Week 3 Passing Matchups

A top-to-bottom ranking of this week's NFL passing matchups, while providing details on both sides of the ball for the best and the worst pairings.

Devin Knotts's Week 3 Passing Matchups Devin Knotts Published 09/24/2026

Week 3 Passing Matchups

See Rushing Matchups here

Top 5 Passing Matchups

NY Jets at Detroit

Geno Smith has been a breath of fresh air in New York, if only by default. He's far more competent than Zach Wilson or Justin Fields, and he comes with far less drama than Aaron Rodgers did. Through two weeks, Smith has been perfectly serviceable, hitting on 71% of his throws. He's kept the ball close and all but eliminated the mistake-rich stretches we saw from him last year in Las Vegas. Now he faces an ailing Lions defense that can't seem to help itself when it comes to allowing yards and points in bunches. This offense has a strong chance to open up this week; it nearly did last week. Adonai Mitchell came tantalizingly close to two long catches, while Garrett Wilson continued to look like an all-purpose route winner and the clear No. 1 option across the field. It's easy to lose sight of just how consistent Wilson has been. He's fallen below 50 yards just once in his last eight games, and Week 3 pits him against an exceptionally shaky group of cover men. The x-factors are tight ends Mason Taylor and Kenyon Sadiq, both of whom could find room up the open seams in this matchup. It's a clear timeshare, but both are dynamic enough to make splash plays.

The Lions defense simply can't get healthy fast enough. Through nine quarters of play, this stripped-down secondary has been thoroughly beaten in seven. In the opener, Tyler Shough and the Saints roared back from an early deficit by attacking the seams, an area that still lacks both starting safeties. Last week, Josh Allen and Dalton Kincaid played a similar game of pitch-and-catch up and down the field. It's not just the absence of Brian Branch and Kerby Joseph, one of the league's best safety duos, to blame here, though they were certainly missed on Joshua Palmer's way-too-easy 43-yard touchdown in Week 2. D.J. Reed and Rock Ya-Sin, both typically strong man cover men, have started the year in shaky fashion, and Roger McCreary continues to struggle in the slot. That won't be lost on Geno Smith, who has spent his first two weeks drawing defenses in with the run and short throws. If the Jets open things up, they'll face very little resistance downfield. Garrett Wilson can win those battles, while Adonai Mitchell and the tight ends can punish an overextended group from sideline to sideline.

Houston at Indianapolis

C.J. Stroud has played relatively well, considering the Texans have opened with a pair of losses. His 627 yards have been largely inflated by game flow, but only so much can be asked of a passer throwing to such a stripped-down group of receivers. Nico Collins, Tank Dell and Jayden Higgins all remain out, leaving a group of intriguing reserves, but reserves nonetheless. Last week, Kayshon Boutte, Jaylin Noel and Xavier Hutchinson combined to turn 19 targets into just 105 inefficient yards. Much of Stroud's Week 2 damage was funneled through Dalton Schultz, who caught 12 passes for 140 yards and stands as one of fantasy's easiest plays to project right now. Schultz is often Stroud's first read off the snap, and sheer volume alone makes him a must-play. The rest of the pecking order is hard to parse, but none of them are needed in fantasy. Stroud and Schultz look poised to post numbers for as long as they're needed to.

Two games in, the Colts seem poised to prove there's much more to building a pass defense than a pair of good cornerbacks. They've committed themselves deeply to Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward on the outside, only to watch both flounder, and Ward then get hurt, through two weeks. Holes remain throughout this secondary, even when both are healthy. Lamar Jackson dazzled in the opener with 324 yards and a touchdown on just 25 attempts, and Patrick Mahomes II posted a vintage 382-yard, three-touchdown night last week. C.J. Stroud may not be quite on their level, but he can find holes beyond those top two cornerbacks. Most of his game will likely center on the short and intermediate zones, plus the occasions when he can escape the pocket and improvise. The Colts don't boast a dominant, edge-bending pass rush to rattle Stroud and keep him planted. Keep an eye on Charvarius Ward, as he did not practice on Wednesday

Tennessee vs. NY Giants

Cam Ward hasn't lit the league on fire in his second season, but he's shown real, measurable growth. This offense still lacks dynamism, but Ward has erased negative plays from his game, so things are clearly slowing down mentally. He's yet to throw an interception in 2026, and has thrown just one interception over his last 11 games. This looks like as strong a week as any for his connection with rookie wideout Carnell Tate to emerge, as he faces a lower-tier set of Giants cornerbacks. Elic Ayomanor continues to make a splash play or two most weeks, and slot receiver Wan'Dale Robinson, who caught 92 passes a season ago as a Giant, will work the slot against the thoroughly beatable Dru Phillips.

The Giants defense followed up an encouraging opening-day showing with a Week 2 dud. They held Dak Prescott and the Cowboys mostly in check at just 5.1 yards per throw, though Dallas did eventually start moving the ball without much trouble. Last week, Matthew Stafford hardly broke a sweat on his way to 327 yards and four touchdowns in a blowout Rams win, and that's bad enough on its own, but consider that Stafford posted that near-perfect game without the services of Puka Nacua. The shoddy secondary had no answers for Davante Adams, who won on every level of the field at age 33, finishing with eight catches for 195 yards and two touchdowns. Cornerbacks Deonte Banks and Greg Newsome II are decent playmakers, but either one can be beaten badly on any given snap, and slot man Dru Phillips is a major liability. The Tennessee air attack doesn't scare anyone, but this group is thoroughly burnable. They may simply lack the speed and quickness to stay with the Titans' young, shifty wideouts underneath and in the intermediate range.

LA Chargers at Buffalo

Justin Herbert and the Chargers have shown little more than faint signs of life to open 2026. They haven't reached 210 passing yards in a game, and everyone involved looks confused. Lacking reliable blocking and a deep threat, Herbert will likely shift soon to a quick-hitting, short-ball approach to beat defenses fast. The Bills tend to bring out shootout vibes even in struggling offenses, and their secondary has attackable spots, with Herbert having his full array of weapons available. Top target Ladd McConkey is back in action, and tight end Oronde Gadsden Jr. remains a mismatch-causing bright spot. Last week, Detroit's Amon-Ra St. Brown and Sam LaPorta worked the middle and underneath for 15 catches, 194 yards, and 3 touchdowns against this same Buffalo defense. If the Chargers can snap out of their slump, this game has real 35-31 potential, and you'll want to be in on Herbert and McConkey at a minimum.

The Buffalo defense looks no tighter than it did fading down the stretch of 2025. After failing to contain Trevor Lawrence and Bo Nix in the playoffs, the team massively overhauled its personnel and coaching, only to open 2026 by getting scorched by both C.J. Stroud (274 yards, two touchdowns) and Jared Goff (327 and four) in shootouts. The revamped pass rush is hitting home, but it's exposing a serious lack of talent in a would-be Super Bowl contender's secondary. Christian Benford has played below his standard, and the team is leaning heavily on names like Max Hairston and Davison Igbinosun for heavy snaps. C.J. Gardner-Johnson and ex-Falcon Dee Alford have struggled mightily in the slot. They've been burned by Amon-Ra St. Brown (nine catches, 142 yards, two scores), Sam LaPorta (six for 52 and a score), and Nico Collins (seven for 75 and a score) to open the year, three very different receivers with three very different skill sets. The Chargers aren't as settled offensively as those teams, but this looks like the perfect week to project a breakout.

Buffalo vs. LA Chargers

Josh Allen has opened 2026 on an absolute tear. Still working with questionable receiving talent, he's thrown five touchdowns against just 20 incompletions on his way to a pair of high-scoring wins. He checks every fantasy box this week: talent, usage, touchdown potential, and plenty of help from his legs. The only real question for Week 3 is which, if any, of his receivers we can trust. DJ Moore produced a 100-yard game in his Bills debut but left Week 2 early and catchless, and may not suit up. Keon Coleman showed real life last week in his place, catching all six of his targets, and could find himself in the No. 1 role against a shaky Chargers cornerback group if he's active, as he did not practice on Wednesday. Of course, the real jewel here is Dalton Kincaid, who seems to get better every year as a seam-stretching weapon. Kincaid has Allen's eye in so many Bills packages that his early lines, five catches for 130 yards, then seven for 95 and a score, feel like his baseline in this matchup. The Chargers, after all, found no answers for Arizona's Trey McBride, who put up nine catches for 95 yards and a touchdown on opening day.

The Chargers' malaise has spread to the defense, which has been rolled over by both Jacoby Brissett and Kirk Cousins to kick off the year. That aging duo completed 70% of its throws for a way-too-easy 530 yards and four touchdowns in relatively easy wins over LA. The Chargers secondary simply hasn't played anywhere near its overachieving 2025 level. They had no answers for McBride in the opener, then fell prey to Tre Tucker (five catches, 119 yards, a score) and a host of mental mistakes last week. The safeties, even Derwin James Jr., have been fully susceptible to both deep balls and sharp in-breaking routes that eat up chunks of yardage. The talent is in place, as 2025 showed. Until the secondary tightens up, though, the team's elite front seven will more or less go to waste. They'll be pushed to the brink again this week trying to contain Josh Allen in the pocket, and James, Tarheeb Still, Cam Hart, and company will be forced to hold downfield coverage longer than usual. We've yet to see any 2026 evidence that they can.


Bottom 5 Passing Matchups

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

More by Devin Knotts

 

Week 3 Rushing Matchups

Devin Knotts

A top-to-bottom ranking of this week's NFL rushing matchups, while providing details on both sides of the ball for the best and the worst pairings.

09/24/26 Read More
 

Cracking FanDuel Week 2

Devin Knotts

Devin Knotts breaks down his Week 2 thoughts while giving you the top cash game plays.

09/19/26 Read More
 

Cracking DraftKings Week 2

Devin Knotts

Devin Knotts breaks down his Week 2 thoughts while giving you the top cash game plays.

09/19/26 Read More
 

Week 2 Rushing Matchups

Devin Knotts

A top-to-bottom ranking of this week's NFL rushing matchups, while providing details on both sides of the ball for the best and the worst pairings.

09/17/26 Read More
 

Week 2 Passing Matchups

Devin Knotts

A top-to-bottom ranking of this week's NFL passing matchups, while providing details on both sides of the ball for the best and the worst pairings.

09/17/26 Read More
 

Top 5 Things We Learned and Overreactions From Week 1

Devin Knotts

Breaking down five things we learned and five things people are overreacting to from Week 1.

09/14/26 Read More