In and Out. No, not the burgers (fantastic though they are). This article is the fantasy football version. In an ideal world, you would roll through the Footballguys positional Rankings and Projections, skimming all your picks right off the top. By all means, those living in a perfect world should do that.
But if you're like the rest of us and play in the shadowy, nuanced world of one-and-done contests and daily fantasy, particularly DFS tournaments where contrarian plays are almost required, the top players might not be options. That being the case, this article won't be a chalkfest. Instead, we'll focus on players who might be uniquely positioned to outperform expectations. Conversely, we'll fade some big names -- yes, even ones that might make you uncomfortable. That's the whole idea.
We'll look at nine players: four that merit lineup consideration (the In), four that don't hit quite right (the Out), and an Outlier of the Week.
First, let me stress: if any of my choices make you uneasy, it's because they're supposed to. If that's not for you, please default to the Footballguys Rankings/Projections.
In and Out Accountability
I use this spot to review my previous week's results. It hasn't been my best season, but I suspect I'm not alone in this. The variance and volatility that are part and parcel of the game seem to be ratcheted up more than ever this season.
My work here reflects that.
But no excuses. Just accountability and explanations for another less-than-impressive showing in Week 10. Let's sift through the ashes.
- I was in on Jets QB Geno Smith, who was projected for a QB18 finish (with 15.9 points) in a favorable matchup against the Bills. While he was able to pass a concussion evaluation early in the game, his day was ultimately cut short by an ankle injury. He finished as QB27 with 5.9 points. His replacement, Cade Klubnik, was QB26 with 6.1 points. So even combining the two wouldn't have made this work. Whatever the case, injuries don't get me off the hook. This was a miss. ❌
- I was out on Packers QB Jordan Love, who was projected for a QB7 finish (with 19 points) in a matchup against a ferocious Vikings defense. While Love fared well against Minnesota earlier this year, I expected him to fall outside the top 10 this week. He finished as QB23 with 10.8 points. A hit! ✅
- I was in on Dolphins RB Ollie Gordon II, who was projected for an RB14 finish (with 14.1 points) in a great matchup against the Colts. I acknowledged we would need some end-zone luck to make good on my assertion that Gordon would exceed that RB14 finish. The desired touchdown didn't materialize, and Gordon finished as RB16. Close, but still a miss. ❌
- I was out on Bengals RB Chase Brown, who was projected for an RB13 finish (with 15 points). Since he'd only hit that mark twice this season, and because the Steelers had been tough on opposing ball carriers -- but mostly because he's had a hard time finding the end zone -- I predicted he would fall short of that RB13 finish. Sigh. Two touchdowns (and nearly a third) later, Brown was RB5 with 28.3 points. The missiest miss this week. ❌
- I was in on Chiefs WR Rashee Rice, who was projected for a WR20 finish (with 13 points) in a favorable matchup against the Falcons. I felt an increasing workload dovetailed nicely with that matchup, offering Rice an opportunity to exceed that WR20 spot. Newly acquired Josh Downs, who caught one touchdown on five targets, had other ideas. Rice finished as WR24. Close again. Also, still a miss. ❌
- I was out on Falcons WR Drake London, who was projected to finish as WR12 (with 15.9 points) against the Chiefs. Given the recent struggles of Michael Penix Jr. and Atlanta's offense, I predicted London would fall outside of WR1 territory. He finished as WR14. Whew. A much-needed hit. ✅
- I was in on Patriots TE Hunter Henry, who was projected for a TE12 finish (with 9.5 points) in one of the most favorable positional matchups possible. Detroit might not be good at stopping tight ends, but the Patriots were a disaster after Drake Maye was hurt on the first series. Henry finished as TE26. A whopping miss. ❌
- I was out on Browns TE Harold Fannin Jr., who was projected for a TE9 finish (with 11.2 points) against a Texans defense that hasn't been great this year -- except when it came to stopping tight ends. That greatness ended on Sunday. Fannin finished as TE3. Another soul-crushing miss. ❌
- As for my Outlier of the Week, Jaguars RB Chris Rodriguez Jr.? Well . . . His Footballguys projection called for an RB39 finish (with 7.3 points). It felt like a low bar, especially with Bhayshul Tuten limited in practice all week. Naturally, a well-rested Tuten dominated the backfield in the win over Tennessee, and Rodriguez finished as RB69. Yeesh. That's a miss. ❌
My 2-7 finish was a far cry from Week 9's 4-5 outing, and it had me longing for that 3-6 outcome in Week 8. Of course, I have nobody to blame but myself, and maybe the fantasy gods who continued to remind me -- this week with injuries and unexpected touchdowns -- why remaining humble is important.
Here's where we stand after Week 10:
Week 10: 2-7
Season: 35-55
The goal here, whether it's realistic or not, is to finish at .500 or better on my predictions. With Week 10 factored in, I've fallen to .389, further diminishing my chances of reaching my objective. And as much as I'd love to pretend none of this has happened, that's not the job. We keep grinding.
And with that, let's dive into Week 11.
Week 11 Picks at a Glance
In: Kirk Cousins, Omarion Hampton, Carnell Tate, Mike Gesicki
Out: Brock Purdy, Bucky Irving, Emeka Egbuka, Trey McBride
Outlier to Watch: Antonio Williams
Quarterback
In: Kirk Cousins, Minnesota vs. San Francisco (in Mexico City)
Cousins' return to Minnesota was enough to spark the team's offense in a Week 10 win in Green Bay. The Vikings put 30 points on the scoreboard -- their most since Week 1 -- and totaled 312 yards -- their most since Week 5.
As expected, the veteran signal-caller unlocked Justin Jefferson (nine receptions for 74), at one point hitting the star receiver on six consecutive passes in the fourth quarter.
But Cousins also notched his eighth game with multiple passing touchdowns, tied for most in the NFL this season.
This week, the Vikings face a vulnerable 49ers defense. Over the last six weeks, the Niners have allowed an average of 19 points to quarterbacks. What's more, four opposing signal-callers have scored 20-plus points against them since Week 5 -- with three of them coming in the last four weeks.
The lone quarterback to fall short during that four-game stretch? Cousins.
As CBSSports.com's Jamey Eisenberg noted, in that game, Raiders tight end Michael Mayer lost two potential touchdowns (he fumbled at the goal line and had a touchdown negated by a penalty), and Cousins threw an interception in the end zone as well.
This time, after two weeks of practice with his new team, Cousins gets another shot at the 49ers' defense, which allowed 32.4 points to Dak Prescott last week.
Bottom line: Cousins' Footballguys projection calls for a QB16 finish (with 16.1 points). I believe that having a better overall supporting cast will allow him to fare better this week -- enough to surpass that QB16 projection.
Out: Brock Purdy, San Francisco vs. Minnesota (in Mexico City)
As always, an "Out" designation in this column doesn't mean you shouldn't start the player in regular, season-long fantasy leagues. But you should reset expectations.
And much like I did when Jordan Love and the potent Packers passing attack faced them last week, I'm doing the same with Purdy.
Are we getting to the point that we're fading every quarterback who faces Minnesota's defense?
Well . . . It's a pretty good starting point.
As ESPN.com's Tristan Cockcroft noted, over the five weeks preceding Sunday's game, Love and wide receivers Matthew Golden and Christian Watson ranked among the top eight in fantasy points scored. In Week 10, they managed 10.8, 12.0, and 6.7 points, with Love's and Watson's numbers representing season lows.
Chalk much of this up to Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores dialing up a relentless pass rush (a week-high 68 percent blitz and 82 percent pass rush win rates), which led to Love being sacked eight times. But it wasn't just the eight sacks. The Vikings also pressured Love 31 times, per Next Gen Stats, and further confounded him with rotating coverages.
This isn't new.
This unit has performed at an elite, historic level all season, allowing just 14 points per game (first in the league) and 1.24 points per drive. They attack in ways that other teams don't even attempt. Their year-to-date blitz rate of 72.3 percent is 29.4 percentage points higher than the second-place Buccaneers.
The Vikings have allowed the fewest passing completions and passing TDs (6), as well as the lowest completion rate (58 percent), while also producing the most sacks (37) and the fourth-most interceptions (10).
Yes, Purdy is fantasy's third-highest-scoring QB (with consecutive top-five outings), but Minnesota is allowing 9.1 fantasy points per game to opposing quarterbacks this season.
They have held eight consecutive QBs below 13 fantasy points -- a list that includes Love, Josh Allen, Jared Goff, Caleb Williams and Tyler Shough, who scored negative points against Minnesota in Week 5.
To be clear, this is a strength-on-strength situation. Purdy leads the league in touchdowns (12), passer rating, and yards per attempt against the blitz.
Again, those needing to start Purdy absolutely should -- with the requisite lowered expectations.
Bottom line: Purdy's Footballguys projection calls for a QB9 finish (with 18.7 points). I'll say he falls outside the top 10.
Running Back
In: Omarion Hampton, Los Angeles Chargers vs. New York Jets
It took a minute, but Hampton had his breakout game on Monday Night Football in Baltimore.
Hampton carried the ball 22 times for 105 yards and a touchdown. As SB Nation reported, the second-year back created explosive runs and was incredibly efficient through contact.
It was enough to make you wonder why Hampton wasn't the team's RB1 over the last two months.
The Athletic's Noah Furtado asked head coach Jim Harbaugh why it took Hampton this long to re-establish himself as the bell-cow RB: "He's there. He's showing it, proving it. And that's all. That's what's important to me," Harbaugh said.
Is that enough for us to assume Hampton will continue to handle a bell-cow role?
Hampton has played on over 60 percent of snaps just twice this season, going for 115 and 105 rushing yards (respectively) with a touchdown in each.
Since Week 3, we've also seen six games of Hampton in a rotation with the other backs compared to this one matchup against the Ravens.
The big difference this time? The Chargers got their first win of the season.
If we're banking on Hampton to continue to get the ball, he'll be carrying it against a Jets defense that allows the second-most rushing yards before contact per carry. New York ranks 30th in the league at 135.3 rushing yards allowed per game.
And they seem to be getting worse with each passing week.
In his Week 11 Rushing Matchups, Footballguy Devin Knotts wrote, "The Jets' run defense has been falling apart over the last month."
That helps explain how three running backs have scored at least 17.3 fantasy points over the last four games. That includes two straight weeks with at least 21 points, as James Cook III scored 21.7 in Week 10 and Ken Walker III scored 36.3 in Week 9.
Bottom line: Hampton's Footballguys projection calls for an RB21 finish (with 11.8 points). I think Hampton will get the workload necessary to finish inside the top 20 for a second straight week.
Out: Bucky Irving, Tampa Bay @ Detroit
I'll admit, my quarterback plays feel a little chalky. So let's fix that.
Entering Sunday's game, the Buccaneers find themselves in the unique position of having the NFL's No. 1 rushing offense and No. 32 passing offense.
And the Bucs (3-6) make no secret of their plan: despite not having the luxury of burning clock late in wins, they have the third-most rushing attempts (294) in the NFL.
As a result, Irving ranks fifth in rushing yards (825) with seven touchdowns.
He has three 100-yard rushing games this year, doubling his career total to six. In the past two weeks, he put up 267 yards on the ground against two top-five rushing defenses in the matchups versus the Falcons and the Bears.
So, what gives?
This is about the matchup. As Knotts noted, Detroit's run defense has been on a historic run.
After allowing almost 120 rushing yards per game during the first four weeks, Detroit has held opponents to an average of just 67 rushing yards per game during its five-game winning streak.
Over those five games, the Lions haven't allowed more than 85 rushing yards or more than 21 points in a single game, and they haven't allowed a single rushing touchdown, which has never been done in franchise history.
They've also allowed the second-lowest rushing success rate, the fewest yards after contact per attempt, and the fifth-fewest rushing yards over expectation per attempt over that span.
While Detroit will be without two defensive stalwarts in linebacker Jack Campbell (injured reserve) and Aidan Hutchinson, Knotts believes the presence of Alim McNeill and Tyleik Williams in the interior keeps the Lions' run defense formidable.
Again, this one is more about setting realistic expectations. Irving is a starter in regular redraft leagues, but expecting him to hit his ceiling might be aiming too high.
Bottom line: Irving's Footballguys projection calls for an RB11 finish (with 16.7 points). I say he'll fall short of that RB11 mark against a defense that's held opposing running backs to single-digit fantasy scoring each of the last three weeks.
Wide Receiver
In: Carnell Tate, Tennessee @ Dallas
Well, leaning aggressively into Irving felt good. Let's do it again!
As SI.com's Nick Raducanu noted, the Titans' passing attack will see major fantasy football ripple effects for Week 11 as they've now placed wide receiver Wan'Dale Robinson on injured reserve due to an ankle injury suffered in Sunday's loss to Jacksonville.
Robinson has been quarterback Cam Ward's safety blanket all season, pacing the team with 54 targets and accounting for 38 receptions, 272 yards, and three touchdowns.
The biggest beneficiary of Robinson's absence is Tate.
I'm taking a bit of a chance here, as the rookie is listed as questionable due to the shoulder injury that sidelined him the last two games. But he practiced fully, and desperate times (see the Accountability section above) call for desperate measures.
Also, the game environment is irresistible.
As Cockcroft suggested, it speaks volumes about the poor quality of the defenses that a game featuring two teams with a combined 5-14 record has the week's highest over/under (54.5 points).
For the season, the Cowboys have been the seventh-most favorable matchup for opposing wide receivers, and sixth most for WR1s. In the past four weeks alone, Makai Lemon, Michael Wilson, and Deebo Samuel Sr. have each scored at least 19 fantasy points against them.
Adding to the positive outlook, Ward has played well in his past two games against Cincinnati and Jacksonville. He struggled for much of this season, but Ward is getting hot just in time for fantasy managers to trust him in a great matchup against the Cowboys.
Bottom line: Tate's Footballguys projection calls for a WR15 finish (14.1 points). I say Tate will beat that WR15 finish.
Out: Emeka Egbuka, Tampa Bay @ Detroit
What the heck happened here? Expectations for Egbuka were high this summer, but the anticipated breakout hasn't happened.
Egbuka missed two games with an injury, and the Bucs have experienced disruption at quarterback due to Baker Mayfield's thumb injury. Mayfield should play this week, but the Bucs, who have attempted the fewest passes in the league (240), are the worst passing offense in the NFL.
NFL.com's Matt Okada notes that while Egbuka managed a rushing touchdown in Week 5 and a receiving touchdown in Week 6, he still hasn't hit 65 receiving yards in a game all season.
Meanwhile, as SI.com's Michael Fabiano notes, Detroit's defense has allowed the fourth-fewest points per game to wideouts since Week 5, so this isn't the favorable matchup it was earlier in the year.
Egbuka is still startable in redraft leagues that require three wideouts in your starting lineup, but we should temper expectations.
Bottom line: Egbuka's Footballguys projection calls for a WR22 finish (with 12.1 points). I say Egbuka finishes outside WR2 territory.
Tight End
In: Mike Gesicki, Cincinnati @ Washington
With Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins dominating the receiving totals for the Bengals, it's easy to overlook Gesicki.
A slow Week 10 didn't help his cause.
As FantasyPros' Derek Brown noted, after two strong games of snap usage and route share, Gesicki saw his role crater last week with a 40 percent snap rate and a 45.7 percent route share.
Gesicki had only a 4.5 percent target share.
So there's plenty of volatility with this one. Still, a matchup against Washington makes him a viable streamer.
The Commanders' defense has allowed the second-most fantasy points and the fifth-most points per route run over the last six weeks, and five tight ends have beaten them for 17-plus points in 2026.
The Commanders also have allowed nine receiving touchdowns to the position (second-most). Gesicki has six scores this season and is linked to Joe Burrow, who's thrown at least four touchdowns in four of the last five games.
In four games in which he's seen at least three targets, Eisenberg notes that Gesicki has scored at least 12.7 fantasy points. Cockcroft adds that Gesicki is averaging by far the fewest targets per touchdown (4.7), making him an especially attractive streaming option in a heavy bye week.
Bottom line: Gesicki's Footballguys projection calls for a TE16 finish (with 8.0 points). He'll finish inside the top 15.
Out: Trey McBride, Arizona @ Kansas City
McBride had a 28 percent target share in Carson Beck's debut as the Cardinals' starting quarterback last Sunday. But as Late-Round Fantasy's JJ Zachariason noted, given the number of plays the Cardinals ran, that resulted in just five targets.
With Beck at the helm, Arizona's offense ran only 34 plays, earned six first downs, and failed on all six third-down attempts.
That's McBride's lowest target total in a game since Week 16 of the 2024 season. His 37 receiving yards against the Rams mark his second-lowest total this year.
The good news?
Beck is likely out this week.
The bad news?
The Cardinals may have a fourth starting quarterback in four weeks when they play the Chiefs on Sunday.
With Beck dealing with back spasms, veteran backup Josh Johnson is in line to start in Week 11. If that's how it plays out, it will be Johnson's first time playing for Arizona in the regular season.
But he has some experience. Johnson has appeared in regular-season games for seven teams, including the Jets back in 2021 when Cardinals head coach Mike LaFleur was the team's offensive coordinator.
Still, we must acknowledge this isn't a great situation. It's also fair to wonder if the offense will be noticeably better with Johnson at the helm.
As Yahoo's Ray Garvin noted this week, when drives end after a few snaps, even a strong target share means limited opportunities.
"McBride didn't lose his role," Garvin added. "Arizona simply couldn't keep its offense on the field."
I'm still starting McBride in redraft. And I think he can outperform his 8.7-point, TE14 finish from last week.
But by a lot? That seems like a reach.
Bottom line: McBride's Footballguys projection calls for a TE2 finish (with 14.5 points). I expect him to fall outside the top five at the position.
Outlier of the Week
Washington wide receiver Antonio Williams has yet to deliver a breakout fantasy performance, but ESPN's Mike Clay believes Williams is getting close.
The rookie wide receiver has scored only two touchdowns -- one in Week 1 and one in Week 10 -- but those scores came on a combined six targets and mark his only games reaching 11 fantasy points. He's also reached six targets in three out of nine games, although they resulted in a total of 100 yards on 11 catches.
So what's changed?
Williams has become a full-time player. He's handled at least 82 percent of offensive snaps in all three games since Terry McLaurin's season-ending injury. He's also scored 10 or more points in two of his past three games, and he has seen a total of 15 targets during this stretch.
His Footballguys projection calls for a WR34 finish (with 10.0 points). I say he finishes inside the top 30.
One more time: I'm taking chances and painting outside the lines here. If that's not for you, please default to the Footballguys Rankings/Projections.
Harris was the FSWA's first-ever Football Writer of the Year back in 2004; he was inducted into that organization's Hall of Fame in 2013. Catch Harris every weekday morning on the Footballguys Daily Update Podcast, your 10-minute daily dose of NFL news and fantasy analysis. Find the latest edition here or subscribe on your podcast platform of choice. You can also listen to Harris weeknights on SiriusXM Fantasy Sports Radio's The Football Diehards show and Sundays on the SXM Fantasy Football Pregame show on Sirius channel 87, and Saturday nights on SiriusXM NFL Radio, Sirius channel 88.
Follow @footballdiehard Follow @Footballguys