Drafting in a Vacuum: Calibrating My QB Projections Against Consensus
Going live with projections in early February means operating in a vacuum, with no industry benchmarks for comparison. While it is thrilling to be among the first to put our analysis out there, it also means accepting that initial projections will naturally deviate from the eventual market consensus.
DON'T MISS OUT: Sign up for our free, daily newsletter here.
Needless to say, my rankings have evolved significantly over the last few months as coaching changes, free agency, and the NFL draft altered the landscape. Now that the rest of the industry is finally launching their projections, it's the perfect time to stack my numbers against the broader market consensus and highlight the biggest discrepancies.
My goal isn't to stand out from the crowd just for the sake of it, but to ensure every deviation is intentional. That intentionality is where you find your edge; it's where you can optimize your drafts while your league mates blindly trust site ADPs and generic cheat sheets.
Key Quarterback Differences
| My Rank | Player | Team | Industry Rank | ADP | Average | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Drake Maye | NE | 2 | 5 | 3.5 | 1.5 |
| 5 | Jalen Hurts | PHI | 6 | 7 | 6.5 | 1.5 |
| 6 | Lamar Jackson | BAL | 3 | 2 | 2.5 | (3.5) |
| 7 | Dak Prescott | DAL | 10 | 8 | 9.0 | 2.0 |
| 8 | Caleb Williams | CHI | 7 | 6 | 6.5 | (1.5) |
| 12 | Bo Nix | DEN | 14 | 15 | 14.5 | 2.5 |
| 14 | Jaxson Dart | NYG | 11 | 13 | 12.0 | (2.0) |
| 15 | Patrick Mahomes II | KC | 13 | 11 | 12.0 | (3.0) |
| 18 | Tyler Shough | NO | 20 | 20 | 20.0 | 2.0 |
| 21 | Jordan Love | GB | 18 | 18 | 18.0 | (3.0) |
| 22 | Daniel Jones | IND | 25 | 25 | 25.0 | 3.0 |
| 23 | Malik Willis | MIA | 21 | 21 | 21.0 | (2.0) |
| 24 | Aaron Rodgers | PIT | 28 | 28 | 28.0 | 4.0 |
Drake Maye-Be Fantasy's Top Quarterback
Drake Maye: My QB2 vs. Consensus QB3.5
The Situation: This is a case of the industry very rapidly catching up with my long-standing enthusiasm. I had Maye as my QB2 months ago, anticipating a significant bolstering of his offensive supporting cast in conjunction with a natural progression from Year One to Year Two in Josh McDaniels' complex system. But as you can see, the consensus has gone from Maye at QB6 a few months back to QB3.5. I wrote a detailed Player Spotlight explaining why Maye is elite and why I expected the market to meet me where I already was.
Odds of Adjusting: LOW
Since making my case, the Patriots have signed Romeo Doubs as an explosive WR2 and traded for perennial All-Pro A.J. Brown as the alpha. Wheels up. Barring injury, Maye will stay my No. 2 quarterback through draft season.
Jalen (Won't) Hurts Your Fantasy Team
Jalen Hurts: My QB5 vs. Consensus QB6.5
The Situation: Jalen Hurts' per-game fantasy rank over the last five seasons is as reliable a top-end baseline as you'll find: QB10, QB1, QB3, QB6, and QB8. I currently project him to remain solidly in the top half of the QB1 tier. That assumes new OC Sean Mannion is up to the task and returns the offense back to the baseline we were used to prior to last year's falloff. It also assumes the offensive line, considered by most a top-3 unit, stays healthy.
Odds of Adjusting: HIGH
I don't envision pushing Hurts up or down more than a spot or two from here, but that subtle shift could be the difference between targeting him or another available asset at a key inflection point in your draft. We need to scour training camp reports to understand how Hurts and the offense are adjusting to a new system that will ask new things from each of them. Hurts has been in the shotgun more than almost any starter over the last five seasons and must learn to play comfortably under center. That's a big ask, while also integrating rookie Makai Lemon into the offense to replace an irreplaceable A.J. Brown.
I'm Sorry, Mr. Jackson
Lamar Jackson: My QB6 vs. Consensus QB2.5
The Situation: A razor-thin supporting cast, a new offensive coordinator with zero play-calling experience, and a troubling injury history all make Jackson a hard bet for me as the second quarterback off the board. We know he's got overall QB1 upside, and there will be at least one manager in every draft willing to bet he returns to MVP form. That won't be me, and it probably shouldn't be you. I've written a Player Spotlight article about my views, and recommend particular caution if you're drafting in a Superflex or 2QB league.
Odds of Adjusting: LOW
I'm not sure the camp reports could be glowing enough to disregard the concerns I have about betting on Jackson's return to glory. Durability can't be tested in the summer, we won't have any inkling of Doyle's abilities as a play-caller in the preseason, and I don't foresee major structural changes to the offensive supporting cast.
Dak Im-Prescott Is Undervalued
Dak Prescott: My QB7 vs. Consensus QB9.0
The Situation: I was the low man on Prescott last offseason, fearing that Brian Schottenheimer would turn the team into a run-first offense. We know that didn't happen, as the Cowboys were a top-5 passing offense despite CeeDee Lamb missing time and not being 100%. Now the Cowboys are set to have George Pickens, Lamb, and an ever-improving Ryan Flournoy anchoring what should be another high-octane passing attack.
Odds of Adjusting: LOW
Prescott has finished as QB8 or higher six times in his career, despite a litany of coaching changes and personnel turnover. As long as the core pieces stay healthy in the preseason, I'll comfortably tier him a full round higher than consensus.