Backfield Breakdowns: Week 17

A ground-level breakdown of how each team doles out snaps, rushes, and targets to their running backs.

Jeff Bell's Backfield Breakdowns: Week 17 Jeff Bell Published 12/24/2025

The football season often works like a barbell. Early results shape the narrative throughout the season, giving us our first taste of production after an offseason of speculation. The end of the season decides the championships. Through two fantasy playoff weeks, the League Winners are emerging. Ashton Jeanty was the overall RB1 in Week 16. Kenneth Gainwell is the RB7 over the last two weeks. Jaylen Warren is providing two fantasy RB1s in the Steelers offense. Tyrone Tracy Jr. and Tony Pollard are coming from obscurity in lost seasons to deliver big performances. Week 17 will add more new names to the mix and decide most championships. We break down the entire league.

© Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images running backs

Backfields Worth Noting

Some backfields saw noteworthy movement in Week 16:

  • Kansas City: The Chiefs are not expected to retain Isiah Pacheco. With their season over, they allowed him to lead the backfield and increase his value heading into free agency. 
  • New England: TreVeyon Henderson left early with a concussion, pushing Rhamondre Stevenson into a lead role. If Henderson does not clear protocol, it will be another heavy Stevenson week. 
  • LA Chargers: Kimani Vidal has not returned to practice after suffering an injury late in Week 16. If he is inactive, expense Omarion Hampton to serve in a Bellcow role. 
  • Cleveland: Quinshon Judkins' season is over with a leg injury. Raheim Sanders should take the lead role with touches, though monitor Dylan Sampson's availability.

Bellcow Backfields

Team Back Player Rushes Targets Stat Line Share Snap %
Detroit RB1 Jahmyr Gibbs 7 13 7-2-0 / 10-66-1 83% 86%
RB2 David Montgomery 4 0 4-14-0 17% 18%
RB3 Jacob Saylors 0 0 0 0% 0%
Indianapolis RB1 Jonathan Taylor 16 3 16-46-1 / 3-33-0 83% 88%
RB2 Ameer Abdullah 0 1 1-4-0 4% 7%
RB3 Tyler Goodson 3 0 3-9-0 13% 8%
Jacksonville RB1 Travis Etienne Jr. 16 5 16-50-0 / 4-16-1 84% 70%
RB2 LeQuint Allen Jr. 4 0 4-10-0 16% 30%
RB3 Bhayshul Tuten 0 0 0 0% 0%
Kansas City RB1 Isiah Pacheco 8 7 8-34-0 / 6-41-0 79% 73%
RB2 Kareem Hunt 3 0 3-2-0 16% 24%
RB3 Brashard Smith 0 1 1-4-0 5% 18%
Las Vegas RB1 Ashton Jeanty 24 2 24-128-1 / 1-60-1 93% 93%
RB2 Raheem Mostert 1 1 1-6-0 / 1-3-0 7% 7%
RB3 Dylan Laube 0 0 0 0% 0%
New England RB1 Rhamondre Stevenson 8 3 8-51-1 / 2-27-0 65% 84%
RB2 TreVeyon Henderson 5 1 5-3-0 / 1-9-0 35% 19%
RB3 D'Ernest Johnson 0 0 0 0% 1%
Philadelphia RB1 Saquon Barkley 21 2 21-132-1 / 0 82% 77%
RB2 Tank Bigsby 4 0 4-37-1 14% 11%
RB3 Will Shipley 0 1 1-3-0 4% 11%
San Francisco RB1 Christian McCaffrey 21 8 21-117-0 / 6-29-2 83% 80%
RB2 Brian Robinson Jr. 5 1 5-20-0 / 0 17% 15%
RB3 Jordan James 0 0 0 0% 5%
  • Gibbs, De'Von Achane, and Bijan Robinson have all accomplished roughly the same rare feat with their own twist. Achance as the lead in rushing yards, Robinson has the receiving yards, and Gibbs has the touchdowns. He's the eighth player in history with 1,110+ rushing, 70+ receiving, 400+ yards, and 13+ touchdowns. The Lions face the Vikings and the Bears and have a very specific path to the postseason: win out and have the Packers lose out. Gibbs struggled in his first matchup against Minnesota, clocking one of his lowest yardage totals of the season. 

  • Taylor has the second-best season of his career, with 1,489 rushing yards and 17 touchdowns. His total is the seventh most for a Colts season, and he has a great chance to move into the Top 4, needing 64 yards to catch Edgerrin James' 1999 season. His next rushing touchdown would tie his own franchise record. James Cook had been closing hard on Taylor for the rushing title and finally caught him in Week 16. Cook now leads by 43 yards. The Colts close with two AFC South matchups, against the Jaguars and Texans.

  • Etienne crossed the 5,000 career scrimmage yards threshold, joining Fred Taylor, Jimmy Smith, Maurice Jones-Drew, and Keenan McCardell as the only Jaguars to cross the mark. He has a new career high with 13 touchdowns, with 32 in his career; he trails Marcedes Lewis by one for fifth on the team's record book. Etienne's future with the team is up in the air, given his free agent status. The contract extension Jakobi Meyers signed has further clouded Etienne's future, given the cap commitment. The Jaguars have a significant matchup against the Colts before closing against the Titans. The Week 18 contest could have little significance depending on Week 17's results. 

© Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images

  • The Chiefs are giving Pacheco the lead chance to improve his value in free agency. ESPN's Nate Taylor suggested the team does not expect Pacheco back and is expected to be aggressive in pursuing a top backfield option. Smith is the only back under contract for 2026, though he would need to work to be the primary backup. We should expect the team to step into both free agency and the draft to add talent to a position group that contributed to the disappointing season. If Hunt is done with the team, he will likely end in eighth on the franchise rushing list, with 3,436 (Marcus Allen is next at 3,698), and his 30 touchdowns are in the same position (Ed Podolak next at 34).

  • Jeanty set a new career high in scrimmage yards and delivered his first big performance since Week 4. He's the 61st rookie to top 1,100 scrimmage yards and 10 touchdowns in NFL history and the first in Raiders history. The Raiders close with a struggling Giants team and the Chiefs, who showed little fight in Week 16. 

  • Henderson left early with a concussion, putting his status for Week 17 in doubt. Without his involvement, Stevenson took on a lead-back role, which he should carry into Week 17 against the Jets. The Patriots close with the Dolphins and need to take both games to avoid the Bills stealing the AFC East. 

  • Barkley crossed the 1,000-yard threshold and sits 155 yards from unlocking a $250,000 contract incentive. His next touchdown will give him four straight double-digit touchdown seasons. Barkley faces a Buffalo defense that has struggled poorly through portions of the season.

  • McCaffrey crossed the 1,000 rushing yard threshold. He needs 151 receiving yards to hit 1,000 yards and would become the first player in NFL history with multiple 1,000-1,000 seasons. McCaffrey is closing in on his third 100 catch season, a threshold he has not met since 2019. He is currently the only running back with two 100-catch seasons. Hitting eight receptions would also move him into a tie with LaDainian Tomlinson for the third most running back receptions. 

Committees With a Lead Back

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Jeff Bell

 

Monday NFL Roundup: Week 17

Jeff Bell

Rounding up all of last week's action in the NFL, including significant stats, spikes, landmines, and deep sleepers.

12/22/25 Read More
 

50 Final Thoughts For 2025 Fantasy Drafts

Jeff Bell

Jeff Bell runs through sleepers, average draft position values, and stats to know before your fantasy football drafts.

08/25/25 Read More
 

NFL Fantasy Fix: Week 16

Jeff Bell

No matter your craving, get your fix here, featuring cries of revenge, player props, DFS stacks, stats, panic meters, and more.

12/20/25 Read More
 

Roundtable: Offseason Dynasty Advice

Jeff Bell

Wood, Hindery, Hicks, Weisse, Major, and Montgomery give advance for Dynasty managers heading into the offseason.

12/18/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Movement: Week 16

Jeff Bell

A panel of Footballguys staffers discusses why certain quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends should be moving up or down your dynasty rankings.

12/18/25 Read More
 

The Targets Report: Week 16

Jeff Bell

An aerial reality check, analyzing every team's target and snap share report, searching out the receivers who are, or who are becoming, true fantasy gold.

12/18/25 Read More