Is It Already Time to Panic on These Players?

Jason Wood's Is It Already Time to Panic on These Players? Jason Wood Published 09/11/2023

I am just finishing up my Week 2 projections, and I'm sure many of you join me in feeling the highs and lows of our preseason viewpoints being upended. Keep in mind that one week does not a season make, and many of the most disappointing Week 1 players will end up being just fine, while some of the week's best performers will end up falling off. So take this as a very early, very reactionary, honest assessment of how I'm feeling.

Here are some players and my level of concern or panic for them. The scale goes from 1 to 10. And it's based on the worry they won't return draft value. For example, Patrick Mahomes II finishing as the QB12 would be a much a bigger worry than Trey McBride not being a top-20 fantasy tight end.

The Scale

  • 1 is not panicked at all.
  • 10 is totally panicked.

Quarterbacks

  • Kenny Pickett (7), Steelers -- The Steelers' offense looked much the same as last year, and now Diontae Johnson is injured. We may have all fallen for meaningless preseason hype.
  • Daniel Jones (6), Giants -- The offensive line is horrendous, and they were far less effective last year than media hype and the Coach of the Year campaign suggested.
  • Aaron Rodgers (4), Jets -- He left Monday Night Football on the first drive, and was carted to the locker room.
  • Justin Fields (4), Bears -- He'll run enough to maintain some fantasy relevance, but he doesn't seem to have progressed at all as a field surveyor or passer.
  • Geno Smith (4), Seahawks -- Whenever a guy we all thought was league average has a bad Week 1 following an outlier season, my radar goes up. The loss of both tackles cannot be underestimated.
  • Lamar Jackson (3) Ravens -- The offense looked the same, despite Jackson's new contract and the arrival of Todd Monken.
  • Jalen Hurts (2), Eagles -- New play-caller Brian Johnson had a concerning debut, but it was his first week against a strong defense.
  • Joe Burrow (1), Bengals -- He got massacred in the first week last year, too, and ended up fine.

Running Backs

  • Cam Akers (7), Rams -- Kyren Williams was better.
  • Antonio Gibson (7), Commanders -- Another fumble and Brian Robinson's strong showing as a receiver don't bode well for the veteran.
  • Najee Harris (5), Steelers -- A plodder on a bad offense? Yikes!
  • Rachaad White (5), Buccaneers -- My worry was that we drafted him for lack of alternatives, ignoring that he's not a good player. Without Baker Mayfield's dump-offs, he's a bust.
  • Khalil Herbert (5), Bears -- The Bears used all their backs, and Roschon Johnson got the goal-line score, although the game was already out of hand.
  • Rhamondre Stevenson (4), Patriots -- Ezekiel Elliott played a lot, and Ty Montgomery was the third-down option.
  • Dameon Pierce (4), Texans -- The Texans' offense might be so bad that there aren't many games where a workhorse running back can produce.
  • Jamaal Williams (4), Saints -- You didn't draft him to be a key player, but you probably expected he'd be super useful in the first three weeks. So now what?

Wide Receivers

  • Drake London (8), Falcons -- I'm not sure he's usable in the current offensive system.
  • JuJu Smith-Schuster (7), Patriots -- Looks to be third or fourth in the pecking order.
  • Christian Kirk (6), Jaguars -- Didn't play in 2-WR sets (Zay Jones got the role over him). If this continues, Kirk could be a huge bust, barring injuries to Jones/Ridley.
  • Garrett Wilson (6), Jets -- If Rodgers misses significant time, our hopes for Wilson vaulting into elite territory are kaput. He was only WR58 in Weeks 4 through 11 last year with Zach Wilson.
  • Amari Cooper (5), Browns -- Didn't run many routes and essentially split snaps and routes evenly with Elijah Moore.
  • DJ Moore (5), Bears -- The Bears' offense appears moribund once again; he'll have big weeks, but the variance could be maddening.
  • DeAndre Hopkins (5), Titans -- He's the alpha, but Ryan Tannehill was so ineffective that the target volume could become an albatross.
  • George Pickens (4), Steelers -- Preseason hype for this vertical threat could be misdirection if the Steelers still can't—or won't—throw downfield effectively.
  • Marquise Brown (4), Cardinals -- Everything hinges on whether Kyler Murray returns in October.
  • Kadarius Toney (3), Chiefs -- I'd rate this higher if I hadn't already considered him a non-factor in the preseason.

Tight Ends

  • Greg Dulcich (6), Broncos -- The Adam Trautman summer vibes are real.
  • Kyle Pitts (5), Falcons -- Desmond Ridder is a fantasy black hole.
  • Dalton Schultz (4), Texans -- Just a guy; if you drafted him as more, you're probably disappointed.
  • Chigoziem Okonkwo (3), Titans -- He scored a goose egg but played monstrous snaps.
  • Dallas Goedert (1), Eagles -- He got blanked but ran 36 routes, second only to DeVonta Smith's 37. He'll be fine; he just probably won't make the breakout jump into elite territory that the beat writers projected.
Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

Quarterback Rankings and Tiers: One Staffer's Opinion

Dave Kluge

Quarterback rankings provided by Dave Kluge, with explanations on where and why he strays from consensus opinions.

07/15/25 Read More
 
 
 
 
The Myth of Geno Smith
Jason Wood
07/14/25 Read More

More by Jason Wood

 

Justin Fields: Overvaluing Rushing Upside

Jason Wood

Jason Wood deep dives on what Justin Fields rushing upside doesn't justify his ADP.

07/14/25 Read More
 

The Myth of Geno Smith

Jason Wood

Jason Wood takes a look at Geno Smith and how his reputation is living off one outlier season in 2022.

07/14/25 Read More
 

What to Expect from the New Play-Callers

Jason Wood

A deep dive into the 12 new NFL play-callers

07/11/25 Read More
 

15 Make Or Break Wide Receiver Situations in 2025

Jason Wood

These receiver situations will define whether you dominate your draft.

06/05/25 Read More
 

11 Running Back Situations You Must Get Right in 2025

Jason Wood

These running back situations are the ones most likely to make or break your draft.

06/04/25 Read More
 

10 Quarterback Situations That Will Define Your Draft in 2025

Jason Wood

We look at the 10 QB situations that will most impact your fantasy success or failure

06/02/25 Read More