12 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Atlanta
13 Lance/Garoppolo - SF at Seattle
14 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Tennessee
15 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Houston
16 Lance/Garoppolo - SF at Tennessee
17 Lance/Garoppolo - SF vs. Houston

The 2-Player QBBC: Trevor Lawrence and Tua Tagovailoa

If you are concerned whether the 49ers will give some starts to Garoppolo and don't want to carry three quarterbacks, Lawrence and Tagovailoa are your targets.

Week
Starting Quarterback
Opponent
1 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Houston
2 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Buffalo
3 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Arizona
4 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Indianapolis
5 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Tennessee
6 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at Jacksonville
7 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Atlanta
8 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Seattle
9 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Houston
10 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Baltimore
11 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at NY Jets
12 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Atlanta
13 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. NY Giants
14 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at Tennessee
15 Trevor Lawrence - Jac vs. Houston
16 Trevor Lawrence - Jac at NY Jets
17 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at Tennessee

The Non-Rookie QBBC: Kirk Cousins and Tua Tagovailoa

If you just can't abide taking rookie quarterbacks, here's your top option.

Week
Starting Quarterback
Opponent
1 Kirk Cousins - Min at Cincinnati
2 Kirk Cousins - Min at Arizona
3 Kirk Cousins - Min vs. Seattle
4 Kirk Cousins - Min vs. Cleveland
5 Kirk Cousins - Min vs. Detroit
6 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at Jacksonville
7 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Atlanta
8 Kirk Cousins - Min vs. Dallas
9 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Houston
10 Kirk Cousins - Min at LA Chargers
11 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at NY Jets
12 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. Carolina
13 Kirk Cousins - Min at Detroit
14 Kirk Cousins - Min vs. Pittsburgh
15 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia vs. NY Jets
16 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at New Orleans
17 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia at Tennessee

All of the QBBCs

Rank
Quarterback 1
Quarterback 2
Fantasy PPG
1 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Lance/Garoppolo - SF 24.12
2 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 24.08
3 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.8
4 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Carson Wentz - Ind 23.74
5 Kirk Cousins - Min Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.64
6 Fields/Dalton - Chi Trevor Lawrence - Jac 23.62
7 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Newton/Jones - NE 23.56
8 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 23.42
9 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Newton/Jones - NE 23.37
10 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Bridgewater/Lock - Den 23.34
11 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Carson Wentz - Ind 23.3
12 Kirk Cousins - Min Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 23.33
13 Fields/Dalton - Chi Tua Tagovailoa - Mia 23.33
14 Fields/Dalton - Chi Lance/Garoppolo - SF 23.18
15 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 23.05
16 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Sam Darnold - Car 23.05
17 Fields/Dalton - Chi Carson Wentz - Ind 23.06
18 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Matt Ryan - Atl 23.01
19 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Derek Carr - LV 23
20 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Bridgewater/Lock - Den 23
21 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 23.02
22 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Derek Carr - LV 22.85
23 Fields/Dalton - Chi Kirk Cousins - Min 22.95
24 Fields/Dalton - Chi Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 22.94
25 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Matt Ryan - Atl 22.78
26 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Winston/Hill - NO 22.83
27 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 22.84
28 Kirk Cousins - Min Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 22.79
29 Kirk Cousins - Min Newton/Jones - NE 22.71
30 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Zach Wilson - NYJ 22.58
31 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Baker Mayfield - Cle 22.59
32 Kirk Cousins - Min Derek Carr - LV 22.59
33 Kirk Cousins - Min Bridgewater/Lock - Den 22.61
34 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Sam Darnold - Car 22.6
35 Kirk Cousins - Min Matt Ryan - Atl 22.54
36 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Daniel Jones - NYG 22.48
37 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Carson Wentz - Ind 22.46
38 Carson Wentz - Ind Bridgewater/Lock - Den 22.5
39 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Bridgewater/Lock - Den 22.46
40 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Derek Carr - LV 22.37
41 Fields/Dalton - Chi Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 22.36
42 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Daniel Jones - NYG 22.42
43 Fields/Dalton - Chi Bridgewater/Lock - Den 22.39
44 Fields/Dalton - Chi Newton/Jones - NE 22.42
45 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Zach Wilson - NYJ 22.31
46 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Baker Mayfield - Cle 22.29
47 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Daniel Jones - NYG 22.32
48 Kirk Cousins - Min Carson Wentz - Ind 22.26
49 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 22.33
50 Derek Carr - LV Carson Wentz - Ind 22.32
51 Fields/Dalton - Chi Sam Darnold - Car 22.26
52 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Jared Goff - Det 22.18
53 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Jared Goff - Det 22.17
54 Kirk Cousins - Min Daniel Jones - NYG 22.23
55 Kirk Cousins - Min Baker Mayfield - Cle 22.17
56 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Newton/Jones - NE 22.24
57 Carson Wentz - Ind Baker Mayfield - Cle 22.23
58 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Baker Mayfield - Cle 22.18
59 Matt Ryan - Atl Carson Wentz - Ind 22.12
60 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Bridgewater/Lock - Den 22.08
61 Fields/Dalton - Chi Derek Carr - LV 22.14
62 Newton/Jones - NE Sam Darnold - Car 22.08
63 Fields/Dalton - Chi Matt Ryan - Atl 22.01
64 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Sam Darnold - Car 21.97
65 Matt Ryan - Atl Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 21.91
66 Kirk Cousins - Min Winston/Hill - NO 21.89
67 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Winston/Hill - NO 21.85
68 Trevor Lawrence - Jac Taylor/Mills/Driskel - Hou 21.89
69 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 21.92
70 Carson Wentz - Ind Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 21.89
71 Derek Carr - LV Newton/Jones - NE 21.86
72 Carson Wentz - Ind Daniel Jones - NYG 21.87
73 Daniel Jones - NYG Newton/Jones - NE 21.91
74 Newton/Jones - NE Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.93
75 Carson Wentz - Ind Sam Darnold - Car 21.88
76 Fields/Dalton - Chi Winston/Hill - NO 21.81
77 Lance/Garoppolo - SF Taylor/Mills/Driskel - Hou 21.8
78 Kirk Cousins - Min Sam Darnold - Car 21.84
79 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Sam Darnold - Car 21.81
80 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Newton/Jones - NE 21.85
81 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.85
82 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Baker Mayfield - Cle 21.85
83 Fields/Dalton - Chi Baker Mayfield - Cle 21.83
84 Matt Ryan - Atl Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 21.71
85 Derek Carr - LV Ben Roethlisberger - Pit 21.74
86 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Daniel Jones - NYG 21.75
87 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Taylor/Mills/Driskel - Hou 21.74
88 Derek Carr - LV Matt Ryan - Atl 21.61
89 Matt Ryan - Atl Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.59
90 Matt Ryan - Atl Newton/Jones - NE 21.61
91 Kirk Cousins - Min Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.6
92 Bridgewater/Lock - Den Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.57
93 Carson Wentz - Ind Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.6
94 Carson Wentz - Ind Winston/Hill - NO 21.58
95 Kirk Cousins - Min Jared Goff - Det 21.58
96 Tua Tagovailoa - Mia Jared Goff - Det 21.58
97 Sam Darnold - Car Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.55
98 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.48
99 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Winston/Hill - NO 21.52
100 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Baker Mayfield - Cle 21.55
101 Daniel Jones - NYG Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.46
102 Baker Mayfield - Cle Newton/Jones - NE 21.5
103 Matt Ryan - Atl Sam Darnold - Car 21.39
104 Matt Ryan - Atl Baker Mayfield - Cle 21.43
105 Fields/Dalton - Chi Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.4
106 Newton/Jones - NE Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.39
107 Ben Roethlisberger - Pit Winston/Hill - NO 21.39
108 Kirk Cousins - Min Taylor/Mills/Driskel - Hou 21.39
109 Derek Carr - LV Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.42
110 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Daniel Jones - NYG 21.4
111 Baker Mayfield - Cle Bridgewater/Lock - Den 21.43
112 Newton/Jones - NE Winston/Hill - NO 21.34
113 Derek Carr - LV Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was 21.3
114 Ryan Fitzpatrick - Was Sam Darnold - Car 21.25
115 Carson Wentz - Ind Taylor/Mills/Driskel - Hou 21.31
116 Baker Mayfield - Cle Zach Wilson - NYJ 21.16
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Clayton Gray

 

Game Predictor: Week 2

Clayton Gray

Our Clayton Gray combines the Footballguys projections with Vegas lines to predict this week's NFL results.

09/10/25 Read More
 

Game Predictor: Week 1

Clayton Gray

Our Clayton Gray combines the Footballguys projections with Vegas lines to predict this week's NFL results.

09/02/25 Read More
 

Running Back Regret and Intrigue

Clayton Gray

As we head into Week 1, here's a look at which running backs' prospects have improved and declined over the summer.

08/31/25 Read More
 

Underdog ADP Movement: How Best-Ball ADP Is Changing

Clayton Gray

Underdog ADP offers insight into the current state of best-ball ADP and its ongoing movement.

08/31/25 Read More
 

Perfect Draft, 12-Team Home League

Clayton Gray

Our Perfect Draft series returns for another season as we run through strategy for your home league.

08/29/25 Read More
 

Running Back Classification Table

Clayton Gray

One look at how each NFL backfield breaks down from a fantasy perspective.

08/27/25 Read More