Week 16 Rest-of-Season Rankings

Assessing the ever-changing fantasy football landscape by generating rest-of-season rankings and adding context to the biggest risers and fallers.

Dave Kluge's Week 16 Rest-of-Season Rankings Dave Kluge Published 12/16/2025

If you're reading this, I can only imagine you've advanced to the second round of your fantasy playoffs. Congratulations! But you probably got lucky.

Of course, we know the old idiom. "Luck is when preparation meets opportunity." At some point, you increased your chances of getting lucky. You still got lucky.

Over the course of a season, the aggregate becomes more apparent. Outliers prove to live outside of the median range. Unexpected variance is smoothed out over a sufficiently long timeline.

In the playoffs, you can't hide behind excuses. It doesn't matter how tight the margins your losses came in. No one cares if you should have had a bye but got hosed by injuries. It's your best lineup against your leaguemates' best in a sudden-death matchup.

You may have snuck into the playoffs as the sixth seed. You've been starting Trevor Lawrence, the season-long QB15, and Kyle Pitts Sr., the season-long TE12. Both were fringe starters going into the week, but you got 84.8 points between the two of them.

© Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images, kyle pitts, kyle pitts fantasy, footallguys, dave kluge, fantasy football, rest of season rankings,

Maybe your opponent started Patrick Mahomes II, the QB2 on the season, and Jake Ferguson, the TE5. Both were plug-and-play starters going into the week, and they combined for 16.7 points. 

Between your two solo positions, you've already locked in a 68.1-point advantage for the week.

In a single-game sample like this, outliers stand out like a sore thumb.

George Pickens was the WR3 coming into Week 15. His 4.8 points in Week 15 scored as the WR58. Jahmyr Gibbs, the per-game RB3 and hottest running back in football coming into the game, finished the week outside of the top 30 running backs.

Superstars faceplant, and sleepers awaken in single-game samples.

In the same way I jokingly said winners got lucky, losers should find solace in knowing that luck does play a huge factor in the playoffs. An undefeated team with the most points scored didn't matter when facing a Week 15 juggernaut with Trevor Lawrence, James Cook, Travis Etienne Jr., TreVeyon Henderson, Amon-Ra St. Brown, and Kyle Pitts Sr. starting.

What makes this part of fantasy football so fun is how it mimics what's happening in the league. The Falcons had no business going into Tampa Bay and beating the Buccaneers. The Bengals, fighting for a playoff spot, were embarrassingly shut out by the Ravens. The Chargers, with a hobbled Justin Herbert, ended the Chiefs' season in an Arrowhead upset. The Bills took down the top-seeded Patriots. The Saints hung 10 unanswered points in the fourth quarter to upset the Panthers.

This is why we love football. "On any given Sunday, you're gonna win, or you're gonna lose."

So when you win, don't minimize it. Don't chalk it up to luck. Enjoy the win. Relish the taste of winning's sweet fruit. Let your leaguemates know of your dominant prowess.

And when you lose, just maintain a healthy perspective and tell yourself that you got unlucky. It happens to the best of us. 

This will be the final edition of 2025's Rest-of-Season Rankings. This series has been a privilege to write this season, and I wish you the best of luck in the season's final two games.

Please come back next week to check out our Week 17 rankings, which are fully customizable to your league's roster and scoring settings.

In this article, I will rank every player by their rest-of-season value. With just two weeks left in the fantasy football regular season, shifts will be dramatic and future schedules will be considered. Next to each name will be a "+" or "-" indicating the movement from last week's rankings. Considerable movers will have added context. New players will be marked as "New."

Let's dive in, starting with the quarterbacks.

Quarterbacks

Quarterbacks have been the steadiest of all positions throughout this season. After the discovery phase during the first month of the season, just minor tweaks are required on a week-to-week basis. Patrick Mahomes II's season-ending injury moves everyone but Josh Allen and whoever is starting for the Jets up a spot.

© Morgan Tencza-Imagn Images, trevor lawrence, rest of season rankings, footballguys, trevor lawrence fantasy, fantasy football, dave kluge

Wide Receivers

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Footballguys.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Footballguys Mother's Day Card Generator

More by Dave Kluge

 

Dynasty Running Back Rankings and Tiers

Dave Kluge

2026 dynasty running back rankings and tiers. Full RB breakdown by archetype, with strategy tips for contenders and rebuilders in dynasty fantasy football.

05/06/26 Read More
 

Quarterback Rankings and Tiers: One Staffer's Opinion

Dave Kluge

Quarterback rankings provided by Dave Kluge, with explanations on where and why he strays from consensus opinions.

07/15/25 Read More
 

2026 Post-NFL Draft Dynasty Startup Draft

Dave Kluge

Full results from a 2026 post-NFL Draft dynasty startup draft, with expert analysis and strategy.

04/29/26 Read More
 

2026 NFL Draft Grades for All 32 NFL Teams (Full Breakdown & Analysis)

Dave Kluge

2026 NFL Draft grades for all 32 teams with a full breakdown of pre-draft needs, picks, value analysis, and more from every pick.

04/26/26 Read More
 

Eli Stowers Drafted by the Philadelphia Eagles: Fantasy Football Impact, Depth Chart, and 2026 Outlook

Dave Kluge

Eli Stowers was drafted by the Philadelphia Eagles in the 2026 NFL Draft. Here’s his fantasy football outlook, projected role, depth chart impact, and what it means for 2026 drafts.

04/25/26 Read More
 

NFFC $350 Draft Recap: Full 20-Pick Breakdown After Round 1 of the NFL Draft

Dave Kluge

Drafting right after Round 1 of the NFL Draft creates chaos and opportunity. We entered a $350 NFFC league before ADP adjusted and broke down all 20 picks, our roster construction, and the key decisions that shaped this build.

04/24/26 Read More